5 ms·
So when the US East Coast springs forward 1 hour California is then going to be 4 hours behind? That's gonna make West Coast travel even worse.
by taylodl 8y ago
So when the US East Coast springs forward 1 hour California is then going to be 4 hours behind? That's gonna make West Coast travel even worse.
- secabeen 8y agoNo. Under this plan, in the winter, CA would be 2 hours behind the East Coast, and the summer, 3 hours behind.
- twoodfin 8y agoSeveral of the New England states are contemplating a move to year-round Atlantic Time, which would keep them synced 3 hours ahead of California. I’d love that. There’s no reason why a city at the latitude of Boston should have to endure 4:30 sunsets.
- ghaff 8y agoI doubt it will ever happen because you're now a different timezone from NYC. But I'd absolutely consider voting for abolishing daylight savings if New England moved to Atlantic Time.
- philwelch 8y agoThe opposite. California is going to UTC-7 year-round. The East Coast varies between UTC-5 and UTC-4. California is effectively going to be in the exact same time zone as Arizona, which is in Mountain Standard Time and does not recognize DST. Honestly, we should just abolish the Pacific time zone and then abolish DST on the West Coast. Rename Mountain Standard Time to Western Standard Time.
- function_seven 8y agoI love the symmetry of that. Western, Central, and Eastern Standard Times.
- Taniwha 8y agothe obvious follow on from that is to abolish timezones all together, all use UTS, and simply change the times we go to work to match local conditions
- rtkwe 8y agoNo that's just awful, now instead of having a defined timezone boundary we have a slow bleed between different areas and we have to look up to know what a businesses hours are if we're not close enough to follow the same customary time instead of just knowing what timezone they're in. So now we're dealing with a patchwork of 'zones of similar customary times' as areas with similar solar times move towards a similar clock so businesses can coordinate and trade easily with local businesses. It'll be a mess so states will probably organize together to make things simpler and have a similar set of hours across the state. These pseudo-timezones will be slightly better and states around a similar longitude will naturally order into a similar set of customary times because their local solar times are roughly the same. Now we've got pretty much the EXACT same situation as the current timezones including a generalized offset from UTC so we gain nothing. What exactly do you suppose we gain from abolishing timezones?
- Taniwha 8y agobut isn't that what you have to do now, look up what timezone a business is in. The only difference with this scheme is that you don't need to convert between timezones to figure out when they're open in your timeezone I live in the southern hemisphere and 'work' online in the northern - I have to deal with the mess that is 4 different combinations of timezones every year, and calendaring systems that are unable to handle the idea of knowing WHERE a meeting is going to be held so they can get the time right Really though people should change their work hours to match their timezones - I live a long way south, we have long twilight in the summers and tiny days in the winter, when it gets dark at 4:30 because we're squashed up against a timezone boundary - I have to get up in the dark anyway, why not move our winter work hours so we get a couple of hours daylight during the winter? it would help with the Vit D issues
- 8y ago
- vinay427 8y agoI can't imagine people in the northern reaches of Mountain time would be pleased about never having DST. They'd likely be better off moving to CST (so no DST).
- philwelch 8y agoSure! Or they could still have DST in the former Mountain zone and not in the former Pacific zone. US law allows for states to opt in or out of DST. (Also, Indian reservations, because they're treated as quasi-sovereign nations in some ways.) A WST would probably entail WA, OR, and CA opting out with AZ while MT, ID, WY opt in.
- intopieces 8y agoSome clarification: California is currently not going to do anything in changing DST. This measure doesn't even propose making DST permanent or switching to PDT all the time, it just allows the legislature to talk about changing it.
- dragonwriter 8y agoActually, it allows the Legislature to actually change it, provided the feds allow it. And it was submitted by the Legislature, which probably wouldn't seek permission if it didn't intend to use it.
- rconti 8y agoHonestly, if it happens, I bet the rest of the West Coast follows suit, and then the rest of the country.