4 ms·
A closer example would be books. For ~500 years, books look approximately the same: normally paged sideways (not top-down), with some margins for handling, wit
by nine_k 8y ago
A closer example would be books.
For ~500 years, books look approximately the same: normally paged sideways (not top-down), with some margins for handling, with text in rows or columns (depending on the writing system), some chapter structure, and index / contents page, page numbers, covers of more durable material to protect the pages, with some kind of a title on the top cover, etc.
Those features don't just exist because of tradition or technical limitations. They mostly exist because they are convenient, useful, and logical.
But they also exist because people expect them, from times of handwritten books. They put the skills people already had to good use. They created a visual language which is easy to pick up and easy to use, both for readers and typesetters.
Most web sites are a logical continuation of books, magazines, newspapers, etc. No wonder they actively adopt the time-proven, well-working concepts from the print media.
Forms have a much shorter, and much less rich history outside web, and here experimentation was wild; a lot of sites do forms quite differently. Though some common language (like labels, placeholder text, pre-validation, etc) already has formed. OTOH even checkboxes are not yet a commonly accepted visual concept; some e.g. prefer "switches", iOS-style.
- justrebooted 8y agoFor books the content is the most important. It's a little different from websites where content isn't always the focus.
- mrob 8y agoFull justified text exists because of tradition. It makes the text harder to read because the word spacing becomes uneven, the line ends become harder to distinguish, and more words are broken by hyphens. But it's higher status because when all books were hand-written it took more skill to produce. Web sites have a similar popular anti-feature that's included for reasons of social status: low contrast text. I think this is popular because ability to easily read it signals both health (good eyes) and wealth (good screens).
- nine_k 8y agoI don't see why is this downvoted. This is quite valid. Fortunately extensions like Stylus allow to tweak page styles to make them more usable.
- mdpopescu 8y agoHuh. I always thought non-justified text existed because people are lazy; I absolutely consider fully justified text to be easier to read, not harder. Non-justified text is distracting.
- bunderbunder 8y agoI'm sure it varies from person to person. I believe, though, the bulk of the studies have found that, while people generally find justified text to look nicer, reading speed and comprehension tend to suffer for it.
- xapata 8y agoSame for contrast. If you're not actually trying to read, low-contrast is more appealing. Thus, the CEO who has read their marketing blurb a thousand times likes low-contrast, even though it's counter-productive.
- chiefalchemist 8y ago> "I think this is popular because ability to easily read it signals both health (good eyes) and wealth (good screens)." Perhaps. But I always presumed the good eyes, good screen, and lack of empathy belonged to the designer. These same site too often seem to have experiences based on an ultra-fast connection, as opposed to a wonky 4G (at best) connection. You might be right. But I've sat in meetings and/or shared office space with low-UX-IQ designer / frontend types.
- discreteevent 8y agoI think the low contrast thing is simply a symptom of a general trend twoards form over function, which though it may seem cool, in the end turns out to be cheap. Its the equivalent of putting dark plastic tint on your car windows. It happens in a lot of fields. The truth is most people don't know what they are doing (and we all didn't know what we were doing at one point).
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y ago> Full justified text exists because of tradition. It makes the text harder to read because the word spacing becomes uneven That should barely be the case with a good layout and hyphenation algorithm (or a competent printer in the old days). What word processing software does is not necessarily the best possible way to produce an even justified layout.
- r00dY 8y ago> Most web sites are a logical continuation of books, magazines, newspapers, etc. No wonder they actively adopt the time-proven, well-working concepts from the print media. True, but print media formats got even more simplified in web. The reason? Responsiveness constraints. Many times I've seen great advanced "article-like" designs for desktop from ambitious designers. It turned out that making them easy to manage in CMS, stable in all possible combinations (or implementing good validators) and at the same time logical and good looking on mobile was extremely hard and not worth it. This led to further simplifications... ... and then Medium looks like Medium. There's not much place for creativity on mobile. And this is where most of the "fast content" is read.
- blancheneige 8y ago> For ~500 years, books look approximately the same I think you can even go back as far as 1000 years to find those same standards. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carolingian_minuscule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carolingian_minuscule
- cabalamat 8y ago> They mostly exist because they are convenient, useful, and logical. What happens, when, in the words of the article, you "Do not be constrained by questions of usability, legibility, and flexibility"? The answer, it appears, is their re-design of HN: https://interface.fh-potsdam.de/future-retro/HN/ https://interface.fh-potsdam.de/future-retro/HN/ which I find unusable.
- zipwitch 8y agoThe pure white screen has a certain aesthetic appeal, but the total lack of content puts it considerably below the original. (I assume this must be an intended effect, given the complete absence of error messages.)
- rytill 8y agoActually wouldn't be terrible if the comments appeared in a more orderly fashion. Right now, they spawn randomly and can even overlap which makes it actually unreadable.
- Retric 8y agoThat's shockingly bad. The expanded view with lines between comments and their parents which scroll independently is literally the worst website UI I have ever seen. And I recall some terrible flash abominations.
- greenhatman 8y agoThat was a pretty hilarious experience.
- smhost 8y agothe day/night button on the bottom right is genius satire
- singingboyo 8y agoThe medium redesign is also awful. Its inability to handle my portrait-oriented monitor did trigger a sense of childish amusement (truncating POOR to POO) but it's entirely impossible to read anything using it.
- dingaling 8y agoYet most books have awful spines that prevent the pages lying flat when open. Not because it's useful or logical but because it's cheap and easy for the publisher.