3 ms·
Does #4 actually apply to the new, USB-C iPad? Your other points notwithstanding at all, I was very pleasantly surprised by the shift to USB-C. I was sure Appl
by Wowfunhappy 8y ago
Does #4 actually apply to the new, USB-C iPad?
Your other points notwithstanding at all, I was very pleasantly surprised by the shift to USB-C. I was sure Apple would never move away from Lightning due to their lucrative MFI program. That they did anyway is a win for consumers, even if there's still a lot wrong with Apple's approach.
- writepub 8y agoThat's the sad part - their move towards USB-c reduces their costs, increases supply chain diversity, etc. But, they're likely locking down non MFI certified accessories, at least in storage, for profit, because they can. Imagine the next iteration of the Mac - USB-C ports where storage manufacturers need to pay an MFI tax to function on a commodity, industry spec interface, just for an Apple blessing Where are the FTC, EU regulatory authorities?
- matthewmacleod 8y agoYou are basing this view on absolutely no information.
- writepub 8y agoIt's not a view, it's a fact. Please feel free to browse publicly available MFI policy. [1] Cheers! [1]: https://mfi.apple.com/MFiWeb/getFAQ.action#1-1 https://mfi.apple.com/MFiWeb/getFAQ.action#1-1
- eridius 8y ago"they're likely locking down non MFI certified accessories" is not a fact. It's speculation. And the list of MFi licensed technologies does not include USB. So unless you're tunneling one of the existing MFi licensed technologies over USB (if that's even possible), then MFi does not seem to apply.
- writepub 8y agoMFi is quite literally DRM for USB [1][2][3]!! You're probably confused by the form factor (Lightning vs USB-C), and understandably so. The MFi program prevents successful USB link establishment for non DRM-ed (i.e. unauthorized ) accessories. It's quite literally a toll on the USB lane that Apple can get away with [1]: http://ramtin-amin.fr/#tristar http://ramtin-amin.fr/#tristar [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lightning_(connector) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lightning_(connector) [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MFi_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MFi_Program
- eridius 8y agoMFi covers Apple's proprietary connectors, as well as certain Apple wireless protocols. It does not cover generic USB. If you want more proof, every since the iPad came out Apple has actually sold a USB-A port for the iPad, called a "Camera Adapter" (e.g. Lightning to USB 3 Camera Adapter[1]). It's called this because the primary use-case is connecting your camera to your iPad in order to transfer photos off of it (similar to connecting an SD card), but it works with other USB accessories such as card readers, MIDI interfaces, ethernet adapters, etc. In fact, I'd assume that it works with precisely the same set of accessories that can plug directly into the USB-C port on the new iPad (well, except for being USB-A instead of USB-C). None of these USB accessories are part of the MFi program. Because they don't need to be. Because they're generic USB accessories, rather than accessories that use Lightning or 30-pin connectors. [1] https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MK0W2AM/A/lightning-to-usb-3-camera-adapter https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MK0W2AM/A/lightning-to-us...
- writepub 8y agoProducts you've cited do implement MFI DRM themselves, like Apple's SD reader. It has an MFI DRM chip, plenty of teardowns are online. Additionally, the original post is about USB-C storage accessories not working with the new iPad Pros. So, there's ample evidence that Apple can indeed enforce DRM over USB It's trivial to connect an MFI/USB protocol analyzer to the USB-C bus, and watch the DRM in action yourself. Cheers