4 ms·
As someone with no credentials or official training, and someone who also works at a big megacorporation as an engineer, imposter syndrome hits me fairly hard,
by tombert 8y ago
As someone with no credentials or official training, and someone who also works at a big megacorporation as an engineer, imposter syndrome hits me fairly hard, especially during interviews. It's really hard to compete with the people who actually have proof that they know what they're doing, and I'm usually interviewing for a job that has a strict requirement of a "bachelors in CS, Math or Physics, Masters preferred".
I've managed to pull it off somehow, but I rarely go a day where I don't wonder if I really should have as good of a job as I do.
- jknz 8y agoEmployers look for these degrees because in their experience this is a somewhat meaningful signal that let them filter applicants. But having someone at work for real for a few weeks give employers a way meaningful signal than any degrees on a resume. If your employer maintains their relationship with you, you are likely worth more than the degrees you mentioned--dont overthink it!
- tombert 8y agoAt some level I logically know this, and obviously if the employer didn't feel I was worth it they wouldn't hire me. Still, after dropping out, it was hard to avoid constant feelings of inferiority. Even though people obviously didn't mean it this way, I was interpreting every statement as having an implicit suffix of "and you're stupid because you dropped out". It took me years to realize that people really aren't that much of jerks, and a surprising few actually give a crap about you dropping out. I do think that, for engineering, a year of experience is worth just as much as a year in school if you are willing to spend evenings self-teaching. My interests tend to be a bit more academic (which don't appear to be willing to overlook a lack of a bachelors), and since there's not a single Math professor in the NYC area that will take me on as a PhD student without a degree (I think I might have emailed literally all of them), I've actually started back in school, so hopefully that'll kill the complex.
- jknz 8y agoWhat kind of mathematics are you interested in? I do math in academia in the NYC area, feel free to email (profile).
- tombert 8y agoI don't see your email in your profile. Feel free to email me at thomas@gebert.app I forgot to mention it, I'm interested mostly in theoretical math, and more specifically Type Theory.
- lowercased 8y ago"It's really hard to compete with the people who actually have proof that they know what they're doing" And yet... as an independent consultant, I'm often brought in to projects worked on by these folks who "have proof that they know what they're doing". If they knew what they were doing, almost by definition, they wouldn't be calling in an outside consultant to fix broken shit. There are often many reasons - cutting corners due to time or budget, or inheriting something that was bad and not having support to fix it, or not knowing how to fix it. But often if I'm able to talk to these folks... they didn't know what they were doing (and often didn't know they didn't know), so the result was a mess. The "1% dude" with his CS degree probably has never had to acknowledge to a boss that they made a mistake, or are in over their head, or... haven't had to deal with their own code 5 years later and clean up their own mistakes, let alone others'.
- ptmcc 8y agoWhat I also find funny is that hardly anyone interviews or vets consultants and contractors the same way they do employees. I've been brought in as an "expert" on all sorts of things, with hardly any interviewing. Just show up and be given the keys to the kingdom. Granted I've almost always been able to deliver, but they mostly took my word for it up front.
- pmiller2 8y agoI’m guessing that by the time someone needs an “expert” at something and is willing to pay consultant rates, they’re probably incapable of such vetting.
- mohaine 8y agoI've done 3 interviews in the last couple weeks where candidates couldn't do a simple Python dictionary lookup. These were people with a Masters in CS and have Python as their primary language. I wouldn't worry about being an Impostor.
- tombert 8y agoMy favorite is when people put "concurrency" as a feature on their resumes. When I ask them their opinions on actors vs. CSP, without fail, they don't know what the hell I'm talking about. Apparently "concurrency" to a lot of trained people just means "spinning up threads and use a lock occasionally".
- vonmoltke 8y agoI have done dozens of interviews in my career and have yet to meet anyone who was this bad. What am I doing wrong?
- mohaine 8y agoProbably working for a company with sane resume filtering. We outsourced that.
- vonmoltke 8y agoOh, yeah, I could see that. Most of my experience was with a company where my team and a dedicated technical recruiter did all the filtering, and where the engineers could override the recruiter decisions (in either direction).
- foobiekr 8y agoSome of it is that, but I can say from my own experience that the company itself can draw large numbers of this kind of candidates. For various reasons ($) I’ve worked at a company that people view as a sort of safety school; you get a much higher fraction of incompetents at companies like this. You don’t see them at startups or at companies with solid technical reputations.
- 8y ago
- IAmGraydon 8y agoI feel your pain. I didn’t finish college and I hold a high level director position at a firm with over 200 employees and 6 offices on the east coast. I’m not an amazing interviewer, but I am extremely creative and resourceful, which has gotten me farther than I would have imagined. The imposter syndrome is strong, but slowly getting better as I see my work changing the company for the better. I’ve made a lot of believers, but more importantly I’m becoming a believer in myself.