36 ms·
Anyone can use the apps, but executives say they hope to improve voter turnout particularly among young Democrats. The VoteWithMe app, for instance, is preset t
by keiferski 8y ago
Anyone can use the apps, but executives say they hope to improve voter turnout particularly among young Democrats. The VoteWithMe app, for instance, is preset to show likely Democrats among a user’s contacts. Users must change the app’s settings to see the voting histories of all of their contacts.
This, combined with the “Our Trusted Partners” section, clearly shows that this isn’t about getting people out to vote in order to strengthen the democratic process - it’s about supporting a particular political party.
As an independent, this is really troubling. It will only result in more tribalism and more shaming for having “undesirable” party registration. Yeah, your actual vote is still private. But considering that mere membership of a party has been an issue in the past, this isn’t very reassuring.
Then again, maybe it will lead to an implosion of the party system and a shift to independent voters.
- davidw 8y ago> Then again, maybe it will lead to an implosion of the party system and a shift to independent voters. Ranked Choice voting would generally be a good move in that direction. Edit I'm also going to add that this isn't a great time to sit on the fence: https://www.economist.com/leaders/2018/11/03/why-the-mid-terms-matter https://www.economist.com/leaders/2018/11/03/why-the-mid-ter... https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2018/11/04/election-referendum-trump-corrosive-changes-american-politics-column/1871790002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2018/11/04/election-r...
- bhauer 8y agoYes. Score voting or approval voting would be my preference. Easier to use and even more expressive for voters. https://electology.org/score-voting https://electology.org/score-voting https://www.counted.vote/ https://www.counted.vote/
- dragonwriter 8y agoScore and approval have inconsistent meaning for ballot markings, and are for that reasons bad mechanisms unless that is resolved (approval is ideal for choosing group activities where either voting approve is a commitment to participate if that option wins or disapprove is a binding opt-out.)
- faitswulff 8y agoI just learned about approval voting and it has my...approval. Jokes aside, "upvoting" all the candidates I approve seems much more doable than ranking the candidates in order of merit, especially given that there are a lot of candidates running.
- davidw 8y agoApproval feels a bit too binary to me. I like the idea of scoring or ranking. Not sure how scoring doesn't get gamed by people giving 10's to the ones they like, ad 1's to the ones they don't, though.
- somebodythere 8y agoIt's not gaming the system, range voting is robust to such an expression of voter preferences. However, there is something to be said for simplifying the system if that ends up being the way that most people vote.
- ClayShentrup 8y agoScoreVoting.net/Honesty
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoGamed? Surely this is exactly how it's intended to work?
- dgzl 8y agoDon't think of score of 1 as being 1/10, think of it as being an additional 1 point in a cumulative game. Insert saying about saving pennies here
- bhauer 8y agoIMO "gamed" is a bit of a strange choice of word. The whole point of score voting is to give each voter more power to express their true preference. If their preference is to assign top scores to several candidates, fantastic, thank you for your vote! If the next voter prefers to give more diversified scores, wonderful, thank you for voting! And if the next voter would prefer to rank order the candidates, you can do that too using score, so great, thank you for voting! Yes, if you are highly strategic and acutely fear some popular candidate(s), you might give maximum scores to all candidates of which you approve to minimize loss risk. But again, great. That doesn't seem like "gaming" things to me. With score, voters leave the ballot box feeling they were able to express their preferences and therefore have less regret about their votes. Incidentally, I feel in the long term, approval or score voting would do more to improve the satisfaction people have with voting thereby increasing participation than all of today's "get out the vote" drives have had.
- simplify 8y agoAnd here's an excellent interactive resource to better understand pros/cons of different vote systems: https://ncase.me/ballot/ https://ncase.me/ballot/
- somebodythere 8y agoI used to be an ordinal-method purist, but I realized that approval voting is still (much) better than FPTP mathematically, and is also a win in terms of usability and understandability versus most ordinal systems. Usability of a ballot system is a big factor when it comes to voter engagement and turnout, so at this point, I would be very happy with approval-method ballots.
