3 ms·
Probably will be radically oversubscribed in order for the economics to work, and will be a shittier service than a properly implemented vdsl2, g.fast or docsis
by walrus01 8y ago
Probably will be radically oversubscribed in order for the economics to work, and will be a shittier service than a properly implemented vdsl2, g.fast or docsis3/3.1 last mile (nevermind gigabit class gpon or active Ethernet ftth), but significantly better than small geostationary service vsat. And will be higher latency and with worse GB/mo bandwidth quotas compared to a modern technology WISP for last mile.
A lot of the technology press has misunderstood the most desirable applications and locations for it. People think that it's going to compete for a residential internet service in a suburb of a city like Portland, or Sacramento, or Denver. If you can get 300 megabit per second DOCSIS3 service in one of those locations, that would be drastically better. where it is going to be a game-changer is all of the locations that are right now dependent on highly oversubscribed geostationary small vsat services, and extremely rural areas where there isn't even a single last-mile terrestrial Wireless ISP. and for ships in the middle of the ocean, if the gigabyte per dollar cost is significantly less than inmarsat or other options.
- shaklee3 8y agoI think I understand what you are saying, but I'm confused at this comment compared to your others. If you believe, as I do, that the user terminal is going to be extremely expensive, how will that compete with the current small vsat terminals? I agree that the service could be better in theory, but at the same time, existing satellite internet service also could be better by taking on fewer customers and not being as congested. But that's a cost trade-off. And in this case, I believe SpaceX has a higher cost per customer to recoup, so it seems in their best interest to also be congested to increase revenue.
- walrus01 8y agoI think that there is a good chance the terminal will be expensive, but the cost hidden or eaten by spacex to gain market share. Building a phased array thing with sufficient gain that can track two LEO satellites can't be cheap. But maybe their terminal hardware engineers have come up with something truly revolutionary, and we will all be surprised. I am hoping but skeptical that it could have similar hardware costs to a viasat small ka-band vsat terminal, in the range of $800-900 for rooftop equipment + modem.