4 ms·
The positive aspect of banning alcohol consumption is that it's an objective measure. If somebody is a drunken lout pawing his employees, save the victim more e
by Spooky23 8y ago
The positive aspect of banning alcohol consumption is that it's an objective measure. If somebody is a drunken lout pawing his employees, save the victim more exposure by drumming him out for the alcohol.
With the possible exception of salespeople entertaining clients, there's no need to drink on duty, and if you do, there is a consequence.
- Benjammer 8y agoI don't think the parent comment is at all disagreeing with the existence of any utility in "banning alcohol" here. The gist of what the parent comment is saying, is that, if you have a policy in place to "compensate" for a certain "negative trait," what you are actually doing is inviting _more_ of that trait, because you are signaling that your company will put effort in to help deal with that, which means that someone who needs help monitoring their alcohol consumption would be _more likely_ to work for you, thus accomplishing essentially the opposite of what you wanted. Mature adults who do _not_ need someone else to monitor their alcohol consumption are far more likely to inherently present with the responsible, adult behaviors that you desire. But, a mature adult who can already sufficiently moderate their own alcohol consumption is going to be _less likely_ to want to work at a place where said consumption is heavily, outwardly regulated/enforced, because why would they want to be constantly told something that they have already fully incorporated into their mature, adult habits and personality?
- mcguire 8y ago"Mature adults who do _not_ need someone else to monitor their alcohol consumption are far more likely to inherently present with the responsible, adult behaviors that you desire." That doesn't seem to describe Google's employees. (Or anyone under the age of 30, for that matter, says the little tiny cynic who lives on my shoulder.)
- Spooky23 8y agoMature adults also don’t sexually harass their colleagues. My priority is to have swift, clear consequences for harassment. If you are drinking at work and in your buzz behave inappropriately, I want you walked out of the building for the alcohol and spare the victim from the more harm. You don’t need to infantalize folks. It’s really simple: if you want to go get drinks, there’s a bar down the road.
- eridius 8y agoYou don't need to ban alcohol in order to punish someone for being visibly drunken or pawing at employees.
- Spooky23 8y agoIf you allow drinking at work, what BAC is ok? What exactly is the justification for endorsing drinking at work?
- piptastic 8y agoThe amount of alcohol you consume doesn't really matter. It's the behavior that is punishable regardless of whether you were drinking or not.
- Spooky23 8y agoSo when your high functioning alcoholic blows a .22 after taking out a telephone pole and hurting another driver, what do you do then? What portion of responsibility will the victims attorney pin on you?
- kjeetgill 8y agoZero. Don't drink and drive; It's the drinkers responsibility. Do you blame the liquor store? The state liquor laws?
- Spooky23 8y agoNope. Serving alcohol or providing a place to drink can make you liable. That’s why you’re usually advised to get a liability policy for weddings and large parties.
- afandian 8y agoSleep deprivation affects cognitive ability. It affects everyone differently. It is sometimes involuntary, sometimes voluntary. That said, how many hours' sleep the night before a day's work is acceptable?
- briandear 8y agoCan we ban nerf guns and adult slides? Good grief, much of Silicon Valley feels like a kindergarten.
- leetcrew 8y agowhy does it have to be a ban? isn't it satisfying enough just to look down at your inferiors and bask in how mature you are?