4 ms·
It's an assumption that has been tested many times. Humans can survive losing parts of their brain, but it causes observable changes in their mind. That's were
by yorwba 8y ago
It's an assumption that has been tested many times. Humans can survive losing parts of their brain, but it causes observable changes in their mind. That's were those colorful maps of brain regions and their functions come from: by recording what kind of brain damage caused what kind of function to deteriorate.
Don't forget that people used to believe that the heart contained the mind and the brain was just a cooler. There was real evidence that caused scientific consensus to change.
- yters 8y agoThere are some interesting examples of very highly functioning individuals with very little brain. At any rate, correlation does not imply causation.
- 0xffff2 8y agoWhat's your proposed alternative? I'm trying not to be dismissive, but I'm also having trouble coming up with a reasonable alternative hypothesis.
- coldtea 8y agoWhy would an alternative hypothesis have to be "reasonable"? Reason is just a category of how we see the world, not necessarily some ultimate truth.
- yters 8y agoI would say halting oracles are a possibility that have some degree of mathematical traction: https://www.am-nat.org/site/halting-oracles-as-intelligent-agents/ https://www.am-nat.org/site/halting-oracles-as-intelligent-a... But, we shouldn't prefer an incorrect model to no model, and the brain = mind model does not seem correct.
- baddox 8y agoFrom that article: > So, the objection that humans cannot solve every problem only shows that humans might not be complete halting oracles, but cannot show that humans are not partial halting oracles. I don't get it. We can already easily making Turing machines that answer the halting problem for certain infinite sets of Turing machines, so there's nothing unique about the human brain in this regard.
- yters 8y agoThe previous sentence to the one you quote explains: > We can even remove an infinite number of problems from the set and still have an infinite and undecidable set. It is an undecidable set, so cannot be described by a TM.
- baddox 8y agoOh okay, I guess that entire paragraph is just a complicated way of rephrasing their claim, which is that there is at least one TM for which no TM can possibly answer the halting problem, but for which humans can. So then, the claim is that it's at least conceivable that humans can do this, because you can remove a finite or even infinite number of elements from an infinite set and still be left with an infinite set. I still don't understand how this is a remotely useful insight or in any way an indication that humans may have super-Turing abilities.
- yters 8y agoThat's correct. It does not prove that humans have this capability. It just shows that a common counter argument fails, and then the article goes on to explain how it would make an empirical difference if humans are partial halting oracles.
- zamalek 8y agoDualist mind theory is not yet quack science, but it looks like it could be. > It's an assumption that has been tested many times. But it does not make that assumption.