7 ms·
> Critically, using the persistent location API also allows us to use an acknowledged acceptable way to capture when our users have active screen time. They're
by CharlesW 8y ago
> Critically, using the persistent location API also allows us to use an acknowledged acceptable way to capture when our users have active screen time.
They're admitting to using background location to infer screen time, which is clearly "misuse" according to section 2.5.4. Whether the decision is right or wrong, I find it hard to believe that the developer is actually confused by this.
- jasonlotito 8y ago> They're admitting to using background location to infer screen time They use it for location data to display where you are using your phone. They also use that location data to infer other things as well. Your comment makes it seem like they aren't using it for location data at all.
- TimTheTinker 8y agoIt looks like they’re using the location API for both (1) screen time inference and (2) screen time and location correlation; and they’re using (2) to justify use of location while ignoring that (1) violates Apple’s TOS. I agree that users ought to be able to use the app without granting access to location data (opting out of #2). But unfortunately, if Apple provides no way of inferring screen time without use of location, this category of app is impossible.
- laohu 8y ago#1 Does not violate TOS. At least the rep spoken to said it does not. It is permitted to apps to known when the screen is on / screen off, via the built-in notification it provides.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TimTheTinker 8y agoPasting section 2.5.4 here: Multitasking apps may only use background services for their intended purposes: VoIP, audio playback, location, task completion, local notifications, etc. If your app uses location background mode, include a reminder that doing so may dramatically decrease battery life. Screen time inference is clearly not an intended purpose for location, since the actual location data obtained has no connection to it (i.e. to #1 above; note we're interpreting "purpose" from the user's perspective). It sounds like the rep is misinformed, or that the TOS needs to be updated with an explicit exception.
- jwildeboer 8y agoThe „etc“ is the word that turns a seemingly clear rule into an interpretation battle. Etc here could allow almost everything or nothing. Depending on what argument you want to push. Ultimately it’s Apple‘s walled garden and they have the final say.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoIn your app configuration, you register your app as needing background capabilities for one or more specific “intended purposes”, and screen time recording isn’t one of them. So I don’t think the wording is actually unclear.
- GavinMcG 8y agoNo, it really doesn't. "Etc." just includes other services. But it's unambiguous that whatever the service, it must be used for its own sake.
- aaaaaaaaaab 8y ago>It is permitted to apps to known when the screen is on / screen off, via the built-in notification it provides. [citation needed]
- laohu 8y agoUnfortunately, this is from a phone call with Apple. Supposedly why there are multiple other apps currently in the store, accepted by apple, the do precisely the same approach for reporting phone use.
- rando444 8y agoThe app has a feature that allows you to see where you are spending your time on your phone. This could be helpful to get an idea about time wasted at work vs. commuting by train or whatever. I'm not going to say it's super useful, but it has a use.. I would categorize this in the same bucket as Snapchat needing your GPS. Anyway, the complaint is that they are using this data for more than features and functionality. Their side of the story leads me to believe this is not the case, and only Apple knows why they think this company is abusing the data they are collecting.
- tptacek 8y agoYou can almost always make that claim about any sneaky use of a platform feature. The test that will be used to determine compliance is whether the intended, expected use of the feature complies, not with whether there are any compliant uses.
- privateSFacct 8y agoExactly this. App developers are constantly saying, I need all your location data for one tiny sliver of a reason or another. If you are a map app, location data is fine. If you are tracking screen time, then no. Apple's is targeting folks like my parents here. They love that apple just works, no crazy secret battery drains etc. Even the subtle prompts apple gives (the little arrow outline etc) is NOT ENOUGH for folks like my parents. It needs to follow logically from what they are doing (no buried menus / advanced features). Apple largely delivers on this. Check out an older person using an android phone with a total ton of apps (and android 3-5 years old, older folks upgrade MUCH more slowly). It's a honking mess. Seriously the battery life goes into the trash, the phone has got a billion things running on it. Apple is making BIG money focusing pretty strictly on privacy. The idea that they are doing this to avoid competitors to screen time (which they make no extra money on) is ludicrous.
- xvector 8y ago> Anyway, the complaint is that they are using this data for more than features and functionality. Incorrect. The complaint is that they are not using Location for its intended purpose, thereby impacting the performance (battery life) of the device. Quoted in the article: > Performance – 2.5.4 > Your app is misusing background location for purposes other than location-related features and functionality. The key word here is location-related features and functionality. Not "features and functionality" in general, as your comment implies. I don't think it could be any more clear-cut. "Screen time" is just about the least "location-related feature/functionality" that one could think of. It's pretty clear that they are violating the terms of service, regardless of the benefit that this feature may or may not provide.
- gnicholas 8y agoThey use the API to determine both location and device usage. I have to wonder whether RescueTime included the mapping feature (to see where you're using your iPhone) just to satisfy this requirement. But in the absence of evidence that this feature was included as a pretext, what should happen? It would seem fair to require that the "primary purpose" of an API's usage be for the intended purpose of that API. But no such rule exists in Apple's guidelines, AFAIK. Instead, we're just left with the overarching principle that Apple can interpret its rules however it wants. As someone who's been on the receiving end of this principle, I have to say I'm not a fan.
- syshum 8y agoOnce Again, Apple telling users how they are allowed to use the devices they supposedly bought not rented from apple...
- Improvotter 8y agoI'm glad the restriction is put in place. There were too many apps abusing constant location tracking. If one kid in the kindergarten cannot handle the responsibility, unfortunately all of the little kids have to suffer from it. Same goes with GDPR and net neutrality, regardless whether it's the government or a trillion dollar company.
- syshum 8y ago>>>If one kid in the kindergarten cannot handle the responsibility, unfortunately all of the little kids have to suffer from it. So you are claiming that most Apple users have the same mental capacity and personal responsibility of a Kindergarten age child?
- Heliosmaster 8y agoNot the users, but the developers. They are the one which were unable to be responsible about permissions.
- syshum 8y agoIf a app seeks permissions to things you do not want it to have you then have the option to not install it. I do this all the time with many apps. It is up to the USER not apple to choose what software to install and run on their computing devices. Protecting people from themselves is what parents do, so clearly you look to Apple to be some kind of Parent protecting you from being unable to read the permission screen and think "do I want this app to have these permissions" I would not have a huge issue with this if apple has methods to side load, or use 3rd party app stores in addition to the "offical" one, but if you are going to prevent anyway for a person to install apps outside of the official store then you better be pretty open about the apps you take. Apples assault on personal freedom and choice is my biggest problem from their App store policies to their war on repair. Apple believes it should have full authority over the devices they sell, if they want that they should RENT them not sell them for $1,000
- mcfedr 8y agoRight or wrong - it's one of the only was to implement this at the moment and apple are trying to kill the competition. I develop an app that does similar features, we are currently still in the store but apple won't let us release any updates for 3-4 months now. They keep saying rubbish like this but at the end of the day they don't want competition for this own apps.
- svarrall 8y agoThis seems pretty clear. They’re giving you a heads up that in a future iOS version you won’t be able to get awake/pickup information whilst using the background location api.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoAs others have pointed out, this makes no sense. Apple allows tons of apps in categories that compete with theirs. How many calendar or email or stock tracker apps are there? They make no money from Screen Time, whereas they do make money from apps sold in the App Store. If they do kill this category of app, I’d say there’s a 99% chance it’s either for technical (for example battery drain) or more likely, privacy reasons.
- Angostura 8y agoDo you explicitly get the user to consent to the use if background location data for this purpose?