7 ms·
This article's quality is higher than many others on the same topic and that's a pleasant surprise. That being said, I can't help being reminded about German l
by pdimitar 8y ago
This article's quality is higher than many others on the same topic and that's a pleasant surprise.
That being said, I can't help being reminded about German language lessons I had ~10 years ago where the teacher was preaching that we must all ditch electric kettles for the sake of the planet. I asked her how is this going to help -- even if 100_00 people do it today -- if corporations are happy to let toxic waste seep into the ocean and lobby to never close coal plants. And we're talking thousands of tons a day. She wasn't pleased that I attacked her agenda.
So alright, I know we all can do better, individuals included. That's unequivocally true.
But let's not ignore the fact that the biggest fault lies in organizations that are happy to pay people to whisper stuff in the ears of the people with power.
Climate change is real and the more we delay the solution, the more urgent and extreme the measures to swing it around will become. And that means to start breaking the warm and cozy positions that many corporations are in -- and enjoy the lack of supervision of.
- joelthelion 8y agoAs the article mentions, individuals can do something about corporate pollution: - Buy less stuff. Corporations produce waste because we buy their stuff. Get the stuff you still buy from more environmentally-friendly companies, if possible. - Political action. Corporations need to be regulated and that can only happen through political action. Lobbies may have a lot of power, but in the end, it's the citizens who vote.
- pdimitar 8y ago> Buy less stuff. This is becoming harder and harder with time. Believe me, I would love to buy my kitchen stove, washing machine, refrigerator, aspirator, air conditioner and vacuum cleaner from a local manufacturer. But there are none. How many household brands do really exist and how many are actually known and bought by almost everyone? Additionally, even if you are an idealist who wants to be the change they want to see, you will still need a bunch of tech gadgets to connect with the world and try to change it -- like a good smartphone and laptop that don't suck. Not every $100 piece of trash will do the job. And the cheaper tech might have actually had much more negative impact on the planet's CO2 footprint. It's very complex and thus no black-and-white solutions exist. Some corps like Apple and Samsung seem hellbent on testing the customers' patience with higher prices every year and it will definitely bite them back at one point. That much is true. > Political action. Never in my life, not once, have I seen citizens voting actually change anything of significance in a country. Have you? And we're talking less than 10 years here. "These things take time" seems pretty shallow and empty as a justification for things not happening.
- eeZah7Ux 8y agoPolitical action is much more than just voting and it's been the major source of social changes in the last 200 years.
- pdimitar 8y agoNot where I live, but I am aware that's not representative for the entire world. I am happy for the places where it works. Not sarcastic.
- yread 8y agoUh, you live in a place without weekends, women's voting rights or laws against child labour?
- pdimitar 8y agoI live in Eastern Europe, where drastic social changes only happen if the politicians see a crowd with pitchworks and torches at the town hall. Literally. People around here are just realists because no significant changes ever comes before people get that fed up. Civil discourse and constructive discussion has so far netted us nothing but dossiers and people landing on dissident lists. This happens to this day. No need to be snarky.
- yread 8y ago> pitchforks at the town hall Hey, do you live in Prague https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defenestrations_of_Prague https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defenestrations_of_Prague ? Don't let the czech mentality get to you, people there complain just for fun.
- pdimitar 8y agoBulgaria. :) It's easy to write us off Eastern Europeans as "complaining just for fun" though. Many do but when you get to the bottom of it, real change happens extremely rare. And that's a valid argument and a historical background to have. But regular-complainers and realistic-no-BS-folk often get conflated by external observers -- to my despair.
- oppzixi00 8y ago> it's the citizens who vote The citizens are easily diverted with racist flamebait issues and neofascism. Nothing will be done.
- beaconstudios 8y agoplease don't bring more partisan flame-baiting onto HN.
- grussergraph 8y agoWe are adults. We can just name the problem. It’s capitalism.
