4 ms·
> Ambulances are very expensive and should be reserved for people who actually need them. Lol what? It's the job of the state to provide adequate resources (fo
by mschuster91 8y ago
> Ambulances are very expensive and should be reserved for people who actually need them.
Lol what? It's the job of the state to provide adequate resources (for example, the law in Germany requires that emergency personnel be at your location in 10min tops, on average). Telling people to use an Uber/Lyft/cab due to cost concerns or not enough ambulances being available is bad. Demand proper emergency services funding from your politicians!
Obviously: when all you got is a small cut on your finger, fine, take public transport or whatever. But for a back injury?! No way in hell I'd risk my chance in public transport or taxi.
- c22 8y agoLol, in the US ambulances are often run by private companies and the bill is delivered to the patient. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_medical_services_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_medical_services_in_...
- eknkc 8y agoHoly shit. Forget Uber, you better be able to walk to Canada or something.
- slavik81 8y agoIt is not cheap to take an ambulance in Canada. In my province, they cost $250-$400 per trip. You do not call an ambulance unless you actually need medical attention at the scene or en route to the hospital.
- cavanasm 8y agoIn the US, an ambulance trip can cost thousands. Also, if after being treated / examined, your insurance decides you didn't need the ambulance, they often won't cover it.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoMuch better than the alternative where everyone pays and sometimes poor people use them /s
- mschuster91 8y agoI know. But I still cannot believe what I'm reading. Not as a German. When I call an ambulance and get delivered to the hospital, I don't have to worry about anything financial related aside from a bit of copay for the hospital stay, but that's it.
- aembleton 8y agoCost a friend from the UK €500 to get an ambulance in Germany. She was covered by her insurance but it was still a bit of a surprise for us as we don't charge anything for an ambulance.
- mschuster91 8y agoThis situation might be because the ambulances are operated by NHS which is also UK health insurance, therefore for citizens no charges apply. Similar thing in Germany: the ambulances directly bill w/ health insurances, nothing needed except the insurance cards. Now, the NHS may not charge German patients themselves for an ambulance ride in UK but either quietly deal directly with the German insurance to get the cost back, or eat it entirely because the administrative overhead would cost more than the fees paid by German insurance would actually bring in - while the German ambulance operator might have decided to put the administrative burden on your friend. tl;dr: international health care insurance/refunds are weird, avoid if possible...
- modeless 8y agoNo matter how many resources you have, using them inefficiently is bad. Dispatching a team of on-call paramedics with specialized emergency equipment to non-emergency situations is bad.
- ethelward 8y agoWhich is why we have, at least in France (and AFAIK, in most of Europe), different kind of ambulances depending on the gravity of the case. The hospital won't send an ambulance with ER stuff for a guy who don't need it.
- de_watcher 8y ago> Which is why we have, at least in France (and AFAIK, in most of Europe), different kind of ambulances depending on the gravity of the case. In France firemen do a very big chunk of that work with their ambulances.
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoWhat if you think you can go by Lyft and then collapse and die? You feel bad, get a Lyft and have an heart attack? Or you had a mild hard attack and think Lyft works whereas you need medical treatment immediately? You fell from a machine and have a broken arm and go by Lyft, whereas you inner injuries and collapse in the Lyft drive to hospital? I assume you're a doctor and able to perform a medical analysis on the accident, so you're fine to go with Lyft. I better call the emergency service and let them decide what would be the best way to go forward depending on my symptoms/injury.
- arrrg 8y agoIn the abstract that is certainly true, but you are missing the bigger picture. You are acting as though people are somehow able to discern what is and isn’t an emergency and decide that all by themselves with perfect accuracy. The point here is that it is preferable to sometimes use resources badly in order to avoid sometimes not at all using the resource when it would be necessary. The point is to not discourage people from calling 911 (or the local equivalent). If there actually are constrained resources† then, sure, that cultural value should probably be set somewhat differently, but I cannot for the life of me imagine why that should be the case in the US. It’s not necessary to set that value differently. (If it were that would be a real shame for US healthcare and you should demand immediate change from your political representatives.) — † I am aware that at some point all resources are constrained. What I’m talking about here is that the system should be designed in such a way that there is spare capacity availible at all times when looking at the maximum number of required ambulances at the same time during, say, the past twelve months.
- Udik 8y ago> Lol what? It's the job of the state to provide adequate resources Isn't it the same with ER? People are severely discouraged from using ER for any concern that doesn't require an immediate action. ERs, like ambulances, are services whose time and resources need to be highly available for those who really need them.
- mschuster91 8y ago> People are severely discouraged from using ER for any concern that doesn't require an immediate action There's a conflict right now in Germany, as many people turn to the ERs instead of primary care practitioners or specialized doctors (e.g. urologists), as for ordinary people it's next to impossible to get a timely appointment. This, again, has the reason that specialized practices reserve the "timely" slots for higher paying privately insured patients, and that the distribution of general practitioners as well as their supply is a bit... mismanaged, leading to either the practices not being open at times when people are not working (in contrast to a 24/7 ER) or horribly overcrowded.