5 ms·
People are missing the point about the integrated graphics. For me this is a feature not a bug because it has USB-C instead. That means that instead of hopeles
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
People are missing the point about the integrated graphics. For me this is a feature not a bug because it has USB-C instead.
That means that instead of hopelessly compromising thermals and power supply with some power hungry, yet limited GPU (because of the small form factor) you simply buy the CPU and memory that you need. It simplifies the job of keeping it cool.
CPUs are evolving a lot slower these days. This one should last you many years before it becomes a problem. Having upgradeable memory all the way to 64GB means that too is not going to be a problem any time soon. It means that a mac mini should have a serviceable life of 3-5 years or more if you are less of a power user.
Additionally, you plugin an eGPU of your choice and additional storage via USB-C. Better, when improved eGPUs become available, you can sell your old one and buy a new one without having to tear the machine apart. They also don't overtax and compromise your power supply or cooling.
I currently have an imac 5K that is nearly 5 years old now. I maxed it out at the time with all the bells and whistles and it has served me well. So, money well spent despite the shocking price initially.
I'd totally consider spending 3-4K on a setup with a mac mini, decent eGPU + monitor, and external ssd storage (I actually have a Samsung 2TB T5 already). The new imac pro would cost more and deliver less value. What I like about this setup is that it is completely modular and I can replace individual components without having to worry breaking the other components.
I imagine the mac pro next year will also emphasize expansion and upgrades through USB-C rather than internals. Basically the old model without dedicated GPU and upgradable Xeon CPUs + Memory would be exactly the right product right now. Egpus can be replaced easily and with a solid base configuration, a pro machine should have a long productive life.
- VHRanger 8y agoYou have small form factor PCs with GPUs. But the exterior won't be as pretty because you have much more thermal to deal with
- whywhywhywhy 8y ago> But the exterior won't be as pretty There are actually plenty of nice looking small form factor PC cases that can house a full GPU - http://www.louqe.com/ http://www.louqe.com/ - https://www.dan-cases.com/dana4.php https://www.dan-cases.com/dana4.php I'd actually say this is one area of the custom PC market that's well served by nice design.
- rado 8y agoThe MBP 15" mobile Radeon Pro is decent and does 4K well. It would only cost Apple 1mm of extra thickness and what, $60? There is no excuse.
- matthewmacleod 8y agoIt's not so much that I want a gigantic GPU, but I'd like something that could just run two external 4K monitors without stuttering. That would make this an excellent general-purpose desktop machine. The 15" 2017 MacBook Pro does this fine, so it's hard to accept that it would be difficult to engineer something into place. Unfortunately, an eGPU is gigantic external box costing a large chunk of change, so it's not really a good option.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoWith a laptop, an external GPU is indeed a big issue in terms of form factor. However in your case, your big 4K monitors are comparatively large as well so having an eGpu that you can also use as docking station is not necessarily the end of the world. Likewise, with a mac mini this should be less of an issue. I'm also guessing this market will develop over the next few years with more attractively priced options aimed at people who just want a middle of the road setup that works reasonably well for games and vr. Right now all the available options are targeted at people who in any case spend too much money on HW. Besides, with Apple you are paying a premium for a dedicated GPU in a macbook, which makes the price of an external eGPU less of an issue. Because if the choice becomes paying 500 euro extra for a mac mini with a last generation laptop grade GPU or spending the same on a eGPU with modest specs (or a bit more on something fancier), that's a lot easier to defend. Especially if you can swap it out once every other year for a new one. I'm guessing that with the mac pro they may offer some options for a dedicated, non upgradable GPU as well as eGPU options. Most professionals would probably prefer investing in the latter because it provides them performance without much compromise and an easy way to upgrade. E.g. I'm still waiting for Apple to make a move with AR/VR, which they sort of support but which they don't really actively promote currently. Anyway, the mac mini is not necessarily that interesting for people looking for cheap options. The start configurations are nice if you don't need much but most more serious users are going to want bigger ssds, more cpu, and more memory. That creeps into the mac pro use case already. I'm guessing that in terms of price segment this thing is designed to fill the gap with the mac pro, which will likely have a starting price of around 5K, just like the last one.
- mijustin 8y agoWhat would you recommend for a Mac-compatible eGPU these days?
- iamdbtoo 8y agoI've been using the Razer Core X for a few months now and it's worked flawlessly.