- smichel17 8y agoAlternatively, score voting but using letter grades (ABCDF) instead of numbers. Everyone who's had a small amount of education can understand that.
- Ntrails 8y agoHow does the abstraction of order from number to letter help people understand what is required? Or is the concern the possibility of confusion around "rank 1-5" vs "Score candidates out of 5" etc
- moate 8y agoThat's a bold assumption. I think that numbers have less cultural understanding needed. Letter grades are common, but not ubiquitous. Some schools just use % based "grades" and the 4.0 GPA system. If you say "Each candidate can be given up to 5 points, or as few as 0 points. There are no limits to the number of points you can give out in total (there are X candidates, so you could give a max of [X*5] points)." you're being pretty succinct and direct in the explanation. You might need more poll workers the first few years (which will create all kinds of problems because areas attempting to minimize voter turn out can exploit that) but once it becomes common you hope that people are used to it and know how the system works
- ClayShentrup 8y agoStarlane.us
- 8y ago
- dgzl 8y agoI had this idea several years ago, but didn't really know how to talk about it. Essentially, if voters can attribute a value (between 0 and 10, let's say) to every candidate they like, then we can see a better picture of who the country likes. For instance if I want Candidate A to win, I'll give him a 10. But if I'm only half bought into candidate B, I can give them 5, and could give Candidate C nothing because I really don't like them. Now if the rest of the country doesn't like A, and the battle is between B and C, then I'd feel good that I could contribute to the goal. The actual process is up for remix of course, but that was the idea.
- mywacaday 8y agoMaybe proportional representation is close to what you're thinking. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_representation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_representation or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_transferable_vote https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_transferable_vote
- jwally 8y agoDan Carlin (hardcore history - which is awesome btw, and common sense) mentioned a couple of ideas that sounded interesting. I’m sure he’s not the inventor of the concepts and I have no idea how they’d actually work, but sounded similar to what you’re talking about. One would work where you have 1 vote per ballot item. If there were 24 ballot items, you get 24 votes. You can allocate your votes across the ballot however you saw fit. If you thought president and senate were more important than city council and an infrastructure bond; you could put 18 votes for president, 6 votes for senate, and nothing for local issues. No idea how this would be normalized but it’s a novel concept. Another idea is to rank options in each issue, and if my first option loses; my votes go to the second option. Say I wanted to vote libertarian for president in the US but was afraid it was a protest vote that wouldn’t win so I voted Democrat because I didn’t like the GOP candidate. Under this system I could say I want the libertarian candidate first, democrat second, and not pick the gop candidate. After the votes were counted and the libertarian lost, my vote would be reallocated to the democrat; and the votes would be re-tallied. This would encourage people to vote for a non binary political candidate since they knew their vote wouldn’t be “thrown away”.
- ClayShentrup 8y agoReformFargo.org StarLane.us
- zamalek 8y agoWhile I immensely agree with these approaches, it is unlikely to change with the current incumbents (as they have perfected strategies for the current system).
- fabianhjr 8y agoHey David, I suggest you take a look into Range Voting (Approval Voting being a case of 2-Range Voting), Score Then Automatic Runoff (STAR), and 3-2-1 Voting (V321). Additionally Reweighted Range Voting as a very good Proportional Representative method.
- MrsPeaches 8y agoNicky Case has a great explorable explination for different voting systems and their flaws: https://ncase.me/ballot/ https://ncase.me/ballot/
- C1sc0cat 8y agoNope for the US getting rid of 18th century style primaries move to OMOV One Member One Vote for selecting candidates. This would freeze out the fringe candidates and also save a metric FT of $. Having the national Dem and Rep party get a fracking grip on the conventions and bring the rules into the 21st century would help, I am sure Tony Blair or George Brown would be able to give insights into fighting militant.
- beaconstudios 8y agodid you mean Gordon Brown?
- C1sc0cat 8y agoOpps yes for non UK political wonks George Brown was 60's/70's Labour politician famous for Liquid Lunches.
