6 ms·
Don't mistake this booklet for "protect and survive" which was handed out in the 1970s and 1980s. this was the precursor work. I was the lucky recipient of "pr
by ggm 8y ago
Don't mistake this booklet for "protect and survive" which was handed out in the 1970s and 1980s. this was the precursor work.
I was the lucky recipient of "protect and survive" in my terrace house in York in the 1980s. We blithly understood the staircase was our best bet, both for initial blast protection and ultimate entombment. The Raymond Briggs cartoon book "when the wind blows" felt more realistic to most of us.
I did not enjoy watching Peter Watkins "the war game" which was with-held from general broadcast and mostly only seen in film societies. It wasn't exactly hyper realistic, but it was chillingly unpleasant. It was dated by the time I saw it (shot in B&W I believe, and in the sixties so over 15 years old by the time I first saw it)
- Jaruzel 8y ago> Don't mistake this booklet for "protect and survive" which was handed out in the 1970s and 1980s. this was the precursor work. They mention that further down the article. > The Raymond Briggs cartoon book "when the wind blows" felt more realistic to most of us. When The Wind Blows is a must read/watch in my opinion. Having first seen it just after it came out (I read the book much later), the emotional impact of it has never left me.
- nivertech 8y agoIs there a connection between: "When The Wind Blows" and "When Shit Hit The Fan" (SHTF) ?
- andyjohnson0 8y agoWhen the Wind Blows is a allusion to the children's nursery thyme "Rock-a-bye Baby" [1]: Rock-a-bye baby On the tree tops, When the wind blows, The cradle will rock When the bough breaks, The cradle will fall, and down will come Baby, Cradle and all. In the context of Brigg's book/film, its seems clear that the bough (tree branch) that breaks is the disaster of nuclear war and the cradle/baby is us/civilisation falling down. I guess that a child-like reference emphasises the horror of the subject by way of contrast. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rock-a-bye_Baby https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rock-a-bye_Baby
- setquk 8y agoTrailer for when the wind blows here: https://youtu.be/4h1lRqUBuSI https://youtu.be/4h1lRqUBuSI This was devastating at the time as it was about right. Incidentally if you’re UK based or in the UK, a good day out is Kelvedon Hatch “secret nuclear bunker”. Protect and Survive is everywhere. Lots of scary information video feeds throughout it as well.
- jsmith99 8y agoI saw some of The War Game at a nuclear bunker near Cheshire. I think it ended with the protagonist screaming as she saw her (presumably deformed) newborn. Hard to believe the BBC made this.
- agurk 8y agoI haven't seen The War Game, but that's the ending from Threads (and Wikipedia lists a different ending for The War Game). Threads is an interesting film from the 1980s, with a very bleak tone about the prognosis after a full scale nuclear conflict. I have read modern analyses of it that suggest it was perhaps too pessimistic in the long term effects.
- arethuza 8y agoAs I note elsewhere in this thread (!) while Threads might have been pessimistic about long term impact (e.g. nuclear winter) it is actually fairly optimistic about the scale of a Soviet nuclear attack on the UK.
- agurk 8y agoThat raises an interesting point that was not covered in the plot of Threads - the strategy behind the nuclear exchange and how it played out globally. You're certainly right, that at one stage the plans the Soviet Union had for the UK resembled what the UK did to Heligoland. In the film, if the West had initiated the exchange with a surprise counter-force first strike, they could have potentially disabled a significant proportion of the Soviet Union's strike ability. If this were the case, one of the morals of the film would have been that even if the majority of enemy warheads are destroyed, they'll still have enough to destroy you. Another scenario is that the Soviet Union went first with a limited strike, and the West retaliated destroying any further offensive capability. There are also scenarios where counter measures worked, devices were a lot less reliable than expected and so on. Thankfully none of this was ever played out, but there is a whole spectrum between nothing and everything (and the politics - MAD, et al) to go with it.
- neilwilson 8y agoI still have occasional nightmares about Threads (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threads https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threads). Mostly about the milk bottle melting. Possibly the scariest TV show I've ever watched - largely because it was set just down the road in Sheffield.
- arethuza 8y agoAnother one that literally gave me nightmares at the time was "QED: A Guide to Armageddon": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9GJttnC8PoA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9GJttnC8PoA You almost got the idea that the BBC didn't approve of nuclear warfare. NB A thing worth noting about Threads is that is based on a nuclear attack scenario that is regarded as rather optimistic - a real Soviet attack would probably have been much worse: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square_Leg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square_Leg
- secfirstmd 8y agoThreads is outstanding. I rarely if ever had a nightmare after watching something but that movie is so frightening and depressing that the first time I watched it I could barely force myself out of bed the next day. Incredible work by the BBC.
- andyjohnson0 8y agoSame with me. I was seventeen in 1984 when it was first shown but didn't see it at the time. I finally watched it a few years ago and had a night of unusually disturbed sleep followed by two days that were mentally tinged with vague feelings of doom and contamination. Not something I'd want to experience again.
- 7000skeletons 8y agoI was born after the Berlin wall came down, so I got to miss all the fun of living under constant threat of looming nuclear annihilation, but Threads still had a profound effect on me when I watched it. It may be dated now, sure, but it still hits with a hell of a force.
- 8y ago
- tragomaskhalos 8y agoPerhaps it's a British thing, but fear of nuclear war was always intertwined in the culture with a deep cynicism about the clear inadequacy of the advice given to the population in the event of an attack; the 'core' in the article, viz a lean-to made out of a door with stuff piled on top, brings to mind the protagonists in 'when the wind blows' obsessively trying to remember to remain in this alleged sanctuary even as radiation poisoning destroys them.
- InclinedPlane 8y agoAlso an American thing. People assumed it would all just be over if there was a big nuclear exchange and all the talk about "duck and cover" was just to make people feel like they had a chance when they didn't.
- eecc 8y agoHow about Threads? (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0090163/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0090163/) I watched it just a couple years ago and ffs it got me into a sombre mood for a month at least...
- twic 8y agoPeter Watkins has made some amazing films. Although also often rather long and hard going (one of them, Wikipedia tells me, is the longest non-experimental film ever made!). Punishment Park is worth seeing. I liked Evening Land, although i wouldn't recommend it unless you really, really like union politics.