2 ms·
This is a subtle version of the Post Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc fallacy. Assumption: free will is defined by unpredictability and indeterminacy. (Actually not a give
by TheOtherHobbes 8y ago
This is a subtle version of the Post Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc fallacy.
Assumption: free will is defined by unpredictability and indeterminacy. (Actually not a given. This is hotly debated, to put it mildly.)
Therefore if a physical system behaves in an intrinsically unpredictable way (quantum systems do...) it is showing evidence of free will.
If you start from the premise that the universe and everything in it is sentient (etc, etc) this makes perfect sense. Of a sort.
But it's not in any way a proof of that premise.
In fact it doesn't even come close to being a proof. All it does is take the long way around proving that constrained unpredictable systems are in fact unpredictable but constrained - something that's proven by Kochen-Sprecker anyway.
Then it pulls the free will rabbit out of the hat and says "Of course! This is just like human free will!"
I'm going to go with "no" on this one.
The irony is that KS is usually taken as a proof that quantum systems aren't just indeterminate, they're essentially partially unknowable. There is no possible one-to-one mapping between states and observables.
If particle free will existed there would either be a tighter constraint on the possible mappings, which would disprove KS, or the free will would be indistinguishable from quantum randomness, which makes it an untestable metaphysical epiphenomenon.
Either way it doesn't add anything to our understanding.
Of course if someone designs an experiment where particles use observables to signal their consciousness to human experimenters, I'll change my mind about that.