3 ms·
Many people talk about proportional representation; my favorite PR system is the "Random Ballot." It is a very simple voting system and is the only voting syst
by aidenn0 8y ago
Many people talk about proportional representation; my favorite PR system is the "Random Ballot." It is a very simple voting system and is the only voting system I know of that never suggests strategic voting (when voting in a way different from your preferences is required to get your preferred outcome).
Basically if you have e.g. 100 seats in your house, you choose 100 ballots at random and whomever is voted for on those ballots are the representatives. It averages out to proportional representation, while still allowing geographically distributed candidates.
It also satisfies all of Arrow's criteria[1], which no deterministic system can.
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow%27s_impossibility_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow%27s_impossibility_theore...
- jhauris 8y agoIsn't detecting fraud harder in a non-deterministic system? Theoretically in any deterministic system you can recount if there's a question.
- DennisP 8y agoYou would definitely need a random source that everyone can verify.
- tzs 8y ago> It also satisfies all of Arrow's criteria, which no deterministic system can. Approval voting is deterministic and satisfies all of Arrow's criteria. Arrow's theorem doesn't apply to voting systems, such as approval voting, that are not ranked choice systems.
- 3pt14159 8y agoI used to be in favour of this one, and talk about it all the time, but I've kinda changed my view. The core problem with most voting systems could be solved with more representatives and just straight proportional representation. In the range of 1 to 10k–100k. Then you do a parliamentary system with one primary chamber that does most of the law making and one secondary chamber that does some checks but is ultimately toothless. A supreme court that can make law, but tends to refer legislation back to the parliament. A clause to allow the primary legislator to override all but the most basic freedoms required for democracy to work like voting and a free press. Essentially Canada, but with proportional representation and maybe double the number of MPs. The problem with random ballots is that unserious people will will or vote for themselves and they're harder to do securely with straight paper ballots that is understandable to laypersons.
- Spivak 8y agoMy ideal voting system would be similar to this but without the actual voting part. Just take a sample of your population until you're some agreed-upon percentage confident you know the preference breakdown of your population and just go with that. If you're going to randomly sample ballots just randomly sample voters and skip the line.