3 ms·
Range voting is challenging because people often have difficulty putting an exact number on how much they want something, and also scales differ between differe
by nostrademons 8y ago
Range voting is challenging because people often have difficulty putting an exact number on how much they want something, and also scales differ between different people. On a 0-10 scale, some people will be putting every candidate as either 0 or 10; others will always put in 3 and 7; and this depends a lot more on the voter than the candidate.
Approval voting is simple enough, but is vulnerable to bullet voting: approving an additional candidate can make your first choice lose. This makes it unsuitable if your goal is to make third-party voting more viable, which seems to be the premise of the article.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Range voting is challenging because people often have difficulty putting an exact number on how much they want something, and also scales differ between different people. On a 0-10 scale, some people will be putting every candidate as either 0 or 10; others will always put in 3 and 7; and this depends a lot more on the voter than the candidate. And, particularly, there is very notable cultural variation, which means (ab initio at least; over time, one expects behavior modification efforts would be deployed around this), support from different cultural groups in a diverse polity will have different electoral value even when turnout is the same. > Approval voting is simple enough, But also has the same problem: concretely what “approval” means is unclear and will be subject to voter-to-voter variation even when the actual preferences are identical.
- ClayShentrup 8y agoNo. I did my first exit polling in a small town in Texas and no one had any problems scoring the candidates.
- ClayShentrup 8y agoOops, link. http://scorevoting.net/Beaumont.html http://scorevoting.net/Beaumont.html