8 ms·
Carly Fiorina destroyed the 'HP Way'
- strlen 16y agoI still won't forgive her for killing DEC/Compaq Alpha, one of the most beautiful CPU architectures.
- asmithmd1 16y agoI don't like her because she split off HP's test equipment division into Agilent. I think The HP Way left the building when this division was no longer the heart of the company. It would be like Disney spinning off the animated movie business to focus on running TV stations or GM spinning off the car business to focus on financing. It might make sense on a spreadsheet but it has to hurt morale of all employees who give more than the minimum because they are proud to be associated with an iconic company
- cadr 16y agoI don't know if you can blame her for that - I seem to remember her starting about the time of the split, so it must have been in the works before she started. I felt the HP Way was alive at Agilent (at least at the time of the split).
- tlb 16y agoThe HP way is very much alive at Agilent. It's the right way to build test equipment and their stuff remains the gold standard. But it turned out that building ink jet printers was a low-margin business so that part of the company had to become a less luxurious place to work.
- parasubvert 16y agoLew Platt, her predecessor, did the Agilent split in the late 90's. He was an HP engineer in the 60's and worked his way up, but ultimately planted the seeds for its downfall during his tenure. I remember disliking him in the 1998-1999 timeframe.
- oiuhjygtfghjnmk 16y agoShe destroyed the "HP way...which put a premium on integrity, respect for employees and a focus on how the company's work would benefit the broader community. Difficult to see how you could do the same in Washington
- Tangurena 16y agoShe was the one who started the policy of bugging employees and board members to find leaks. I'm sure the WireTapHawks would love to have her in DC.
- purpledove 16y agoI can't take this seriously - blaming an individual, especially a CEO, for destroying a corporate culture is ridiculous. I know essentially nothing about the history of HP, but what I do know is that the board bears ultimate responsibility for big decisions, for example a massive layoff. There is also the distinct possibility that the 'HP Way' was sacrificed to save the company. Again, I know nothing of the history, but putting out a hit piece like this right before the election is just crude.
- mikeryan 16y agoI have to disagree, I would think that the CEO would be the single most important individual in defining, creating and driving a corporate culture.
- pstuart 16y agoSteve Jobs comes to mind as a perfect example (in the positive sense).
- gamble 16y agoI agree, but in the case of HP I would add that the board has been entirely capable of disgracing itself independently of Fiorina. Fiorina, Hurd, and Apotheker didn't manifest out of thin air, after all.
- gaius 16y agoAgreed. Infact you could say that that's what a CEO does.
- jbooth 16y agoI can't take this seriously - blaming an individual, especially a CEO, for destroying a corporate culture is ridiculous. I think this is actually the dumbest thing I've ever seen written on Hacker News. If the CEO isn't responsible for corporate culture, then A) Who is? and B) What's the CEO responsible for?
- okaramian 16y ago
- zeteo 16y agoFiorina's (mis)adventures with HP are hardly news (she resigned in 2005). This is a purely political article before next week's election, and it is "off-topic: most stories about politics [...] unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon."
- gamble 16y agoEven when she was CEO, it was widely believed within HP that Fiorina was only there to fluff up her Republican credentials in preparation for a run at higher office. The HP/Compaq merger was at least in part motivated by her desire to be the author of a flashy, attention-grabbing merger that would vault her into the public eye. Apparently, though, epic failure in business doesn't disqualify you from running as the candidate of managerial competence in the modern Republican party. Fiorina destroyed an icon of the American tech industry, and for what? Nothing
- hugh3 16y agoY'see, this is why I don't like these sorts of discussions. Suppose Fiorina were a Democrat instead of a Republican. Would you be writing the same thing (s/Republican/Democrat/), or would you be defending her? Maybe you would be writing exactly the same thing. Maybe you're a paragon of political detachment. But in the fraught political climate of the day, I the reader am left to suspect that most people's opinions on the matter are severely coloured by whether they personally wish to see a Republican replace a Democrat in next week's California Senate election. This is why I don't think this article is conducive to good discussion and have flagged it.
- moxiemk1 16y agoI'm not sure that the exact same discussion would be had if she were a Democrat, but not because people would be giving her a free pass. The Republican party makes it a major plank to support large business and to support issues that benefit the wealthy/large, while making less-than-indisputable arguments as to why the decisions benefit the rest of the company. Thus, her tenure at a large business is quite relavent to her viability as a Republican candidate, while it's less relavent (though certainly still important) to her viability as a democrat.
- ahoyhere 16y agoI agree. I'm far from considering myself a democrat (I hate both parties pretty much equally), but aren't most of the "experience is totally out of left field" politicians Republican? The Gipper Arnold Schwarzenegger Clint Eastwood Carly Fiorina George W Bush (his main claim before governorship, other than genetic, was running a baseball team) Who else? Sarah Palin - sportscaster Sonny Bono Shirley Temple (yes really - she ran for office, didn't win, but was chosen as a diplomat) On the Democrat side there is… who? Hillary Clinton? But she actually majored in polisci and law, which is a traditional path. Al Franken is odd but he was a political humorist. And he graduated from Harvard with a degree in polisci. In fact, though I looked, the only Democrat I could find who fit the bill was Jerry Springer. Yes, that's Gipper-level weird.