- ElBarto 8y agoIndividuals have huge power over pollution in general and corporate pollution in particular. Individuals are in the end the drivers of corporate actions because they are the consumers. It's not necessarily about buying less stuff but about changing your daily actions and about buying only products you consider environmentally friendly. Corporations will produce what sells. We decide what sells through our individual choices and actions. Edit: We can also make it quite plain to corporations: For example, why not ask coffee shops/takeaways how they plan to pack our order before we actually order then walk away if we don't like the answer? If many people start to do that I'm sure things will change fast.
- rezeroed 8y agoStop travelling to work.
- pdimitar 8y agoI work remotely for almost 8 years now. ;)
- Vinnl 8y agoUgh, I once read a booklet that had the same premise of the article. One of the suggested solutions: use less soap when doing the dishes, to preserve packaging. As I mention in a different comment, individual action is important. However, there is a large difference in effectiveness, and promoting obviously ineffective ones isn't going to convince people to do the ones that are likely to be effective.
- pdimitar 8y agoThe cynic in me thinks such articles are commissioned by the lobby groups so as to shift the blame. But I can't prove it so I will not claim it. But you have to wonder.
- eeZah7Ux 8y agoThere's been countless examples of research papers on various topics being sponsored and cherry-picked by companies to manipulate public opinion. Your theory seems extremely likely.
- Vinnl 8y agoThis particular instance was too amateurish and small-scale for that to be the case. But of course, the author might have been influenced by those lobby groups indirectly.
- yitchelle 8y ago> individual action is important. This is critically important, but the mindset of the population need to change for it to be effective. If everyone have the same mindset, things will start to change. Imagine doing a simple thing like reducing your shower time by 25% or reduce your TV watching time by 25%. With enough people doing it, its impact will be significant.
- Vinnl 8y agoI think that's the primary reason why individual action is important: because it achieves the mindset change. Or at least, is a prime motivator in changing other people's mindsets.
- ido 8y agoOff-topic but what's wrong with electrical kettles? was her position to not boil water or to use a different kind of kettle? My Kitchen has electric range so I doubt using a non-electric kettle on it would be any more efficient.
- pdimitar 8y agoThe main argument against them was along the veins of that it draws big amounts of wattage in an initial burst and that we must use "slower" and thus allegedly more sustainable tech. Which is ridiculuous because every electrician will tell you that your home-grade fuses and the switchboard of your house/block handle such loads quite well without much additional strain on... anything, really. I quickly wrote her off as a virtue signaller back then.
- ido 8y agoyeah it sounds like "I sorta once half-heard some thing or another so it must mean electric kettles are forever bad".
- robotbikes 8y agoFor better or worse this is standard practice for how most people get their beliefs about pretty much everything. Some people are more discerning in who they believe and others more skeptical but a lot of people will just add random fact to their knowledge base because they heard it from someone they know.
- yread 8y agoWell, you could make a point that if everyone has powerful appliances at home then the network has to be robust enough to handle quick changes in power needed. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TV_pickup https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TV_pickup So, in a sense, boiling water with gas has less externalities. EDIT: You can of course also argue, if we can't have powerful appliances why bother with electricity at all. I'm just saying it's not an issue that can be so easily dismissed
- pingec 8y agoI'd argue the idea of doing something is a strong one. If people become engaged, if they start thinking about the environment on a daily basis then that is already progress in itself. If that means starting with a kettle sure that's probably not an improvement in itself but I'd say the thought counts. People who take/propose such small steps might later start thinking about other means to improve their footprint on the planet that have a bigger impact. They might start to identify themselves as people who care about the environment. They might start spreading the idea to other people. And one day maybe they will say hey I ditched an electric kettle and made a compromise and what did you do, what are the big corps doing? So I hope you engaged the teacher in a positive tone and proposed how we can all have an even bigger impact.
- throw1118 8y agoOr to many people, they may feel that their everyday 'sacrifices' are enough. "i switch off all the bulbs and recycle all my bags. i should be able to buy that nice SUV i want" Which effect, identifying with environmentalism or i-do-enough-ism, is stronger takes research to find out.
