3 ms·
There are lot of confounding factors. It is not certain it has worked even once. All we know is a few patients that have been on MP has survived. But so hav a f
by vidarh 8y ago
There are lot of confounding factors. It is not certain it has worked even once. All we know is a few patients that have been on MP has survived. But so hav a few patients that have not been on MP, and most patients on MP have died, as have several of the "successful" MP patients subsequent to overcoming the initial stage of the disease.
A further problem is that many of the patients have had the PEP treatment partially or wholly first. In those cases we don't know if the outcome was due to MP or PEP. Several other (single digit numbers) patients have survived without MP. It is not clear why. It's not clear that their treatments had any effect. Or it might have saved them. It may be genetics. It may be difference in virulence. It may be specific aspect of the treatments. It may be aspects of how the patients are treated that are not part of the protocol itself. It may be dumb luck.
The problem is that this is not a matter of MP or nothing. It's a matter of MP or trying to find other alternatives. If MP serves no purpose in saving these patients - and it may very well not - then focusing on MP may hinder exploration of other options.