5 ms·
This company sees the intermittent nature of renewables as a the primary problem, but that's thinking left over from the last century, a century where you could
by epistasis 8y ago
This company sees the intermittent nature of renewables as a the primary problem, but that's thinking left over from the last century, a century where you couldn't make the demand responsive to the supply. That's going to change; the biggest amounts of home load will be heating/cooling of air for the home and water heating. Both of these will be demand responsive. And as cars electrify, that's another huge amount of load that will be responsive. The only thing left is the business model to pay consumers to charge/heat/cool at the right time. We don't even need that many additional batteries because thermal storage is cheap, and an electric car will store 2-3 days of electricity usage, and most people come nowhere close to needing a full 60 kWh of electric driving every day. Those that do will use it, but those that can be more responsive to when they charge will get paid for it.
In the 20th century storage was super expensive, and large precise construction was inexpensive; that's being flipped. In five years, solar plus enough lithium ion storage (or other tech) will be cheaper than the cheapest nuclear. In 10-15, winter levels of sunlight + storage will be cheaper than the cheapest nuclear. They're trying to address the problems of toady, in 20 years. If their development pipeline is 20 years out, they need to anticipate the problems 20 years out, rather than skating to where the puck is now.
The problem has changed; there will be niche needs for nuclear power, I'm sure, but unless they can drive down current nuclear costs to be cheaper than wind or solar, there's going to be little need for nuclear at all.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> That's going to change; the biggest amounts of home load will be heating/cooling of air for the home and water heating. Both of these will be demand responsive. You can use time of day pricing to get people to do their laundry at a better time. You can't use it to get people to heat their homes during the day instead of at night. Once people are no longer burning oil for heat, there is going to be a winter month where the average nighttime temperature in the northern half of the country is -4 degrees and that is going to drive high non-responsive demand for electricity at night. In theory you can install enough batteries for this and charge them with solar during the day, but what happens when it's cloudy during the day and cold at night for a straight month?
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoAdd wind, wave and hydro to the mix, including pumped hydro for storage and demand response. Start installing ground and water source heat pump community heating that's powered from wind and solar during times of excess. Combined with adequate insulation it becomes remarkably easy to heat and power even in northern climes almost for free. Allow the local electric co to smart-manage the home and EV batteries as part of the grid, subject to personal constraints of when you need 100% EV battery etc. Some places are already there with excess power from renewables every year. We just need the will to scale up.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoHydro works great where you have an appropriate location for it, but most of the appropriate locations already have it. It doesn't scale. Insulation is great for new construction but cost prohibitive for existing structures -- the new codes require 2x6 construction instead of 2x4 to leave more room for insulation, but you can hardly change that for a hundred million existing structures that aren't going anywhere. Wind and wave aren't diversification because waves are caused by wind, so a still night is still for both. Community heating from wind and solar doesn't provide any efficiency improvement without a cold sink that many areas won't have -- or something that generates waste heat, like nuclear. (Using waste heat from a steam turbine as the cold sink for a heat pump for community heating would be extremely efficient.) Energy storage and time-based pricing is great for handling the high demand low sunlight period in the early evening. You still need something for baseload.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoIt's all doable. Quite easily and without bankrupting everyone. Heating from ground and water source heat provides a thoroughly well documented 4 to 6 fold increase in efficiency and still works even when the sea or ground is only at a small differential and the absolute temperature is single digits above freezing. You don't need a handy nuclear plant or gobs of geo-thermal like Iceland. You power the pump and heat exchangers from spare renewable capacity, the heat comes from the ground, sea or river. It works well enough in the Nordic countries and N Scotland (Orkney) to be fairly popular. Of course they benefit from going a bit deeper with ground source which further encourages community over individual installations, but sea works surprisingly well even at those latitudes. Fully becalmed is pretty rare for much of the planet even when onshore is still. There is often wind a little offshore and the waves can result from winds pretty far offshore. Not forgetting tidal and pressure contributions. Sure, some areas will be less suited to wave or tidal than others, just as the UK is far better served by wind than solar. Though solar is still effective enough to be worth installing. Install the right mix for local geography and climate, balance with the national or regional grid. You're right that pumped hydro is particularly constrained by suitable geography, but there's plenty of spots it could be added to the grid still, just not in Florida, Kansas or The Netherlands. :) Insulation isn't so hard either if you promote insulation for existing structures or apply judicious subsidy. New build should, of course, be better and we're a long way from achieving the insulation standards of Nordic countries. UK for instance had a decade of promoting and requiring the energy companies to provide subsidised installation of roof and wall insulation. It was remarkably popular, and pretty damn effective. Not all buildings were suitable of course, but start with the easier ones to get an 80% fix, then worry about the difficult sites and edge cases for the next steps.