- bliblah 8y ago>Ranked Choice voting would generally be a good move in that direction. There's a wide array of voting options that can be implemented with their own pros and cons. I really enjoyed this resource: http://www.cgpgrey.com/politics-in-the-animal-kingdom/ http://www.cgpgrey.com/politics-in-the-animal-kingdom/
- iosDrone 8y agoWow, thanks for telling all of us how to think. That USA Today column really profoundly altered my views.
- duckMuppet 8y agoActually, many places you need to be registered to a particular party to vote in the primary, which actually might be more important as you are actually selecting the candidate.. Registering as an independent, leaves the selection process up to the registered party members, or those who are motivated enough to get out there. Those folks typically don't necessarily look to out forth a candidate who's moderate, instead you get, Trump, Clinton, Sanders or Cortez. There's something to be said for registering to a particular party to select a proper candidate. The stigma associated with being registered to a particular party leads many to register as an independent, which means their voice generally isn't heard until the candidate is chosen. It's unfortunate this data is public, it's even more so that politics has become so much of an identity for people that they can't see past it.
- umanwizard 8y agoSanders lost the nomination, and Clinton is absolutely a moderate.
- gaius 8y agoClinton is absolutely a moderate. That’s an odd thing to say, because Clinton never talked about policy. Sanders talked about free healthcare and education. Trump talked about building the wall. But all Clinton ever said was that it was her turn. Similarly their supporters all echoed those policies, except Clintons who were just “with her” in a policy vacuum. So you can’t assert that she was moderate because no one knew (or cared) what her policies actually were!
- matt4077 8y agoThat's a blatant lie. - We're going to make the biggest investment in new jobs since World War II. - a new modern electric grid to be able to take in clean, renewable energy - I have a plan to install a half a billion solar panels by the end of my first term - give a tax credit to any company that is willing to pay a young person while that young person is learning the job - extending broadband access to every place in America. - We've got to return technical education to our high schools, our community colleges. - a moratorium for three years on student debt - we should raise the national minimum wage and on and on and on... Note the annotation explaining that while this stump speech, the one she held about 400 times, mostly just includes the headlines, there was a long, printed/online program with further specifics. Also note that she does not say it was "her turn". But you already knew that, didn't you? Read it yourself: https://www.npr.org/2016/09/15/493924325/inside-hillary-clintons-stump-speech-annotated?t=1541501342701 https://www.npr.org/2016/09/15/493924325/inside-hillary-clin.... And stop lying. (Yes, I'm making an assumption of bad faith here. Because there's no plausible scenario where the comment I'm replying to would be made by anyone who made even the most cursory but honest attempt to get the facts.)
- baddox 8y agoBut if you’re honest, what value does “strengthening the democratic process” have to you if you think the people in power or resulting policies are bad (unfair, unjust, immoral, bad for the economy, etc.)? Democracy even in the most idealistic description isn’t some inherently good thing. It’s only good if the resulting policies and outcomes are good. Perhaps a staunch deontological ethicist will disagree with me here, and please do let me know. If anything, a higher voter turnout may give a bad regime more confidence, or at least give them a nice talking point about their “mandate.” Note that I absolutely do not intend to infer that any particular party or ideology or policy or even outcome is “the good” one. I mean that each person has their own views on what’s good and bad, and that high voter turnout in favor or opposing politicians or policies are absolutely not good for that person.
- jonathankoren 8y ago>If anything, a higher voter turnout may give a bad regime more confidence, or at least give them a nice talking point about their “mandate.” This is ahistorical. Bad regimes do not need an excuse to talk about how they are The One True Choice Of The People. In fact, bad an unpopular regimes have two very common modus operandis to maintain power, or at least the patina of democratic legitimacy. The first is simply fraudulent elections. We’re taking litteral ballot stuffing, and other unfair and unfree election tactics. The second, which has a long history in the United States, is voter suppression. This is where you make policies that ostensibly applies to everyone and makes elections “safer” or somehow better, but actually makes it harder on groups you think will oppose you from actually voting. Tactics include literacy tests, poll taxes, photographic ids, strict registration requirements that target students, selectively closing polling places early, or simply closing them in certain precincts, targetting strict handwriting or punctuation. Even gerrymandering could be considered election rigging. In all of these suppression cases, the commonality is that the politician is not being chosen by the voters, but rather the politician is choosing the voters.
