6 ms·
21st Century Victorians
- zeckalpha 8y agoReminds me of http://www.classmatters.org/2006_07/its-not-them.php http://www.classmatters.org/2006_07/its-not-them.php Which has been applied in tech in https://www.harihareswara.net/sumana/2016/05/21/0 https://www.harihareswara.net/sumana/2016/05/21/0
- chickenfries 8y agoThanks for sharing this. Very interesting so far. "Inessential weirdness" is something I've been thinking about for a while but didn't have a name for.
- justtopost 8y agoThe problem is, what seemed reasonable and essentially weird then, and what seems that way in retrospect, are very, very different. This is a problem for both sides of the coin. What is essential is in the eye of the observer, through the lens of their culture and time. Calling someone's drive 'inessential' is just cast8ng judgement by another name.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI deeply disagree with the author's politics however I think the following paragraph deserves quoting: >Whether or not there's an obvious connection with money or status, if these cultural clashes happen across class lines, then class dynamics are at work. Of course there are also working-class vegetarians, Buddhists and so on, and when they get culture-shock reactions from other working-class people, it's not a class issue. But whenever there's a big difference in income, assets, education and/or status, then cultural differences become laden with class dynamics.
- gumby 8y agoAlthough I deeply disagree with Jacobin Magazine's politics I find this article really right on point: > Today, spin classes, artisanal food, and the college application process ...make no mistake, they serve the same purpose: transforming class privilege into individual virtue, thereby shoring up social dominance.
- nwj 8y agoI agree that the central point of the article is on target. The notion that this is somehow a "Victorian" thing, though - that the Victorians have some special responsibility in history for inventing this strategy of social dominance - that's an error. Humans have been doing this for much longer than that.
- munk-a 8y agoI don't disagree but it's a really keen comparison. The Victorian Era has been romanticized pretty heavily but it's close enough in memory for there to be general knowledge about it while being far enough away to seem foreign and allow us to examine it with a more critical eye.
- purestgreen 8y agoThe Romans and the Greeks wrote endlessly on this topic. Everything Confucius said, too. Perhaps the only significances of the Victorians was the rise of a middle class and "more" upward mobility. Before it had been "act your class/caste", the one you had been born in, but for the Victorians is was the class you wanted your _children_ to be born in. But for sure, was an interesting comparison, until the vomit forced into the last line.
- 0x8BADF00D 8y ago> But for sure, was an interesting comparison, until the vomit forced into the last line. I’m glad that I wasn’t the only one who found that to be offputting. What a way to ruin an otherwise excellent article.
- 8y ago
- actionbronson 8y agoAlso see: * “I don’t even own a tv” * preferred pronouns in Twitter bio * keto * wellness/mindfulness * no straws * city bikes In general there is no small amount of pearl clutching to be had to improve your social standing.
- beaconstudios 8y agomost of these can be conspicuous or can be practical interventions for something a person needs or wants. See being a vegan because you think eating meat is wrong versus being a vocal vegan because you want everyone to know how much better you are than them. That distinction can apply to everything you've listed.
- actionbronson 8y agoBut a poor person would never "think eating meat is wrong" or do any of these other things. Even seeing them as issues is middle to upper to middle class culture, conscious or not.
- cowpewter 8y agoYeah, I eat keto, but I don't push it on people or think it makes me better than anyone. I'm a T2 diabetic, and it's simply the best way for me to eat to prevent losing my feet or winding up on dialysis someday. It's not the cheapest way to eat (meat and fresh vegetables are expensive compared to processed carb products (or heck, even nonprocessed carby staples like rice and beans)), so I would never look down on someone that couldn't afford to eat this way. I wouldn't even push it on another diabetic, beyond mentioning that I use it to control my blood sugar and it works well for me. I think my eating keto is a personal "essential weirdness" to quote an article someone posted elsewhere in this discussion. [1] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18403103 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18403103
- ravitation 8y agoAs someone who would willingly describe themselves as a socialist, this reads like satire, or, if taken seriously, like a poorly thought out high school history paper. The author does quite a good job lampooning the modern practices of the (often liberal) elite, but fails abysmally to prove that any of these practices are done "to assert one class's moral superiority over another and to justify social inequality." Without that crucial piece of support for the author's thesis, this article fails to provide any meaningful social or moral commentary about the practices of the modern elite. In fact, one could argue that the lampooning of the modern liberal elite and their practices, such as the author does in this article, is itself done as way of asserting a different class's moral superiority over another - in this case a socialist intelligentsia's superiority over the mainstream liberal elite.
- dogma1138 8y agoSadly this isn’t satire, which is the problem.
