2 ms·
As soon as I can find some time to work through that, I'll give my thoughts. But ... is there maybe a truncated explanation of the general dynamic there?
by SilasX 8y ago
As soon as I can find some time to work through that, I'll give my thoughts.
But ... is there maybe a truncated explanation of the general dynamic there?
- Sohcahtoa82 8y agoBasically, imagine you have three candidates: A, B, and C, and there are 50 voters, and the votes come in like this: 100 - A > C > B 100 - B > C > A 40 - C > A > B 10 - C > B > A After round 1 of IRV, candidates A and B each have 100 votes, C has 50. C gets knocked out, 40 votes move to A, 10 votes move to B. A now has 140 votes, and B has 110, and A is declared the winner. The problem is that the B > C > A don't get their second choice considered. Why does this matter? Look at it when you put the votes into pairs. A vs B: 140 people think A > B. 110 think B > A. A vs C: 100 people think A > C. 150 think C > A. B vs C: 110 people think B > C. 140 think C > B. C is actually the more popular candidate, but C LOSES using IRV!