- shoo 8y ago> Have no illusions. To achieve our goal of getting off fossil fuels, these reductions in demand and increases in supply must be big. Don’t be distracted by the myth that “every little helps.” If everyone does a little, we’ll achieve only a little. We must do a lot. What’s required are big changes in demand and in supply. David MacKay https://www.withouthotair.com/c19/page_114.shtml https://www.withouthotair.com/c19/page_114.shtml
- pdimitar 8y agoAwesome read, thank you.
- yqx 8y agoI share your frustration with people who claim it's out own responsibility to change our habits and come up with things like limiting your showers and turning off the lights when you leave the room, but flying less or not owning a car (if realistic in the country you live in) is a completely different ball game and can actually make an huge impact of enough people do it. Of course it's also up to governments to make these couches financially attractive by for example cutting tax breaks for aviation fuel (https://www.aef.org.uk/issues/economics/taxation/ https://www.aef.org.uk/issues/economics/taxation/).
- k_ 8y agoIndividual actions are definitely a start, but yeah it sounds like almost nothing compared to corporations (or even governments, responsible for so many unnecessary plane travels). Is there some data on the actual scale of individual vs corporate pollution / climate-changing faults? Hard to measure, I guess.
- WheelsAtLarge 8y agoThere's a fallacy with this type of thinking. It's something to the effect that "the big bad wolf is causing the trouble, therefore, I'm powerless to do anything" The reason corporations do what they do is because they are providing a service to millions of customers at the lowest cost and the highest profits for them. We, consumers, like to shift all the blame to someone else, it lets us continue as we have without guilt. We need to feel we are powerless so we don't feel bad about not doing anything about the problem. The fix can come from the producers or the consumers or both. Saying that consumers are powerless just continues the inaction until the fix is forced onto all of us by nature. Reducing power consumption and reducing the number of items we buy and eventually throw away is a start. Pushing politicians to make the hard choices is also part of the fix. But saying someone else has all the power, therefore, I can't do anything or I saying I can only do a little therefore I won't bother is not.
- pdimitar 8y agoI, and many others, can definitely do a lot -- but other people have done the math and concluded that we don't amount for anything but a blip in statistics. There is a link in this thread giving the same perspective as well. I'd like the world to start attacking the source of issues top-to-bottom and not bottom-to-top. Can the citizens help? Absolutely. Will they amount for much unless corporations start taking action? No.
- ElBarto 8y agoA very effective way to make corporations take action is citizens making them to. Are you willing to?
- pdimitar 8y agoVery broad and vague question. I'm not throwing away my PC, or MacBook, or iPhone, or iPad, or 35" 144Hz display that consumes 200W. I actually need them and they actually help me live a better life. But sure, I do use less napkins compared to 5 years ago. And I don't have a car (which is insane to have when you live in the center of a city anyway). You'll have to clarify what do you have in mind with your question though.
- ijidak 8y agoI always find the below statement interesting because it is 2,000 years old. But it shows that even 2,000 years ago, the tendency of the human species to destroy the planet was already clear: "But the nations became wrathful, and your own wrath came, and the appointed time came...to bring to ruin those ruining the earth." -- Revelation 11:18 It's interesting that the human tendency to "ruin the earth" is still a problem 2,000 years later. Given that scientists are now saying we're close to the point of no return on climate change, I don't have much confidence humans are going to turn this around... If this problem was listed in a 2,000 year old book, and we're still "ruining the earth" in 2018, I'm not convinced humans as a species are going to have a sudden change of heart in the next 10 years... Just saying..
- wortelefant 8y agothese little actions count; changing consumption patterns creates a signal to the market and to politics. a community of practice concerned about the environment, once set in motion, makes it easier to estimate the political gains of passing new laws, like stricter waste disposal standards. A dedicated minority that genuinely cares about an issues can shift the agenda, even when the majority is largely undecided. When I invite 3 vegans and 7 omnivores to a party, food will be vegan (similar point by N N Taleb). I hope this works out just as well with political parties..