- iandanforth 8y agoHave you tried swapping it between machines? Could I use an eGPU with say a NUC and the Mac Mini?
- kylec 8y agoThe Blackmagic eGPU is designed to be plug-and-play compatible with Macs. You can even buy it directly from Apple: https://store.apple.com/xc/product/HM8Y2VC/A https://store.apple.com/xc/product/HM8Y2VC/A Also, one nice thing about this eGPU is that it has two Thunderbolt ports, so you can plug a Thunderbolt display like the LG UltraFine 5K directly into it.
- Applejinx 8y agoWell, THAT's interesting. I've been looking at some Blackmagic stuff for streaming and camera work, that would take burden off my desktop computer. It looks like the new Mini plus this plus outboard x264 encoding (also includes ability to run a good dynamic mic into the encoding) would add up to an insanely flexible livestreaming setup that could do both GPU-needing things and camera-based things without loading the computer, and be expandable later with SDI camera inputs and the ability to do production video switching. It… didn't occur to me that I might be thinking about running such a rig off a Mac Mini. But then it didn't occur to me that a Mac Mini would come out and be in some conditions faster than any other Mac currently made. Interesting times…
- 9935c101ab17a66 8y agoI have an HP Omen Accelerator with an RX580 and a 2016 MBPr and it's plug and play in macOS 10.14. Last I checked, you could get most Nvidia GPUs working, but it required some spelunking. It may be different now. I've been very happy with it overall. I have a 4k 28inch monitor and a 30 inch Cinema Display plugged into the GPU, and the eGPU enclosure has a sata port + ethernet port. There are some gotchas, eGPU.io is a great resource. Also, bootcamp with windows 10 works with my eGPU, but required some work. If you want more info, let me know.
- dahauns 8y agoa) You assume that at least some GPU power in SFF wouldn't - be possible (while SFF devices like Hades Canyon et al. with e.g. Kaby Lake-G manage to do just fine without breaking thermals and noise) - still be immensely useful for many/at least better than current integrated Intel (which is a significant step backwards with the dropping of Iris) b) You assume to have USB-C/TB3 instead, when there's no argument against having both. And for anyone really not needing it and arguing about the unneccessary cost - just restrict it to the more expensive SKU, done.
- kayoone 8y agoi like that idea, but I also need a laptop and investing in both seems overkill for my needs. But i guess with a current 6C Macbook and 32GB + eGPU, i could kind of do the same thing.
- aczerepinski 8y agoThat sounds like a horrible mess of wires and power strips to me. If only they could make a single case to fit all these various computer components in, and one chord to supply power to all of them.
- ihuman 8y agoThat doesn't sound like something with "mini" in the name. Maybe an alternative product with "pro" in the name?
- blacksmith_tb 8y agoSure, except the 'trashcan' Pro doesn't have room in it for anything either, it was also designed to daisychain drives etc. via TB. My very elderly 'cheesegrater' Pro of course does have lots of room for 3.5in drives and PCIe cards, but I have wrung about as much as I can out of it, so the new Mini has some appeal. I am skeptical that the new-new Pro of 2019 (assuming it materializes) will be designed with extensibility in mind...
- aczerepinski 8y agoIt was a sarcastic attempt to point out that scattering the components of a computer into 3 or 4 units with separate power chords is an inferior design to the standard desktops we’re used to. I want a Mac desktop for under $3,000 that doesn’t require multiple accessories plugged in to behave like a desktop.
- rbanffy 8y ago> If only they could make a single case to fit all these various computer components in They do. It's called an iMac and comes free with an excellent monitor. Now, seriously, unless you plan to do a lot of GPU computing (I don't) the internal Intel graphics are pretty reasonable. I can't see how a 64 gig mini would not be able to be my main machine for 5 years or more. With an updated SSD, my previous mini is a pretty good general purpose computer.
- lostgame 8y agoWhat's the need for an eGPU if there's enough space for a GPU in the unit? I long for a return to the Powermac G5 'basic tower' form factor.
- hamstergene 8y agoI wish someone made MacMini-sized eGPUs and external disk drives so they could be stacked on top of each other. That'd look very good aesthetically with minimal or no mess of wires. An ITX format video card (~7") should fit into MacMini-sized case (7.7"), not sure about PSU and heat dissipation though.
- vosper 8y agoIf it was the same shape as the MacMini but just taller then it might still look cool stacked.