4 ms·
As is every club with any kind of charter. The DAR; the sports teams at my local high school; heck even girl's schools like Wellsley. And the religious compone
by JoeAltmaier 8y ago
As is every club with any kind of charter. The DAR; the sports teams at my local high school; heck even girl's schools like Wellsley.
And the religious component is contained in "adherence to spiritual principles, loyalty to the religion that expresses them and acceptance of the duties resulting therefrom"
Its about teaching young people to respect spirituality, to accept loyalty in Scouts to their own faith. I can't see harm in this. Perhaps an Atheist, dogmatically demanding that we all give up faith, could see harm?
- candu 8y agoMeanwhile, in Canada: http://wiki.scouts.ca/en/Sexuality http://wiki.scouts.ca/en/Sexuality ...which goes to show that you can run a chartered organization, even one otherwise substantially similar in content and procedure to BSA, without being discriminatory about it. Same goes for religious organizations: several Christian denominations allow openly gay ministers. There's nothing about spirituality that requires we discriminate against or hate each other. IMHO, we can and should expect better of organizations than to discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation, especially those organizations that purport to model good behavior for youth.
- grigjd3 8y agoThe BSA now allows openly gay members and leaders. It took a while to get there, but it happened.
- endymi0n 8y agoSo which faith should I be loyal to please if I have none? And which universal „spiritual principles“ exist in the world that I could adhere to, except for „whatever my religious leader says“ (of which I don‘t have any)? There‘s simply no logic in these sentences, which points back again to the boy scouts being a de facto religious organization.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoMost young people do grow up in some spiritual environment, at least in America. And all Scouts are required to respect others' faith. I call straw man - what specific problem is being referred to? An imaginary youth raised in a cave?
- lovich 8y agoCitation please. America has very diverse pockets. There's places where the average person wouldn't dream of missing church weekly, and there's others where people have never seen the inside of one. Stating that "most young people" grow up in a spiritual environment means that a kid who isn't spiritual must have been raised in a cave is disengenous
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoTry google in general? Something between 80 and 90% of Americans for instance identify with some faith.
- lovich 8y agoYea, looks like 20% of americans have no religious identity[1]. That leads to roughly 69 million people. How does a population that large of non-religious people lead you to believe that a non religious child would have to be imaginary and raised in a cave? [1]https://news.gallup.com/poll/224642/2017-update-americans-religion.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/224642/2017-update-americans-re...
- ams6110 8y agoI was in Scouts for a couple of years. Religion was not really a focus at all. The message was that we should respect each others choices with regard to religion and spirituality and that was about it. Morals, good citizenship, and respect were otherwise discussed without much reference to religion.
- ryanmercer 8y ago>I was in Scouts for a couple of years. Religion was not really a focus at all. Same. Aside from having a Jehova's Witness as a scoutmaster (that never once brought up religion, in fact my family and that family were the only non-holiday church-going families in my dens and packs), there was absolutely nothing religious about my time from tiger cubs up to my father dying just shy of my 13th birthday and me leaving scouts.
- EvanAnderson 8y agoI was in Scouts, too, and I had a similar experience to you. That doesn't change the fact that organization has weighed-in on matters of religion[1] and affirmed themselves as being discriminatory toward atheists. [1] - https://blog.scoutingmagazine.org/2018/05/31/bsa-reaffirms-duty-to-god-aspect-of-all-programs-through-resolution-adopted-at-2018-national-annual-meeting/ https://blog.scoutingmagazine.org/2018/05/31/bsa-reaffirms-d...
- CydeWeys 8y agoIt depends on the troop. I was in the Cub Scouts in Takoma Park, MD (which is where the hippies went who never stopped being hippies), and indeed religion was not a focus there. But in troops elsewhere, it definitely can be. And those troops are being given cover and explicit endorsement to do so by the national organization. Whereas if, say, a local dance class started injecting religion and making some people feel uncomfortable because it's not their religion, the national organization might step in and shut that all down, saying stick to dance instruction and leave religion in church.
- sneak 8y agoChiming in just to offer some counter anecdata to what seems to be on display in this thread: I was edged out of my local scout troop for being an atheist. This was roughly around 1996-1997 though, so perhaps things have improved.
- fesoliveira 8y agoIt's not so simple as that. Atheists don't demand people to give up faith, but we try raise critical thinking in people so that their actions are guided by fact and evidence instead of blind adoration and faith. Teaching kids to blindly follow things instead of teaching them to think critically can be very harmful in the long run.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoTeaching kids respect is a positive thing. Teaching kids not to steal or lie, likewise.
- EvanAnderson 8y agoAgreed. And one can have those things without religion. Teaching kids to blindly accept matters that are unfalsifiable, doesn't seem like a positive thing. Acting as an example to kids by being discriminatory toward those who do not blindly accept the unfalsifiable doesn't seem like a positive thing either. Edit: minor phrasing
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoTeaching kids respect for other's views on the subject of faith
- dhimes 8y agoIf by respect you mean tolerance, I agree. But I cannot respect, for example, those that believe (as per Leviticus) practicing homosexuals should be put to death.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoNot a lot of them in my Troop
- grigjd3 8y agoYou really should not generalize about athiests. I'm an atheist and I see no special athiesm-based reason to do anything. I promote critical thinking, but that isn't because I'm an atheist. That's because I'm a litterate human being.
- Kye 8y ago>> "Perhaps an Atheist, dogmatically demanding that we all give up faith, could see harm?" You've confused atheist with antitheist. The former is a personal lens on the world. The latter is an ideology. I look up at the stars and see balls of incandescent gas and an indifferent cosmos, but that doesn't mean I berate the witches I know for finding significance in their alignment.