4 ms·
>>Western toilets aren’t the answer, because they require a massive infrastructure of sewer lines and treatment plants that just isn’t feasible in many poor cou
by baybal2 8y ago
>>Western toilets aren’t the answer, because they require a massive infrastructure of sewer lines and treatment plants that just isn’t feasible in many poor countries.
Then build it! No magic tricks there.
I think, this is the most infuriating trait I see in all Silicon Valley "sophisticated person" types.
- blowski 8y agoBuild what? What trait?
- baybal2 8y agoInfrastructure: power stations, grid, water supply, sewage, roads, garbage removal. Without that, you have no functioning cities, and without that, no modern day economy. > What trait? The believes in all kinds of trickery. No will to deal with issues the straight way. Such people spend more time looking for a shortcut, than dealing with an issue at hand. Look: Mr. Gates spent $200m on a magic toilet that is nowhere to be found. That's enough to build 5 small electric power stations, and 5 small sewage treatment plants in a third world country. How many people lives were improved with magic toilet, and how much by building more infrastructure.
- kiriakasis 8y ago> Look: Mr. Gates spent $200m on a magic toilet that is nowhere to be found. That's enough to build 5 small electric power stations, and 5 small sewage treatment plants in a third world country. There was a nice movie about an engineer that was in Thailand (not sure about the country) to build a dam. long story short a civil war start in the country and he is a main target because infrastructure investment from outside to build an infrastructure you cannot maintain only puts you in a death spiral of debt.
- renjimen 8y agoIt’s pure pragmatism. There aren’t the resources to build and maintain a sewage network everywhere it is required. Having a more self contained, affordable solution is better for many places.
- gtsteve 8y agoI'm not a civil engineer but I do work with them occasionally. There are numerous challenges with this, probably the hardest is water pressure: if the water pressure cannot be guaranteed then poor plumbing can send waste water back into the water main, which is a really big problem. I also assume that to ensure water pressure involves electricity - a lot of poorer countries do not have a constant or reliable electricity supply. Building this sort of infrastructure is a massive engineering task and it can take years to complete a project like this. It requires skilled engineers and labour. During that time, people will die because it's not done yet. In conclusion, I think Gates and co have made a good investment.
- baybal2 8y ago>Building this sort of infrastructure is a massive engineering task >It requires skilled engineers and labour Exactly, and there are no tricks around that are known to solve that, other than to engage in massive infrastructure projects. A very simple thing.
- gtsteve 8y agoThere are tricks around known to solve this, such as building intermediate solutions like what Gates proposes to do. When you have a serious issue in production that can be fixed with a global variable in 5 minutes or spending a day correctly planning and implementing a fix that routes the data correctly, what do you pick? I'd hope doing the first thing and replacing it with the second. It's that sort of decision, only people die if you don't move in time.
- baybal2 8y agoYes, the magic toilet took a possibly a decade to make, and I bet will never ever see real world deployment. In the same time, most banal sewers and septic tanks take days to build.
- wongarsu 8y ago>I also assume that to ensure water pressure involves electricity - a lot of poorer countries do not have a constant or reliable electricity supply. Today water pressure in the western world is mostly generated by running finely controlled electric pumps constantly, but it wasn't too long ago that water towers were used everywhere to maintain water pressure. The advantage of a water tower is that you can run an inaccurate oversized pump occasionally to fill up the reservoir on top of the tower, and gravity does the rest of the work. Of course building a tower capable of holding many tons of water is a comparably complex civil engineering task and is costly in materials.