3 ms·
>Anytime you're working on a rooftop or on a tower, your risk of falling to your death is not zero. Okay, but I'd still be interested in: a) A measure of deat
by SilasX 8y ago
>Anytime you're working on a rooftop or on a tower, your risk of falling to your death is not zero.
Okay, but I'd still be interested in:
a) A measure of death risk to the general public, i.e. people not directly involved in the production of the energy. It's important to distinguish internalized vs externalized risk.
b) A measure that accounts for the potential cost of preventing these deaths. That is, one that could capture insights like "source X and source Y currently have the same death count per kWh, but it would cost half has much to achieve a 10% reduction in deaths from X compared to Y".
The ratio of internal/external deaths would hugely effect the measure in b) -- it's much easier to stack on measures that can prevent deaths if they're employees of the provider than if it's the general public.
And so, on a), I would guess that measure for wind power is really hard to distinguish from zero.
- mchannon 8y ago> A measure of death risk to the general public, i.e. people not directly involved in the production of the energy. It's important to distinguish internalized vs externalized risk. That's kinda creepy. Like we should be ok with Appalachian coal mining's horrible safety record because the general public never dies in mining collapses or gets black lung. Who cares about some faraway people just so long as I can run my crypto farm at under 5¢/kWh? Very "Hunger Games".
- rickycook 8y agocertainly shouldn’t be okay with it, but if arbitrary people in a 100km radius were effected rather than just miners, yes that would be worse, because their “decision” to remain in the area is further removed from the problem than the decision to remain a miner
- roenxi 8y agoSo what are you thoughts on coastal cities? Should the government do something about them? My memory is every so often a major hurricane comes along and kills a bunch of people. The people who die probably didn't choose to put the city where it is. The risks are much higher than the nuclear industry. And some follow up questions, because I always vent on Nuclear (sorry, don't mean to take it out on you, the lack of evidence based policy on environmental issues just gets me every time): Is dying in a hurricane better than the health impacts of nuclear, which are many years delayed? Do you think that the evacuation from the region around Fukashima (deaths: 10s of people), which killed more people than the radiation (deaths: 0) is evidence that the standard of "were effected" is too high? Have you ever exposed yourself to so much solar radiation that you felt heat on your skin? Do you feel that this level of risk is remotely acceptable, given the number of deaths caused by skin cancer each year? _PS_ I've worked on a coal mine. Deaths mining coal is already a crazy low figure, Australian coal mines are probably safer than supermarkets by the statistics. I'd be shocked if erecting and maintaining solar panels and wind turbines is safer than nuclear. Roofs and spinning blades will kill people.