4 ms·
Never mind the "new nuclear age" clickbait. It's considerably out of date, of course. It's said that generals often fight the last war, not the present war. Th
by OliverJones 8y ago
Never mind the "new nuclear age" clickbait. It's considerably out of date, of course. It's said that generals often fight the last war, not the present war. Theology departments (like this one at Notre Dame University) typically fight the war before last. The headline writer for this article, well, yeah, theologian writing for church people. Ignore the silly headline.
But read the article. Our trade is strongly influenced by Rene Girard's understanding of competitive mimetic desire and its violence. Why? The people who organize the ad-driven internet know all about Girard. Peter Thiel invested in FB because he saw its potential for harnessing mimetic desire to drive engagement. (reference: https://www.lrb.co.uk/v39/n16/john-lanchester/you-are-the-product https://www.lrb.co.uk/v39/n16/john-lanchester/you-are-the-pr...) FB-style social media is addictive precisely because of the fear of not being as good as "friends." Mimetic desire is the the human yearning behind the Fear of Missing Out. Driving engagement is most effective when it exploits that fear. It works very well indeed.
Other attempts at building social media networks (Stack Overflow, Linked In, Slack, for example) try to avoid that exploitation. They try to use other motivators than FOMO to drive engagement. Can they be successful without overusing mimetic desire? It's the key question they must answer to be successful.
The obligatory panel of customer logos just below the fold on SaaS landing pages engages mimetic desire in IT buyers. "Wow! Schwab uses this! I want to be like Schwab!" It's benign in these cases.
Girard offers a good unifying framework for understanding the human nature behind all sorts of marketing work. Convincing people their hair is ablaze and offering them ways to put it out is the heart of building new businesses. Getting people to set each others' hair on fire, then putting it out, is the holy grail of new businesses.
It's no accident that Silicon Valley employs that framework in lots of ways: he was a scholar at Stanford's Hoover Institution. It can be a hard slog to learn about him. But it's worth your trouble.
- mothsonasloth 8y agoLinkedIn is going the way of Facebook StackOverflow uses badges and fake internet points as the mechanism to encourage usage. Not sure what Slacks pulling factor is
- ams6110 8y ago> Not sure what Slack's pulling factor is Initially, it was better than alternatives. So the draw was that it actually did something useful. Now, it's where everybody is, so FOMO is a big part of it now. I've never used Slack, so it's just my hunch.
- OliverJones 8y agoSlack's pull factor? My boss told me to use it. And, it's better than email for workplace communication. Stack Overflow's? In my case, reciprocal altruism. I get a TON of benefit from it, so I like to contribute to it. Y-Combinator's? I'm not sure, but here I am using it.
- lurcio 8y agoY-comb for me is "broadcatch" (Kevin Kelly?) over a range of side-interests (tech, science)
- pqs 8y agoWhich book do you recommend to start reading Girard?
- OliverJones 8y agoThe Girard books I've read are REALLY tough slogging, and they are focused on interpreting the content of the Hebrew Bible and the Christian Gospels. That's why I'm looking forward to the biography in this article; maybe it will be more accessible. But, you asked a question. Try The Scapegoat http://www.worldcat.org/title/scapegoat/oclc/13124168 http://www.worldcat.org/title/scapegoat/oclc/13124168 or Things Hidden From the Foundation of the World. http://www.worldcat.org/title/things-hidden-since-the-foundation-of-the-world/oclc/1001640426 http://www.worldcat.org/title/things-hidden-since-the-founda... It's radical theology but well-worked-out anthropology.
- pqs 8y agoThanks! :-)