4 ms·
> is it okay for doctors to lie about placebo treatments if it actually helps? Let's sharpen the question: What if the lie is the treatment? It sounds to me l
by BurningFrog 8y ago
> is it okay for doctors to lie about placebo treatments if it actually helps?
Let's sharpen the question: What if the lie is the treatment?
It sounds to me like the 40% who the placebo helps for have a different, mainly mental, problem than the 60% for whom it doesn't.
- apocolyps6 8y agoIt was 40% effective for _both_ groups. Meaning the "actual treatment" might actually be doing nothing.
- BurningFrog 8y agoYeah, I got that. The injection probably did nothing aside from a placebo effect.
- IncRnd 8y ago> It sounds to me like the 40% who the placebo helps for have a different, mainly mental, problem than the 60% for whom it doesn't. It's likelier that the 60% not helped are those who have a different, mainly mental, problem that the 40% for whom it does work. If the cure comes from strength of mind, then it probably isn't correct to say that those with weaker minds and wills are healthier mentally.
- BurningFrog 8y agoAre you saying no fractured bone pain is physically based? That seems overly radical. Then again, I suppose all pain is in the mind at some level.
- IncRnd 8y agoNo, I'm not saying that. My comment doesn't even come close to implying that.
- da_chicken 8y agoNope. Placebos can work even when you know it's a placebo: https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/placebo-can-work-even-know-placebo-201607079926 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/placebo-can-work-even-kn...
- psychometry 8y agoI wonder how much of that effect is due to subjects not understanding what a placebo. Would the effect remain if the study population was other physicians or scientists?
- da_chicken 8y agoI think it's relatively unreasonable to assume that when the study says that participants are informed that they're taking a sugar pill that the participants don't understand what that means, nevermind assuming that no effort at all was made by the administrators to address this fairly obvious issue. If the entire point of the study is testing whether or not patients still benefit when they understand that they're not taking any medication, it seems self-evident that they would be required to ensure their test subjects understand that they're not taking any medication!
- thedailymail 8y agoFrom the article, the guy who ran the study apparently still has reservations on this point: "And he can even be disparaging of his own work, wondering, for instance, whether the study in which placebos were openly given to irritable bowel syndrome patients succeeded only because it convinced the subjects that the sugar was really a drug."
- conanbatt 8y agoCan you imagine a label on all drugs. "General surgeon reminds: your doctor might be lying to you as part of your medical treatment. This might not be a real drug"
- jhayward 8y ago> different, mainly mental What evidence do you have that the placebo effect is 'mental'?
- 08-15 8y agoAbsolutely correct. It's called Münchhausen Syndrome. What "helps" these patients isn't the placebo, it's the attention. (And it "helps" them in the same sense in which the next fix "helps" the junkie.)