3 ms·
They don't look the same; you can make an argument they look similar though. "Fabian and Florian turned Hacker News into an interactive visualization. The soci
by Fnoord 8y ago
They don't look the same; you can make an argument they look similar though.
"Fabian and Florian turned Hacker News into an interactive visualization. The social media site is a news aggregator, focusing on computer science and information technology. Its design is bare-bones but it has complex functionality for voting and discussions. Fabian and Florian have taken the existing structure and turned it into a typographic space of timelines and networks. The visual presentation is based on the sequence and connections of news and comments. They also connected their design to the API of Hacker News, so you can actually use it to read the site. View the redesign of Hacker News."
And the redesign is a usability nightmare. You cannot easily skip a topic you're not interested in, and you cannot even skip the comments easily which are emphasized. In normal HN, you can browse news.ycombinator.com and click on the links from there. You can open the original links and the HN discussions in tabs. Not in this redesign. Perhaps it is God's greatest gift on mobile (I tried it on desktop), I don't know. Examples of doing it different should be objectively better; this one doesn't appear to be such an example, so don't mention it [1]. Instead, go back to the drawing board.
[1] There's also a bug that clicking on No. and Pts. gets you to that user's hompeage. Which could be 1 or 76, but it has nothing to do with that userID.
- lasagnaphil 8y agoI’ve tried it on mobile. (iPhone 8) The whole thing takes more than five seconds to load, and the UI is basically unusuable. Tried clicking at an article, comment text is almost impossible to read due to the broken layout.