- baddox 8y agoI completely agree. I don’t think the “mandate” stuff is a significant effect.
- aluren 8y agoWhat if strengthening the democratic process can only be done through the support of a political party? Right now, the Republicans control all branches of the legislative, executive and judiciary, despite Trump having lost the popular vote and Republican leaning demographics being a minority. Such a situation is the combined result of 1) a byzantine 'elector' system in lieu of proper suffrage, 2) Rural, sparsely populated states being given more voice than densely populated states making up the majority of the population, because mumble mumble state rights mumble mumble or something, 3) Copious amounts of gerrymandering resulting in some district borders looking like a Picasso drawing, and 4) Ludicrous voter suppression laws and dispositions hailing all the way back to post-civil war Black disenfranchisement. So I'm not sure how trying to reverse that unjust imbalance with an app is a threat to a democratic process which is by all accounts quite endangered already. Shaming is much less of a big deal than disenfranchising.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- specialist 8y agoYup. I'd only add 5) massive propaganda network. We now have tyranny of the minority. After all the concern trolling about tyranny of the majority. Is this irony? We'll see in a day or two if minority rule is the new norm.
- specialist 8y agoWinning elections has been about motivating one's base and suppressing the opposition's turnout since, well, the beginning. With big data and microtargeting, the belligerents got a lot better. As in down to the individual voter. First with doorbelling, direct mail, and phone banking. Now they've added social media. If you want to stop this ballot chasing, advocate for compulsory voting. (IRV, another suggestion, is one way to break the current duopoly. It'd do nothing about ballot chasing or suppression.)
- specialist 8y agoAny one wanting to better understand ballot chasing could take Axelrod and Rove's new courseware. https://thehill.com/blogs/in-the-know/in-the-know/413138-karl-rove-and-david-axelrod-partner-for-online-politics-class https://thehill.com/blogs/in-the-know/in-the-know/413138-kar... https://www.npr.org/2018/11/05/664280714/rove-and-axelrod-teach-new-generation-of-political-strategists https://www.npr.org/2018/11/05/664280714/rove-and-axelrod-te... I don't know how one learns how to do voter suppression. I suppose you'd have to learn on the job as an election admin. Any county in Wisconsin, Kansas, Georgia would be good places to start.
- rtpg 8y agoWhy would you, as an indepednent, be worried about more people exercising their vote? Isn't this the point of elections? To have more people vote? The fact that disenfranchised people and more disillusioned people happen to vote for a specific party in a two party system is not a coincidence
- mkhpalm 8y agoI'm sure this is controversial but I think an uninformed vote is worse for society than no vote.
- wtallis 8y agoI think this can be the case, especially for local races where the most important issues may have little to do with the major tenets of the national party platforms. But for this election cycle, I think even a minimally-informed vote for any not-Republican candidates will generally be better for society than not voting. The Republican party as it exists today needs to disappear and be replaced by one or more parties that offer sane alternatives to the Democrats, though I despair of this happening without a major restructuring of our election systems.
- rtpg 8y agoDisenfranchised are not necessarily uninformed. They could be plenty informed of the issues, but they took a day off and it turned out the county moved their polling spot the _same morning_ (this happened last week!). They could have been purged from voter records despite not having issues for years (happens all the time). They could have simply moved and forgotten to register. There are a million reasons people can’t vote despite being perfectly equipped to make the right decision
- hobs 8y agoSo should we have tests to vote? https://www.crmvet.org/info/lithome.htm https://www.crmvet.org/info/lithome.htm Are you qualified to vote? Find out! Look how easy it is to register! These comments seem to have little understanding of the history and current context of voting in the USA, the fact that all of these systems are pretexts for those in power to control and remove the rights of the rest of us.
