4 ms·
It's interesting that the root cause is attributed to education and not living near a mission. That is live near a mission and end up 10% more educated. Be 10%
by chiefalchemist 8y ago
It's interesting that the root cause is attributed to education and not living near a mission. That is live near a mission and end up 10% more educated. Be 10% more educated and earn 10% more.
If A leads to B, and B to C, isn't A ultimately the cause of C?
- sabas123 8y ago> If A leads to B, and B to C, isn't A ultimately the cause of C? Only if the mappings hold for every element, ie every A has to lead to B and every B has to lead to C before you can conclude that A causes B
- jlawson 8y agoNot really, causation doesn't have to be 100%. Example: Getting shot causes holes in your lungs. Holes in your lungs cause you to die. Therefore, getting shot causes you to die. All the above, including the inference in the last sentence, are valid statements, even though they don't hold true in 100% of cases. Answer to grandparent's question is: Yes, if A->B->C, then A->C. Just make sure those casuative arrows actually exist before you make this deduction.
- giovannibonetti 8y agoI think that is a bad example because there are multiple ways to die from getting shot. So, even though there is not 100% chance that you die from holes in your lungs, there is a pretty high chance that you will die from any complication.
- ComputerGuru 8y agoNo, and your example is perfect. Getting shot can end up NOT leading to B (and then not leading to C). Get shot in the leg and live. No B means you can’t assume C.
- jlawson 8y agoYou're right. But in natural language, statements about causation don't have to be 100 percent guaranteed to be valid. Otherwise there's very little you could really say about the world. Consider: "smoking causes cancer." According to you, this would be false.
- Nomentatus 8y agoSee John Stuart Mill on causation. There's no such thing as singular causation.
- shinryuu 8y agoIn the article they also mention that there were missions made by franciskaner who focused more on poverty and health. There was no such correlation of being more educated and earning more when living close such a mission. So education seems to be the core benefit here. Not just living close to a mission.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoThen should the study then take it's hypothesis / theory elsewhere and see if it applies where edu was increased and there were no missions? Without that level of proof, the conclusion is premature. Or as I already mentioned, the core stimulus wrong.
- nazgul17 8y agoIt's not easy to find another situation where no other confounding effects were present. As explained in the article, the scholar brings good arguments as to why this is as close as it gets to a randomised trial.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI didn't say it was easy :) But that's still no excuse to say B leads to C when in fact, it (probably) does not. Science isn't supposed to be easy. Truth isn't supposed to be easy. If it's easy, then there's a fair chance it's not either one of these.
- ineedasername 8y agoWhy would you say it probably does not? Aren't you falling into the same lack of evidence trap you claim is present here? As an aside, this conclusion is bolstered by research into factors influencing student outcomes in modern time: Even controlling for socioeconomic factors, students from more educated families and peer groups tend to complete higher levels of education, and thus perpetuate that cycle with their own children later in life. That's the same cycle being observed in this article. There may be other confounding factors that were the cause here, so further examples would be enlightening, but as it is this is a result that fits very well within the existing body of knowledge regarding factors that influence educational outcomes.
- lkrubner 8y agoThis thesis works with even more power in Europe. From 1517 to the 1550s, Protestantism spread rapidly. It's spread stopped when the Jesuits began to build their schools. In every city where the Jesuits opened a school, the advance of Protestantism was quickly stopped. Its often said that the Jesuits were the foot soldiers of the Counter-Reformation, but specifically, it was their schools that were the main thing. And the schools helped make each city wealthy, where the schools were.
- hedvig 8y agoCan anyone elaborate - did Protestants not value intelligence or learning as much as the Jesuits?
- Misdicorl 8y agoMy understanding is that Jesuit schools were indeed noteworthy/novel in their time/place
- alehul 8y agoI'm not sure of the Protestant's focus or lack thereof, but many popular colleges in the U.S. are Jesuit universities: Boston College, Georgetown, and Fordham, for instance.
- lkrubner 8y agoI believe the Protestants simply lacked the institutional wealth to set up these schools. Wealthy Protestant institutions don't appear till the late 1600s. In the 1500s the Protestant factions celebrated thrift, at least relative to the Catholic faith. Likewise with the Gregorian calendar, introduced in October 1582. The Protestants simply lacked the institutional strength to pull off so important a reform.