You're right, the new rule doesn't filter out dishonest discoveries, only incidental ones (which may be dishonest). If you wanted to show benefit from an incid

You're right, the new rule doesn't filter out dishonest discoveries, only incidental ones (which may be dishonest). If you wanted to show benefit from an incidental discovery, you would have to run another study with that as its declared objective. The author is kind of doing the same thing here that they accuse others of doing...