- ubernostrum 8y agoAs an independent, this is really troubling. Nothing is stopping you from going out and putting together get-out-the-vote efforts for "independents". Nothing is stopping you from emulating this model in a way you feel is less distasteful. The only person stopping you is you. If you feel this is a major issue, why aren't you doing anything about it?
- tiles 8y agoThe preset party supports stronger Democratic norms like same-day registration, the other supports Voter ID laws and reducing the number of polling locations. Of course an app encouraging voter maximalism can work in favor of the party that aligns with their goal.
- ericdykstra 8y agoThe parties support the policies that will help them win. Thinking this is an ideological position rather than a tactical one is wrong. If it turned out that Voter ID laws would benefit Democrats, they would support them in an instant.
- damnyou 8y agoTo quote dril: the wise man bowed his head solemnly and spoke: "theres actually zero difference between good & bad things. you imbecile. you fucking moron"
- ericdykstra 8y agoI'm not making a value judgement. edit: I'll also challenge you to find a policy around voting that is supported by a party that simultaneously hurts that party, just because they're principled.
- damnyou 8y agoThe point is it is impossible to talk about politics purely at a meta level without evaluating the stances themselves. It is bad that you are not making a value judgement there. Start making some. To respond to your edit, it is not a coincidence that the party supporting expanded voting rights is the party that's more inclusive in other respects as well.
- ericdykstra 8y agoThis is a ridiculous premise. I made commentary without making a value judgement, and you're telling me it's impossible and that I need to. Then you respond to my question with a value judgement rather than actually answer my question. I don't care about your political opinions, and I don't care to state mine here now.
- shard972 8y agoIt seems like the FBI should investigate this company for foreign ties. If so, this is pretty much hacking the election.
- damnyou 8y agoWhy are you more bothered by some abstract notion of "tribalism" than the real harms only happening to real people today because younger people don't come out to vote as much?
- int_19h 8y ago> maybe it will lead to an implosion of the party system and a shift to independent voters. It won't happen for the same reason why parties emerged to dominate the American politics to begin with. Our electoral system is pretty much entirely first-past-the-post, and that means that whoever can consolidate votes better, wins.
- pluma 8y agoSo? The Republicans are a far-right extremist party by Western standards, the Democrats are centrists at best and center-left at worst. If you want to complain about the political landscape in the US, start by criticizing the electoral system that is heavily biased to a strict two-party system. There's really no legitimate reason to vote Republican anymore.
- cdolan 8y agoI think your comment typifies the tribalism and faction-based shaming that OP was alluding to. Telling Republicans “there is no legitimate reason to vote Republican anymore” is not a logical argument that will win people over.
- pluma 8y agoHere's a logical argument: There are literal nazis running for Republican seats. There are literal nazis in the Republican party. The Republican party hasn't distanced itself from bigoted statements and lackluster "both sides" handwaving about nazi lynch mobs. If you vote Republican you vote for a party that either actively supports nazis among their own or knowingly tolerates them. No, I'm not being hyperbolic. Do you know why people say Charlottesville was a nazi protest? Because there were literal, flag-waving, swastika-adorned nazis chanting anti-semitic, racist and bigoted slogans. The same protest that involved a nazi (or nazi "supporter" if that's more to your taste) charging into a crowd with his car and killing a human being. This isn't tribalism. I'm not even American. I'm German. The post-beerhall NSDAP were "plenty of fine people" too and nobody took them serious when they talked about killing the jews, leftist, homosexuals and other "undesirables". Yes, "not all" Republicans are nazis, but the party has politicians who are either literal nazis or sympathise with nazis. Do you know what people who are not nazis do when they find out their group is being invaded by nazis? They kick them out and make it unmistakably clear nazis aren't welcome.
- ralusek 8y agoI could not disagree with you more. The Republican party is not a far-right extremist party, the Republican party is an extremely confused and poorly defined cooperative between conservatives and liberals. The Democratic party, on the other hand, is increasingly radicalizing and unifying in favor of socialized policies. I think that the American left wing is far more unified and further left as a collective than the heavily fragmented and incoherent right wing. American liberals have effectively been excommunicated from the left wing, and as such are beginning to represent a sort of tentative alliance with the conservatives in opposition to the Democratic party. TL;DR, I think the Democratic party is more cohesive and further left than the highly polarized Republican party is right.