- mpk 16y agoWasn't Carly Fiorina the one who destroyed HP's R&D division and consequently relegated a large chunk of the HP product line (HPUX, systems and storage) to obsolescence in the space of a few years?
- bfung 16y agoHP wasn't the first. In the 90s, there was Lucent Technologies, aka Bell Labs (Unix, C, C++, vi, plan9...): http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/tag/carly-fiorina/ http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/tag/carly-fiorina/ http://www.finnov-fp7.eu/publications/finnov-discussion-papers/the-rise-and-demise-of-lucent-technologies http://www.finnov-fp7.eu/publications/finnov-discussion-pape... (disclosure: my parents worked there at the time and brought home the internal news every night)
- tlb 16y agoWorth reading, thanks. But it faults her for Lucent's strategy of pushing new products into the market by financing small companies to buy and operate them. Not only was it approved by the market, it was a sound strategy. Lucent was continually developing new networking equipment with a particular service model in mind, but AT&T was sluggish in deploying them. So they found ambitious small companies and hooked them up with equipment on time payment plans. Generally they ran the service better than the telcos would have, and it created lots of great companies.
- bfung 16y agoThe 2nd link provide does a "by the numbers reported" reports. It's like high schoolers in chemistry class trying to get an A on lab work; who hasn't fudged the numbers before? The Fortune article digs a bit deeper: PathNet was such service provider caught in the easy money in the internet bubble era. "...PathNet, with barely 100 employees and all of $1.6 million in annual revenue..." "...The smaller company had barely $100 million in equity (and that's based on generous accounting assumptions) on top of which it had already balanced $350 million in junk bonds paying 12.25% interest. Adding $440 million in loans from Lucent..." So, give equipment and money to a company, knowing they would need to one day repay 220 times their revenue (if they could), and recording that as a "sale" ... that does not appear to be sound strategy for sustaining one's own company. It's like banks, giving out loans to people to buy houses they might not be able to afford...
- mahmud 16y agoI hate to be that guy, but vi was written by Bill Joy at Berkeley.
- justinchen 16y agoWhen I joined HP in 2001 out of college, the first thing my boss had me do was read the book "The HP Way." It was by Dave Packard and outlined their history and philosophy for doing business. My boss was an HP lifer and loved the HP culture and made all his direct reports read the book. Sadly, reading the book just made me realize what a different company I had joined since Carly's changes were soon felt through the organization. Even more so when HP merged with Compaq and instilled their Texan-style top-down management approach and booted out the more distributed and democratic approaches towards innovation and decision making. I finally left in 2006 when the Compaq IT management started forcing all IT employees to move to Houston or Palo Alto (I had just moved to Chicago).
- _delirium 16y agoThe depths of dislike for Fiorina in the tech industry are somewhat impressive. A former-HP friend who strongly leans Republican lamented that the Republicans managed to find almost the only possible person who he wouldn't vote for over Barbara Boxer (who he strongly dislikes... but not as much as he dislikes Fiorina).
- jackfoxy 16y agoDidn't the HP board destroy the HP Way by placing the outsider Fiorina at the helm?
- protomyth 16y agoI am of the same opinion. I always thought that the board had lost it's way and Fiorina / Hurd were just the consequences. It is not like the board didn't know what they were getting.
- brown9-2 16y agoI agree. You can't blame a single person for such a large strategic shift. She is just the most visible, and the easiest to blame. However, some number of people had to think it was a good idea to hire her, continue to extend her contract, and reward her performance with huge compensation. Even a CEO has a boss.
- nostrademons 16y agoThe analogy here is that if she's elected and screws up the country, then it's the voters' fault. Which is true, but is also a good reason to not put yourself in that position as a voter.
- johngalt 16y agoThe timing of this article is interesting. Supposedly she destroyed the 'HP Way' years ago. Makes me wonder why it was brought up now... Almost as if there was some important date approaching...
- brown9-2 16y agoThe intention is clearly stated in the first and second sentences of the article. It's not as if the author's are trying to hide their purpose.
- krakensden 16y agoLook at the username, this person is trolling.
- gfodor 16y agoCarly Fiorina running on her record as CEO of HP is like Michael Brown running on his record as the head of FEMA.
- tlb 16y agoThe article charges that at HP, Fiorina maximized shareholder value at the expense of a great intellectual & humanitarian legacy. You can deplore that or not depending on your economics. But it's not a reason to paint her as a bumbler or willful destroyer. The market approved her strategy at Lucent and most of her time at HP.
- gamble 16y agoWhat? Lucent lost 90% of its value thanks to Carly's leadership, and HP's stock lost 50%. If she was effective at anything, it was destroying shareholder value by the billion.
- stretchwithme 16y agoand Barbara Boxer is, along with her fellow foolish democrats and republicans, destroying the American Way. I guess they're even steven.
- stretchwithme 16y agoSeems to me that quite a few tough choices need to be made in DC and I don't recall Boxer making any that didn't involve wasting vast sums of money.