7 ms·
An Israeli spacecraft is gearing up for a 2019 Moon mission
- billfruit 8y agoNo info in the article as per my eye on the probable date of launch.
- andyjohnson0 8y ago"Early in 2019" according to [1]. [1]https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-falcon-9-rideshare-commercial-lunar-lander-2019/ https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-falcon-9-rideshare-commerci...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- golergka 8y agoStrange mission purpose: all you have to do to get motivated for a STEM career is to open yad2 and check out Tel Aviv rent rates.
- dotancohen 8y agoJust to clear something up, a small detail is slightly misrepresented in the fine article. NASA asked SpaceIL to include a laser retroreflector for use for future lunar navigation. Every gram counts on a craft like this, and SpaceIL is providing NASA a service by bringing the LRA down with it. The article frames the relationship as NASA doing SpaceIL a favor by giving them the LRA, which is a paperweight today and will continue to be so until suborbital lunar navigation becomes commonplace. I.e., not in the mission timeframe. Note that NASA is in fact being very generous towards SpaceIL, by providing time on the DSN and other assets. I'm just clearing up the bit about the LRA.
- ISL 8y agoRetroreflectors are immediately useful for improving our understanding of gravity: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apache_Point_Observatory_Lunar_Laser-ranging_Operation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apache_Point_Observatory_Lunar...
- OpenBSD-reich 8y agoOver thirty billion dollars per year in aid with no strings attached. They owe us, it's the least they can do!
- wolf550e 8y ago3 per year, not 30. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel–United_States_relations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel–United_States_relations
- yostrovs 8y agoIsrael defends itself, though, unlike Japan, S. Korea, or Germany. The tens of thousands of troops in those countries are not counted as foreign aid. But having them there, their guns and equipment, food,etc, is a lot more than direct aid to Israel.
- golergka 8y agoI can see how without detailed information you could frame it like that. But in reality, US gets world-class military research and development and intelligence from the region, and in return dumps shiny military hardware that mostly just collects dust in hangars, just so american military industrial complex doesn't have to cut jobs in some congressional districts. I mean, it's nice that we have F-35s now, but with the support we give to US in the region, I don't think we actually get a fair deal out of this relationship.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jacob019 8y agoAmazing that a private entity in a tiny country can scrape up the resources to go to the freaking moon on mission of inspiration. Can't wait to see them land it.
- Scarbutt 8y agoResearch their relations with the US.
- rustcharm 8y agoWhat does this mean? Israel also has very good relations with India and China.
- Retric 8y agoThis is a very cool project. But, it's not fully funded by Israel and uses a US rocket etc. IMO, the bigger deal is it's a privately funded moon mission. PS: Israel has a GDP of 350.9 billion USD, US had a GDP of 542 billion in 1960 which works out to: $4,622 billion or around 13x Israel which just shows how much richer the world has become.
- mnx 8y agoAre you adjusting for inflation?
- dogma1138 8y agoConsidering the latter half of his sentence he clearly did, Israel might be small but it has a GDP greater that of the smaller developed EU countries like Denmark or Ireland, in fact it's not that far off from the likes of Norway and while Israel has been developing some LPG fields they don't have nearly as much petroleum export as Norway. Israel might be small but it has the money and more importantly the knowhow to run a proper space program and develop a real launcher rather than the 3/4 stage "we promise it's not an ICBM" they use to launch their military satellites, if their situation would've been different and they could cut down on defence spending they likely could've been on the same level as India, keep in mind that India only spends about $1bln. a year on theirs, Israel spends nearly $20bln on defence.
- boltzmannbrain 8y agoLove to see the XPrize teams pushing on; also Astrobotic [1] and Moon Express [2]. [1] https://www.astrobotic.com/ https://www.astrobotic.com/ [2] http://www.moonexpress.com/ http://www.moonexpress.com/
- tt123879 8y agoNice note. While Israel is rolling in the intellectual and monetary riches, the native Palestinian population is forced to endure a life in the ghetto and the wonderful life of never knowing if a soldier or a settler might just show up to end your life or eliminate your livelihood. But thats not so pleasant. Lets just celebrate the scientific and capitalistic success of Israel. Lets ignore blatant, barbaric disregard by the Israelis for the basic humanitarian conditions of the Palestinians. Edit: To all the downvoters trying to suppress this comment, have some spine and respond. Tell us, why should we celebrate Israeli startups and technologies and ignore the Palestinian blood their nation sheds? Why should celebrate Israeli wealth and ignore the fact that they trample on all basic human rights?
- pavel_lishin 8y agoWhy celebrate anything? Nobody's hands are clean. Do you leave similar comments on stories about US companies?
- vkou 8y agoI can't speak about the United States, but whenever Saudi Arabia is brought up, Hacker News response is to drown out all other conversation, by referring to Saudi blood money. Likewise, any time China is mentioned, a dozen people will chime in about freedom of speech, the Uyghurs, the great firewall, espionage, etc. Mentioning that Israel is a brutal apartheid state is not any more off-topic. Mind you, the gp post goes a bit past mentioning that.
- hpcjoe 8y agoIt's insane that we must respond to these allegations in 2018. See the ADL's writeup of this [1] which does a effective, factual takedown of this argument. Arguing this isn't for HN. Attempting to call out a state using misleading labels isn't a sign of intellectual honesty. Its a state level version of an ad hominem, and demonstrates that the accuser has lost an argument badly. Whether or not you like/dislike Israel is not the point under discussion. Whether or not you believe things you've heard about them from others doesn't matter. What matters is that this little state, under constant and tremendous threat over its 70+ years of existence from terrorists, their fellow travelers, NGOs, and states alike, can still launch a cost effective privately funded moon mission. [1] https://www.adl.org/resources/fact-sheets/response-to-common-inaccuracy-israel-is-an-apartheid-state https://www.adl.org/resources/fact-sheets/response-to-common...
- davidf18 8y agoI saw a talk a few years ago about this very impressive program. Not noted in the article was that the group worked with many high school students to help implement the program.
- bob_paulson 8y agowtf people are looking on the moon, beside some pride?