- qubax 8y ago> This, combined with the “Our Trusted Partners” section, clearly shows that this isn’t about getting people out to vote in order to strengthen the democratic process - it’s about supporting a particular political party. Was there ever a doubt? The "article" is just a democratic party propaganda piece. The app is a pro-democratic party app. > As an independent, this is really troubling. As an independent, the most troubling part is how so much of the "news" companies are just a propaganda organizations for one political party. The lack of objectivity and professionalism and decency by so much of the media is troubling. Especially since the media has been brow beating tech companies into being biased just like they are. > Then again, maybe it will lead to an implosion of the party system and a shift to independent voters. I think it'll have the opposite effect. An entrenchment of the party system where the two political parties are even more extreme as only the most loyal members remian.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoI never understood why anyone would cheerfully give to the state their party affiliation let alone tell people how they voted.
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoBecause when you register, that registration document is public record. And it has what you declared. If you want to vote, you HAVE to do this step. No choice in that matter. I walked in our election central and they gave it to me.
- kodablah 8y agoIsn't registering as an independent the equivalent of registering without party affiliation?
- someguydave 8y agoIn some states "independent" is the name of a party. "Unaffiliated" is the correct term.
- 24gttghh 8y agoOr, registered and "unenrolled".
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoThat's fine. Do you know what's still Public Record? "GENDER","DOB","EMAIL","FIRST_NAME","MIDDLE_NAME","LAST_NAME","PhoneNumbers","FULL_ADDRESS","IDENTIFICATION_NUMBER","IDType" if IDType is DLN, then IDENTIFICATION_NUMBER is your drivers license. if IDTYPE is DOBSS, then its the month/day/year/last4 SSN Frankly, this should not be public record. This would be a breach notification if it was a company doing it. But I walked in to election central, and they PLUGGED in my usb stick into their computers. I could have been a bad actor and had powershell or ironpython exploits - but i'm not that person.
- unstuckdev 8y agoSolving the problem "low turnout" requires getting people to vote. When people who don't vote are turned out, they tend to vote D. Strengthening the democratic process and increasing turnout for Democrats are currently the same thing.
- specialist 8y agoShort of compulsory voting, there just a handful of ways to boost turnout (participation). In order: Universal, automative voter registration. Like very other mature democracy. Vox's "Why America needs automatic voter registration" segment is a good primer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hd5Qs0fc_I0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hd5Qs0fc_I0 Competitive races. Because then people feel their vote matters. This means fair redistricting, probably based on measure of wasted votes. Threatening people's right to vote sometimes motivates participation. I don't recommend such exteme measures. Early evidence is that free postage on mail ballots boost turnout ~4.5%. We'll see. Mail balloting weakened the culture of voting. Seeing your neighbors and family vote increases the peer pressure. Like the top OC, there have been a few weak efforts to use social media as a substitute. Put motivating cultural wedge issues on the ballot. Homophobia, corporate welfare, war on drugs for the right. Anything pro human or fact based for the left.
- tomjen3 8y agoDane here, we consistently get 85+ with no compulsory voting. Yes we have universal registration, but we also have a system where more than one party can win, which I think is much more important. People can be motivated to overcome challenges if they have a good reason.
- mikeash 8y agoOf course they’ll concentrate on what helps the side they prefer. And this is an extremely benign way to do it. They’ve made a general tool and then they’re using it preferentially. It’s no different than sending people to knock on doors to ask them to vote and concentrating on neighborhoods that tend to vote your way, and it’s miles better than sending misinformation to neighborhoods that vote the other way, or threatening people by implying that you’ll tell their neighbors if they vote the wrong way. (Both réal examples, by the way.)
- admax88q 8y agoThe party system is a natural consequence of democracy. The accomplish anything its always more effective to organize with like minded people and work together.