6 ms·
Meh. I think reaching for the mike was OK. She didn't push, and disengaged when he made it clear ("excuse me ma'am") he wasn't going to comply. Literally, sh
by ajross 8y ago
Meh. I think reaching for the mike was OK. She didn't push, and disengaged when he made it clear ("excuse me ma'am") he wasn't going to comply. Literally, she reached around for the mike, their arms bumped, and she sat down. That is just not a violent incident in any reading.
But note that the complaint here isn't that it was sped up, it's that it was actually doctored; the motion of his arm, alone, was sped up to look like a "karate chop" while the rest of the video remains at normal speed. There is a superimposed version floating around on twitter that shows this trickery. It's... pretty scary.
- dragontamer 8y agoThere's nothing scary about random internet people doctoring videos on the internet. Hell, even magazines doctor images to add more darkness or light to a picture to make various celebrities look scarier or more friendly. The subtle-points of marketing / propaganda. Case in point: the famous "Muhammad Ali Knockout vs Sonny Liston " shot was doctored up to sell magazines / newspapers (IIRC: A few more camera flashes in the background of the black-and-white version of the image). Doctoring images is... actually quite common. These changes aren't usually major and Newspapers generally take care to keep things "contextually correct", but its the personal decision of the editor for what counts and doesn't count as "changing the message" of photographs. Anyway, the main issue is that the "doctored" video is being pushed by the White House Press Secretary. We all know disinformation exists in today's age. But we generally expect the White House's mouthpiece to strictly report the facts. But this White House does not stick to the facts. This sort of thing is more expected to come from a sensationalist magazine, and not from the official communication channel of the highest-office in the land.
- eweise 8y agoNothing scary about the whitehouse publishing doctored videos to suppress the new media? ok.
- krapp 8y ago>This sort of thing is more expected to come from a sensationalist magazine, and not from the official communication channel of the highest-office in the land. This is the office that tried to push "alternative facts" as a rationale for the disagreement between Trump's claims of the size of his inauguration crowd and the photographic evidence. I mean, you lived through the same election cycle as everyone else. We saw the crazy train coming from miles away and for some reason the American people decided to board it. Not only should this sort of thing be expected, it's apparently the sort of thing people wanted.
- conductr 8y agoNo doubt the issue of trying to make this guy look like a woman beater is horrible. I would counterpoint that it probably should be someone elses job to us force to get the mic back. I’m sure there are officers of some kind in that room.
- lucozade 8y ago> probably should be someone elses job to us[e] force to get the mic back I'd quite like to think that it shouldn't be anybodies job to use force to get a microphone back from a journalist in a press conference.
- lucozade 8y agoNor should it be anybody’s chagrin to suffer bad grammar. Apologies.
- ajross 8y agoSorry, why would you need to "use force" to prevent a followup question? Trump was literally refusing to answer the question. Journalistic norms going back long before the invention of the microphone say that's not kosher and you have to have an answer. I mean, if we're going to throw norms to the wind and (literally!) push journalists around to control the questions being asked, then we probably don't want to have a press conference in the first place. The solution is certainly not to have the secret service rough up Jim Acosta because Donald Trump doesn't like the question he asked.
- humantiy 8y ago>Trump was literally refusing to answer the question. He answered the question, but Jim didn't like the argument.
- moate 8y agoHe gave a non-answer to the question "why are you categorizing it as an invasion" by saying "because I consider it an invasion". Why is this an invasion and not "a group of refugees and asylum seekers"? Why are you using specific, strong, and decisive language to demonize this group? What is illegal about seeking asylum, since presumably that's what this group would want to do in order to enter the country? It is being pointedly obtuse to say that his answer would be considered satisfactory by anyone. That's not to say that the situation didn't get heated on both sides, but let's not pretend Trump was just being a super nice guy by staying off the golf course long enough to answer these assholes' questions and didn't deserve to get some serious questions answered after a midterm election.
- poulsbohemian 8y agoHe's a credentialed member of the press asking a legitimate question. He has every right to have that microphone and to ask the question. The fact that it happened, that Sarah Sanders is spinning it as an attack on the intern, and that even my kids would be able to tell the video has been doctored should have every American - Republican or Democrat or Other - up in arms. Republicans love to talk about defending the Constitution... well, here's your chance!
- humantiy 8y agoThe issue was he wasn't trying to ask a question but argue with the president and taking time away from other members of the press to ask legitimate questions. He disagreed with the president stating it was an invasion and the president answered him with he believed it was an invasion. Trying to go back and forth wasting time. There wasn't anything else to add which is why the worker came to grab the mic to provide it to the next person. This is common in these interviews since there isn't a lot of time and there are a lot of questions so they try and let everyone get a question in and they only have the one mic. To be honest this is being blown up more than it should but in watching the full video of the press conference Jim was trying to grand stand and was rude. I can understand why this happened. There were other press members there who pushed/challenged Trump on other topics but were respectful and did let go of the mic.
- ajross 8y agoSo... your opinion (hell, I even share it) is that Acosta was in violation of the established norms of presidential journalism. And your conclusion is apparently that it's OK to fabricate evidence to accuse the guy of assault ("placing his hands on a young woman")? Do I take that right?
- humantiy 8y agoIt isn't ok to fabricate evidence. Don't take this the wrong way but I'm not sure if you're saying fabrication to be disingenuous to this event happening or just that they are making it look more like a karate chop. I assume the latter and to me I don't really see much of a difference and isn't the point or is a distraction from the issue as to why they made the decision they did. You drop some frames and it looks more like a karate chop, but I watched the full press video on cbs and other various locations enough to say I don't think he chopped her hand away or anything too crazy. I don't think there is an argument that it didn't happen and that Jim wasn't trying to stop her from taking the mic away to pass to the next person and either on purpose or by reaction blocked and made contact with her at the elbow. I'm not in the camp to call it assault even though it might be technically. I don't know or don't care to debate legally if it is/isn't because I tend to think of assault as more provoked or violent than what this was. The reaction of the staffer was interesting though with her looking confused and unsure what to do as if that hasn't happened before. I do think he was out of line given how he acted not just with the staffer, but after his question on indictments in the Russian investigation which is a question he's asked a few times before and been given the same answer on. Then standing back up and talking over Peter who was called on next to say something about the media being the enemy of the people and something about the pipe bombs (couldn't hear it well due to him not being mic'ed). To me all of those things combined I can understand why they decided to revoke him. Other Press members asked questions that were far more challenging and critical of the administrations direction in this briefing and their creds weren't pulled which leaves me with the conclusion its because of how he acted.