- Gibbon1 8y agoOne thing I'd like to see is how much night time demand based on simple arbitrage. And how much of that demand will disappear if the rate structure makes night time power expensive.
- pl-94 8y agoWe are really far from solving the storage issue. And no nuclear is far from being cheaper than solar + lithium (except maybe in very specific area such as Chili with high sunlight and high cost of nuclear). There are not enough Lithium on Earth anyway to answer large scale energy storing. Using vehicle battery is a naive way to think about it. Your car battery cycle is not appropriate (and will surely not be) to house consumption: as a result you will just crash your battery life expectancy. The only advancement for large scale is fly wheel storage. But the record is only 40 MWh for a duration of 4 hours. Waw. Not even close. The point of the nuclear is namely to think that 4th generation nuclear power plant are a way to reduce nuclear fossils cost to zero. Zero because many countries recycled their nuclear waste (if France is using 4th generation, they will not need to buy uranium before 10000 years). And Russia succeeded to make work a 650 MW 4th generation power plant. Governments have paid large subsidies (140 billions in 15 years in France) for renewable energy. But in most cases, it resulted in a few percent of energy consumption - and it will not be much more in next years. If we want to solve global warming today, thats just not a working solution. The only solution is to enhance nuclear powering.
- danans 8y ago> The only advancement for large scale is fly wheel storage. But the record is only 40 MWh for a duration of 4 hours. Waw. Not even close. Flow batteries have already reached 60 MWh storage, and their capacity scales linearly with the volume of electrolytes, so it's effectively unlimited, unlike flywheels, which can only get so massive before their mechanical systems would fail. They also have extremely fast response times, and unlike Lithium Ion batteries, are capable of charging to 100% and total depletion to 0% without damage to the battery. Therefore they are already being deployed in grid-scale renewable energy applications to smooth out supply and demand. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanadium_redox_battery#Largest_vanadium_grid_batteries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanadium_redox_battery#Largest... The only thing they don't do well at is energy density, but for grid storage applications, that's not an issue.
- ryacko 8y agoThere is mechanical and thermal storage. Molten salt storage has been used several times in recent designs but it isn’t popular. For mechanical storage, pumping water could be more viable than fly wheels.
- nickik 8y agoI'm always amazed by how 100% sure 'renewables' people are that progress in renewables is absolutely 100% assumed but progress in nulcear technology is somehow almost impossible. Nuclear is now trying to solve the problem 20 years away. If we had a mass producible MSR we have practically unlimited fuel and we can mas produce the power plant. Lets remember that nuclear is still the largest source of carbon free energy and by many calculations, the amount invested solar/wind/batteries in renewables could already have solved the carbon issue (Germany being the example). Furthermore we actually have prove that the nuclear solution works. France went to almost 0 carbon energy 30-40 years ago. While Germany and its fight for renewables is the biggest polluter in Europe and after absurd amounts of investments in renewables they have only just replaced nuclear, added lots of infrastructure investment and by their own plans it will take many, many more years of massive state investment to even have chance to run Germany on renewables. If Germany had done a France/South Korea style program they could be carbon free now already (or at the least well on its way) and in 20 years. And that is with 1970 tech, not even considering GenIV.
- epistasis 8y agoLet's assume that progress picks up after many many many years of stagnant research. What are the directions that can improve construction costs for nuclear? The reason that they went to massive huge scales in the first place was cost, because giant steam turbines work better on bigger scales. Lets assume that the thermal energy could be taken completely free, without any cost to get it. This is the best case possible situation of improvements in advancing nuclear technology. In that scenario, thermal energy still needs to be converted to electricity. And then we're in the situation of geothermal, or solar thermal, and we're in a situation where we are at one of the most optimized engineering areas that's ever been explored, and where our skills have plateaued. I'm not even sure if massively improved costs on materials will improve that area much. Natural gas is winning among thermally-related tech because of combined cycle technology, where you get energy through two different ways. I don't see how thermal plants alone can compete with the cost trajectory of solar and wind. I mean, I could be wrong, I'm not "100% sure" as you strawman me. But the chances that nuclear can 1) make the thermal generation part super cheap, and 2) make the thermal to electric conversion cheaper, or 3) come out of left field with some sort of direct energy conversion or whatever, are just such loooooong bets that when someone makes them I'm guessing they're just being a contrarian, or just haven't paid attention to the field in a long long time. I'd not sure which camp to put Myhrvold in, since he invested a while back it could be either or neither or just one.
- jasonkester 8y agoan electric car will store 2-3 days of electricity usage What percentage of people have their car at their house during the time the sun is providing most of its power? On a weekday, most people drive them to work for the day.