3 ms·
> This is where many of the arguments against government regulation break down. If you take government out of the picture, you're still left dealing with massiv
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> This is where many of the arguments against government regulation break down. If you take government out of the picture, you're still left dealing with massive institutions and bureaucratic regulations.
This is only true of uncompetitive markets. If Target refused to sell you clothes because someone made a false copyright infringement claim against you, you would laugh in their face and go shop at any of a thousand other stores. And for exactly that reason they don't even attempt to do things like that.
Moreover, in many cases the regulations are what make markets uncompetitive. Providing internet service to urban areas is highly lucrative and has relatively low costs -- if you could pull $40/month from each of a hundred people just for wiring a single high rise, companies would be lining up left and right to do that. But you aren't allowed to do that without also providing service to an area covering hundreds of square miles, including random farmhouses that are ten miles apart from one another. A competent government would instead solve that problem through direct subsidies to providers who expand into rural areas (or leave it to the market to figure out how to connect sparse farmhouses with some kind of medium-speed directional wireless or similar), and then there would be more competition. But we haven't got that.
Moreover, even when there are actual natural monopolies (like roads or rural internet) that can justify government involvement, what works best in those cases is often for the government to just provide the thing directly rather than trying to regulate some independent private entity with a 96% chance of capturing the regulators.
- clairity 8y ago> "This is only true of uncompetitive markets. If Target refused to sell you clothes because someone made a false copyright infringement claim against you, you would laugh in their face and go shop at any of a thousand other stores. And for exactly that reason they don't even attempt to do things like that." what you say would be true of (increasingly rare) mom-and-pop shops, but the relationship you use is highly asymmetric and favorable to the large bureaucratic organization, no matter the competitive dynamics of the market. target would be the one laughing in your face, not the customer. the false dichotomy of preferring one bureaucracy over another because one is private and the other public is silly (in case it's unclear, you should prefer neither). the rest of what you said is reasonable however. direct provision, direct subsidies, or removal of regulatory barriers in rural access would be better than the convoluted compromise we have now.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> target would be the one laughing in your face, not the customer. Target has a thousand competitors selling substantially identical products for similar prices. Walmart, Amazon, eBay, Kmart, Costco, Staples, J.C. Penney etc. They have no market power. By contrast, if you can't get internet from Comcast you basically have to move to another state.
- clairity 8y agoand yet, target can mark up their products higher on average than the competitors you named (e.g., http://blogs.marketwatch.com/great-columnist/2012/10/15/retail-markups-and-the-power-of-amazon/ http://blogs.marketwatch.com/great-columnist/2012/10/15/reta...). so they really have no market power? why do you think target spends so much on branding? really understanding a firm's market power and the competitive dynamics of it's market requires a bit more depth than noting that products are similar. (there are also different forms of market power, but i'll leave that for another day)
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> and yet, target can mark up their products higher on average than the competitors you named Costco and Amazon have lower unit margins because they charge annually for memberships or Prime. Walmart has lower nominal markups because they don't use promotions, so all their nominal markups are their actual markups rather than regularly getting eroded by promotions. When it all shakes out, the thing that costs ~$15 at Target costs ~$15 at Walmart. > why do you think target spends so much on branding? That's what companies with no market power do. They can't significantly raise prices so they push to drive sales volume. > really understanding a firm's market power and the competitive dynamics of it's market requires a bit more depth than noting that products are similar. On the other hand, when they're independently selling the same product for the same price... https://www.target.com/p/lego-minecraft-the-zombie-cave-21141/-/A-53166490 https://www.target.com/p/lego-minecraft-the-zombie-cave-2114... https://www.walmart.com/ip/LEGO-Minecraft-The-Zombie-Cave-21141/280852858 https://www.walmart.com/ip/LEGO-Minecraft-The-Zombie-Cave-21... https://www.amazon.com/LEGO-Minecraft-Zombie-21141-Building/dp/B075RDZLZ5 https://www.amazon.com/LEGO-Minecraft-Zombie-21141-Building/...
- dreamcompiler 8y ago> Moreover, in many cases the regulations are what make markets uncompetitive. Regulation is necessary to prevent monopolies, and monopolies by definition make markets uncompetitive. Antitrust regulation protects capitalism from itself. Unfortunately the Antitrust division of the Justice Department has not been doing its job for several decades.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoAntitrust enforcement is a completely different type of regulation than most others because the number one problem with most regulations is that they harm small businesses and add fixed costs that promote business consolidation. By contrast, antitrust by its nature applies only to very large businesses and does not have that problem.