5 ms·
That is a very low bar though, any country still functional enough to run a printing press can make coupon payments. The issue is, if someone lends the US enou
by roenxi 8y ago
That is a very low bar though, any country still functional enough to run a printing press can make coupon payments.
The issue is, if someone lends the US enough money to buy a coffee, it is difficult to see why they believe they are guaranteed to get a coffee+ worth of money back.
The numbers are staggering, the economic growth isn't there. The US has a technological edge and a big army, but at the end of the day it is 'just' a country like all the others. At this point, a reasonable observer could conclude that the political process is locked in to running up debt until the interest can no longer be paid. Neither the Republicans nor Democrats are in a position to improve the numbers.
After the '07-'08 era crisis, it seems a legitimate question to ask why the taxpayer should pay their debts if the financiers seem to get a pass when it all gets too hard for them.
- icelancer 8y ago>> That is a very low bar though, any country still functional enough to run a printing press can make coupon payments. This hasn't happened unless you count QE as printing money to pay debt, which would be a pretty serious twist of logic. >> The issue is, if someone lends the US enough money to buy a coffee, it is difficult to see why they believe they are guaranteed to get a coffee+ worth of money back. >> At this point, a reasonable observer could conclude that the political process is locked in to running up debt until the interest can no longer be paid. Neither the Republicans nor Democrats are in a position to improve the numbers. If you think this is actually true, there is a ton of money to be made on the open markets by securing your position with capital. There's plenty of financial instruments you can leverage to back your position. >> After the '07-'08 era crisis, it seems a legitimate question to ask why the taxpayer should pay their debts if the financiers seem to get a pass when it all gets too hard for them. This is a legitimate criticism but separate from your other claims. QE is protectionist and massively contributes to inequality (in more ways than just income). I am quite critical of the USG and their economic policies. Now I can admit that and also admit that the United States is probably the safest credit risk on the planet, primarily due to the hegemony-driven policies we exert globally. You might argue that this is not for long, but I highly doubt this to be true, and the rest of the world acts as if.
- roenxi 8y ago> This hasn't happened unless you count QE as printing money to pay debt, which would be a pretty serious twist of logic. Credit ratings are forward-looking though. The US's financial position is the worst it has ever been - public debt to GDP is on wartime footing in a long period of peace between major powers. And from my admittedly highly unreliable sources, a number of states aren't in great financial health and there is a pension crisis afoot. The fact that the US is going to hand out the nominal value of its debt is not comforting in light of this. > ... there is a ton of money to be made on the open markets by securing your position with capital That isn't a fair challenge and you know it, there are a lot of ways to lose everything being clever with derivatives even if the macroeconomic assessment is right. Profiting off something isn't the only way to be right about an opinion. > This is a legitimate criticism but separate from your other claims. No it isn't. If the US isn't honoring the capitalist system inside their markets, it is legitimately risky to assume that they will treat foreigners with more respect. There is an argument that they will, but it isn't a sure thing by any stretch. If something does change, by the time everyone admits that it will be far too late for investors. The US is chronically unable to balance its budget. The first thing to give could easily be foreign-owed debt, because foreigners don't vote.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoEverything is relative. Even with all the problems in the US, the world has decided that it is still where they should put most of their trust. Also, having the most powerful military means it can do whatever it needs to keep itself going (not that it necessarily will, but it can, so that adds to the trust).
- intended 8y agoAt nation scale, lending money does not work like buying coffee. ITs an entirely different mechanism. Think of the difference between breaking styrofoam apart and pulling atoms apart.
- throwbacktictac 8y agoThis sounds like an interesting statement. What are the main differences in lending money at nation scale vs. local bank (or payday loan)? We can agree that both lenders are in it to improve their economical/financial stance? Beyond possible political levers, I can't think of how they are that much different.
- hiram112 8y ago> At nation scale, lending money does not work like buying coffee. This seems to be the econ 101 answer all modern day Chicago - school influenced economists give out. Student: if the US has a debt that's more than their current GDP, isn't that bad? If a family had a credit card debt higher than their current salary, we'd say that they were in bad financial shape. Economist: The macroeconomics of a nation work much differently than a single family's budget. Student: Well, when the family has no plans to cut expenses, continues to charge more and more each year on the credit card, and their solution involves some vague plan of getting a huge raise sometime in the future, how does this not end in disaster for the family, but turn out fine for a government doing the same thing. Economist: Running deficits and borrowing money in perpetuity is good for a large country to do, just not for an individual. It is known. Student: well eventually the family's interest payments will be more than they actually make, leaving nothing left for actual expenses. At that point, their card is canceled and they have to sell all their stuff, move out of their home, and crash with the parents. And nobody lends to them again for a long time, and only at high rates. How does a nation avoid this outcome when the math is the same? Economist: Trust us <waves Jedi hand>. I get the feeling we're going to someday look at today's accepted macroeconomic theories, and wonder just WTF we we're thinking.
- diffeomorphism 8y ago> Student: How does a nation avoid this outcome when the math is the same? Economist: As I have told you multiple times by now, it isn't. That is what we taught you in first year. You can't simply arbitrarily scale up models from lemonade stand to international trade. Things are not all linear, simplifications in one model are simply not valid in another model. Arguments like these always strike me as similar to "if evolution, then why are there still monkeys". Maybe you are right, everything is really simple and everybody else has been too stupid to see it. Or maybe people are right when they tell you that you don't quite understand what you are talking about.
- pjc50 8y ago> any country still functional enough to run a printing press can make coupon payments Only on bonds in their own currency! Argentina would be in a much better position if they could print dollars. > 'just' a country like all the others For this to be a problem the US has to fail in a way that doesn't bring the rest of the developed world down too
- BenoitEssiambre 8y agoThe assumption that savings must always have positive real returns, is one of the most weirdly persistent fallacy in economic debates. Historically, negative real returns on stores of value were the norm. Before financial systems existed, almost all investments had negative returns if you didn’t put work and energy into them. To store value, you had to accumulate stuff, buildings or land. Most options either had high maintenance costs, were subject to risk of damage from natural causes and theft, were very volatile or required hard labor to get production out of. Even in societies with financial systems, getting low risk, hassle free, liquid, positive real returns has been difficult for a large part of history. This just reflects the natural laws of thermodynamics that tell us that everything tends to decay without a constant supply of work and energy. In general, most things require maintenance to keep their worth. The 20th century was probably the most notable exception. Because of unprecedented demographic and technological growth, positive risk free real returns were easy to find. The effect of recency on our collective minds probably explains some of the confusion people have about this. It is possible that under favorable conditions, wealth can have positive returns and even compound into very good long run returns but it is not a guarantee and there is nothing natural about it. It may not continue forever, particularly amidst an aging and retiring population in a world no longer as rich in easy to exploit natural resources. While people are used to get negative returns on very short term purchases, you buy fresh vegetables at the supermarket, even if they degrade over time, many can’t seem to accept the normalcy of negative returns on longer term assets. In nature, squirrels’ nut caches have a certain percentage of losses from theft and spoilage. Real returns tending towards the negative is natural even if they can seem unusual for people just out of the 20th century. There are good reasons to keep government debt low enough but long term possibility of repayment is not a huge worry when market real interest rates and safe asset returns are very low or negative. In the latter case, you can just wait and let the real debt evaporate through inflation.