3 ms·
There are a lot of platforms to choose from, but my house is only physically connected by one high speed ISP.
by rootusrootus 8y ago
There are a lot of platforms to choose from, but my house is only physically connected by one high speed ISP.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- yantz 8y agoYou can still connect to a low speed ISP much in the same way that people banned from Twitter or YouTube can still use much smaller platforms with a lower reach.
- rootusrootus 8y agoMy tax dollars helped pay for the infrastructure that the ISP is selling me service over. It's a little different from Twitter or Youtube, who are just a site on the Internet.
- yantz 8y agoYour tax dollars helped pay for the development of the Internet and many of the technologies that those sites and services use today.
- rootusrootus 8y agoSure, the development of the technology, but not the actual services themselves. The difference with the local ISP is that my tax dollars actually helped pay for the physical plant. And through my gov't I give them actual physical right-of-way to lay cables and maintain them. This is a very important distinction that does not apply to a soft service on the 'net somewhere. Now, if my tax dollars helped pay for Twitter's datacenter, then now we have something to talk about. And perhaps in the state where Twitter is, they got tax breaks which amount to effectively a subsidy from the citizenry. In that case I think it's time to take the case to court.
- yantz 8y agoThe physical plant was made a long time ago and was a one-time investment, like arpanet back in the day, or for example investigation made by universities using public grants that helped develop video codecs that are now in use by sites like youtube. So yes, it's the same.
- wuliwong 8y agoI kinda agree with both you and 'yantz'. I think there is government subsidy in both cases and I also agree with you that the government subsidy muddies the waters a bit. I am someone who believes that private businesses should be free to discriminate with regards to whom they provide service but we are faced with varying degrees of subsidization and I'm not sure where you would draw the line. Another issue is that there is really no non-subsidized alternate choice of note to these corporations at this level in the United States. These large corporations lobby and help craft favorable legislation on a continual bases. There is a very complex and murky relationship between the large corporations in the United States and the various governing bodies.
- wuliwong 8y agoI think you are oversimplifying here. The de-platforming often was sweeping across many websites and service providers. So there weren't really any choices left. And in the case of Gab.com they have had a lot of trouble getting running again at all. I think they were completely shutdown for a week or so. Some of these accounts that were de-platformed completely erased followings that they had developed over years of working that were probably worth millions of dollars to them. To imply that you finding a different ISP is a greater inconvenience than what these businesses had to face is doubtful. Even if you had to completely move to a new home to get service it could be argued that it was still less of an inconvenience.
- rootusrootus 8y agoThat is certainly an interesting question. When your position has become so odious that every provider on the Internet wants nothing to do with you, what is the solution? In any case it is still much better to have multiple providers to possibly be rejected from, as opposed to a residential broadband subscriber who can be completely shut down by a single company. And Gab.com is not a person, so they can locate their service anywhere someone will allow them to host it. The virtual nature of that arrangement is very convenient, and the relative inconvenience of buying a whole new house (in a different city or state, perhaps, since you have to move far enough to find a different ISP) is off the charts by comparison. It seems disingenuous to even try to compare those.