4 ms·
You could make your argument much clearer if you chose an example at least vaguely similar to software, such as books, rather than something completely unlike s
by simonh 8y ago
You could make your argument much clearer if you chose an example at least vaguely similar to software, such as books, rather than something completely unlike software such as a screwdriver. Deliberately choosing something that shares very few characteristics in common with software, when other very common and well understood better examples exist could give the impression you're concealing something. Protecting authored works with a copyright to prevent unauthorized copying is well understood and commonplace and has good economic and social reasons backing it up.
Furthermore even some screwdrivers or similar devices, and many more complex devices are absolutely protected by IP in the form of patents, so even the argument you make is simply untrue in many common everyday cases.
Free libre software licensing has a lot to recommend it, I've published thousands of lines of code under GPLv2. The FSF is a powerful and virtuous advocate of it. However it's not right for everyone in all cases, including me.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoBut software - the best kind of software - is really more similar to a screwdriver than a book. A book is just data, and more useful as an example in discussions about IP/piracy. Software is a tool. My copy of `dd` is my screwdriver. My copy of Emacs is my combine harvester. Software freedoms are connected to the idea that you should be able to own your tools, and use them as you see fit.
- simonh 8y agoI've already pointed out, tools _are_ covered by IP in the from of patents, including some screwdrivers, so arguing we should treat software like we treat tools is walking right into a horrible trap. How can you suggest piracy has nothing to do with licensing? OMG! Piracy (non high-seas type) by _definition_ is the violation of a license. It's almost as though you don't understand fundamentally what liecenses and IP are as concepts. Book and the information in them are tools and are exactly like software. We follow recipes in cook books, we follow DIY guides, we type code from books into computers and run it, we enjoy literary and visual printed entertainment. Programs are texts in the general sense, that's literally what they are.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> I've already pointed out, tools _are_ covered by IP in the from of patents, including some screwdrivers, so arguing we should treat software like we treat tools is walking right into a horrible trap. It's not as much walking into a trap as it is showing that the way physical goods are covered by IP laws is starting to get ridiculous as well. Software just makes this painfully visible. > OMG! Piracy (non high-seas type) by _definition_ is the violation of a license. Maybe in case of videogames it is, but I'd say it's arguable. Books, movies & music don't generally come with license agreements. Piracy is first and foremost a copyright violation. > Book and the information in them are tools and are exactly like software. We follow recipes in cook books, we follow DIY guides, we type code from books into computers and run it, we enjoy literary and visual printed entertainment. You're confusing form with function. Software may be like books in its form - strings of numbers encoded on a physical substrate, to be read by a machine - but is totally unlike books in its function. `cp` isn't a book, it's a digital equivalent of a photocopier. Photoshop isn't cooking recipe, it's a digital equivalent of a 1950-era photo studio. Most software functions as tools that transform digital stuff into other digital stuff, but when you connect appropriate hardware, software becomes a tool affecting physical world. > Programs are texts in the general sense, that's literally what they are. If you want to go there... in this sense, screwdrivers are text too, because OpenSCAD drawings describing them are text, and G-codes driving CNC machines are text too.
- simonh 8y ago>Piracy is first and foremost a copyright violation. Copyrights and patents are licenses. The first statute establishing copyright was called the 'Licensing of the Press Act 1662'. '...ownership in copyright includes exclusive licenses of rights'. >...in this sense, screwdrivers are text too No they really aren't, they're objects which is why the laws around their ownership and transfer are fundamentally different, the design though is intellectual property and is a text. It's information. In your original post you said a screwdriver can be freely copied - no it can't, not if it's patented and many of them actually are. This basic error comes from a fundamental miss-understanding about the nature of these things. If you look closely at why you came to that incorrect conclusion you might start to get to grips with this. Information and physical objects are not similar in the way you think they are.