4 ms·
> Google, “[this activity I like] for dummies” and learn for a week. I used to think this, but after guiding some folks into coding I find this flippant and di
by ergothus 8y ago
> Google, “[this activity I like] for dummies” and learn for a week.
I used to think this, but after guiding some folks into coding I find this flippant and discouraging.
First, tech is lucky in that you can learn essentially for free, with the not-to-be-forgotten requirements of a computer and an internet connection. Other professions - say, carpentry - have costlier barriers to entry, even for that week.
Second, what are the baseline requirements to get there? Tech is in the opposite position here: depending on what you turn up in that hypothetical Google search, you might find things for different OSes, for different kinds of work. Ops is not Database is not Data Science is not backend service code is not front end web coding is not desktop application development (and mobile is in a place of it's own). It's VERY VERY easy for someone to get a very wrong impression. Someone "not good at math" but with a logical thought process can kick ass in coding in the right area, but they can get the wrong tutorials for what they want with no clue that's happening. Most tutorials (for good reason) don't try to overload you so they make a lot of assumptions...but those assumptions are wrong for a lot of people.
Third, the assumption of "a week" is very hard for most people. They have family considerations, whatever job(s) they currently hold (and the energy it sucks out of them, which for people wanting a career change is often higher than otherwise). Do you expect an hour a day for that week? 3? 8? Make this clear before telling people that if they can't handle the week they shouldn't try this.
I applaud what the author is TRYING to do, but this approach is most likely to end up discouraging rather than inspiring most people in my experience.
In the past when I told people they could just learn the basics of programming online, I was basing it off of me trying to do so with all of my knowledge and experience that I already have (which, not coincidentally, also includes a lot of info on how to find good ways to learn online). Expecting others to do so without accidentally steering themselves into frustration is optimistic at best.
This doesn't mean they CAN'T - it just means a little guidance helps a LOT. While I only really know coding and tabletopRPGs, I assume the same points apply to other professions: A guide - not asking them to teach you, but to help you define what you're asking and avoid pitfalls ("Don't pay $200 for a udemy course, wait for their very regular $10 sales") can help you make the most of any go-get-um attitude and dedication.
- semitext 8y agoI also take issue with the idea that you should try something for a week, and if you don't like it, it's not for you. There are certain ctivities where your first week will be a poor representation of how much you enjoy an activity. I found the first couple of weeks of learning how to play a guitar miserable. That does not mean it was wrong for me to persevere, it meant that certain activities only become enjoyable once you reach a particular skill threshold. I can think of a lot of activities that work like that.
- astura 8y agoConsider the case of someone who is terribly out of shape and tries something that is a bit physically demanding for a week. They will feel miserable. That doesn't mean the task is "not for them," it might mean they can enjoy it if they get into better shape.
- bluGill 8y agoCarpentry is easier to get into than you think. During the boom years the requirements are able bodied (sorry, if you are confined to a wheelchair you are out) and willingness to work hard. The boss will lend you tools for the first weeks until you get that first paycheck which you are expected to use to buy a few tools (but this won't cost much). Of course it is a boom and bust profession. Some years they are not hiring, some years they can't get enough people and will hire anyone who is willing to work.
- ergothus 8y ago> The boss will lend you tools for the first weeks until you get that first paycheck This doesn't line up with the "google it and try it for a week" unless some sort of apprenticeship is the norm (which also assumes you have no current job). Now, I happen to think what you describe sounds great, but it also sounds like starting the job rather than finding out if the job is for you.
- bluGill 8y agoIf you have no skills you can get paid to try it for a week. The pay isn't great compared to other jobs, but you don't need invest much to try it (compare to the investment to get far enough in brain surgery to decide if you like it)