- retsibsi 8y agoI mostly agree with your take on the article (though I admit I skimmed some paragraphs), but I think this bit was probably intentional: > the lampooning of the modern liberal elite and their practices, such as the author does in this article, is itself done as way of asserting a different class's moral superiority over another Unfortunately, I think the most effective way to counter a status move is not through reasoned argument, but with a status move of one's own. If you can turn the status symbol into something ridiculous or embarassing, you've successfully undermined it. This is (usually) most easily done via public mockery.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoYes and no. You've undermined the public expression of the status move. But pride is all over the place, from things that look like pride, to "I'm not proud like those people, I'm down to earth" - and proud of it, to (another turn of the screw) "I don't do false humility like those people". It's the human condition to find someone to look down on to feel better about yourself. You can perhaps make people stop expressing it publicly, but you aren't likely to change hearts very much. (And when you do, you'll most likely make someone realize that having pride in that is stupid, so they'll change to having pride in something else.)
- sverige 8y agoEntertaining in much the same way as Veblen's commentary, though without as much hilariously and intentionally poorly-concealed contempt. Perhaps if the author wishes to continue to pursue this particular sort of Bildung, he will expand this piece into a much longer form for us. Just think how well that would display the amount of free time he has! And how much more room would be available to flesh out what must be a very well-developed political argument! I am giddy with anticipation.
- geitir 8y agoGenerally, practices that garner popularity in the middle and upper class have life improving properties, whether physical, social, or mental. That doesn't mean they don't create a class barrier, but that's a consequence of financial means more than anything imo.
- lucas_membrane 8y agoTrue, those absurd excesses of conspicuous consumption that do not simulate at least a soupcon of some plausibly life-improving property are seldom flaunted where the other classes may observe, but privacy is itself now one of the essential privileges of the moneyed elite, protected by the same class barriers that lucre's natural owners erect to satisfy their disproportionate need for the life-improving mental feelings of safety and security (from those on the opposite side of the barriers). Any 21st century moralist who does not accept that they are wealthy only in proportion to the number of things that they can do without is a phony.
- Torwald 8y ago>>> Of course, exercising, eating organic food, and pushing children to use their spare time usefully are not inherently bad things. However, they become markers of bourgeois values when they are marshaled to assert one class’s moral superiority over another and to justify social inequality.<<< Is this really happening? I mean: "marshaled to assert one class’s moral superiority" is this really going on? I do know middle-class Americans from, let's call it bluntly, both the "red" and the "blue" side of the country and I don't observe this behaviour there at all. Sure, people can be proud, but trumpeting "moral superiority" because of class? Can't remember having ever seen that.
- judah 8y ago>> Is this really happening? No, of course not. Jacobin is a hard-line socialist publication. They want readers to view every aspect of life, no matter how minuscule, through the dim lens of class, gender, and race struggles.
- monadgonad 8y ago> dim lens of class, gender, and race struggles To call something as broad and all-pervading as "class, gender, and race struggles" a "dim lens", as if it's looking at life from the specific interest of a very small group, is laughably myopic.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoIt is also myopic to have "class, gender, and race struggles" as the only lens you can view life through. I suspect that's judah's criticism of Jacobin.
- monadgonad 8y agoThat's a fair argument. I do think it's absolutely an appropriate lens for this issue but can see why someone like judah might find it grating.
- 8y ago
- sevensor 8y ago> These clothes were sending a message: "Make no mistake, we are not walking or riding bikes for transportation. This is exercise." I often use a bicycle for transportation, and I've noticed that spandex cyclists won't give me the time of day. This happens even on otherwise deserted streets, where I and the other cyclist are the only two people for a mile. No bell or "on your left" from an overtaking cyclist, no wave of the hand from somebody going the other way, not even an ambiguous nod of the head. It's the strangest thing. edit: I don't mean to imply that spandex cyclists would actually put bells on their bicycles.
- mkj 8y agoIt is a pity that English doesn't have the distinction between people riding bicycles and people riding in lycra, the Dutch Fietser vs Wielrenner
- sevensor 8y agoThat's a good distinction -- perhaps I'll start calling them wheel-runners. It might catch on. And to be fair to wheel-runners, it could be that what I'm reading as haughty disregard is actually the same kind of abstraction one sees in foot runners, a kind of meditative absorbtion in the experience of exercise. This might also explain why they appear unable to see stop signs.
- Abutere 8y agoMAMIL (noun) - Middle Aged Man in Lycra
- internet555 8y agoAs a kid I always thought spandex or whatever bike riders were huge dorks who got scammed into wasting their money. If you’re driving around your home area a few times a month (or even week) I doubt that you’re anywhere near good enough that your clothing matters this much. Similar with people who suck at guitar but own a $3000 Gibson or whatever. I feel like good equipment while you’re bad just makes you look like a joke. Perhaps this is a blue collar ethic though
- mo1ok 8y agoI also feel I've seen this mentality in play in politics - the core of of bourgeois politics seems to consist of virtue-signaling or name-dropping challenging philosophers.