4 ms·
What has happened to HN? The second paragraph of the article explains quite clearly that these apps display only the fact of a ballot having been cast, not the
by ajross 8y ago
What has happened to HN? The second paragraph of the article explains quite clearly that these apps display only the fact of a ballot having been cast, not the votes. Yet I count no less than seven posts here railing about exactly the wrong thing.
Yes, people: the secret ballot is an important part of democracy, and this has nothing to do with that. To be sure, it's one of those social network paradigms that have unindended consequences. And those are worth discussing. But only if you read the article!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 8y ago> Yes, people: the secret ballot is an important part of democracy, and this has nothing to do with that. After downloading the VoteWithMe app, I call major bullshit on this. The app shows big "Rs" or "Ds" next to folks based on whether they voted in a Democratic or Replublican primary. I do of course realize this was not private information previously, but when the vast majority of viable candidates are from one of the too major parties, that big R or D would seem to take a huge part of the "secret" out of the secret ballot.
- ajross 8y agoYou genuinely feel that registering with a party so you can vote in its primary elections is... a violation of the idea of a secret ballot? I'll just come out and say it: people who have problems with this aren't worried about the sanctity of elections at all. They're personally worried about being outed to their friends as holding political beliefs other than those they present to their peer group. If you don't want people to know you're a republican, change your registration.
- friedman23 8y agoGood thinking, that way republicans can self select for even more extremism. I truly hope that you don't ever need to live in fear of having your political beliefs exposed to your co workers or boss.
- ajross 8y agoAnd like I said upthread, that's an interesting discussion to have. But it's not about secret ballots or voting behavior.
- pluma 8y ago"Even more extremism"? Trump dropped the dogwhistling and euphemisms for outright bigotry. That was unthinkable because it was supposed to be political suicide. Yet Republicans are entirely unmoved by it. If you vote Republican you're already fine with being on the side cheered on by literal nazis. I don't think "pushing the Republicans towards more extremist positions" is a legitimate concern at this point anymore. That's literally the reasoning Jewish moderates used in the 30s: take the moral high ground so people will realise the nazis are the bad guys. That never works. Not if the opponent values the ends over playing by the rules.
- chiefalchemist 8y ago"...violation of the idea of a secret ballot"? Maybe not. But a twist on gerrymandering (i.e., manipulation of the market)? Yes. Absolutely. A collusion by the two ruling parties to corner the market in a cartel-ish sort of way? Yes again. Sure, it's been normalized, but that doesn't make it healthy. If we truly want more and more diverse voices to be heard then we must be willing to address the system(s) that in one way or another prevent that from happening (i.e., maintain the status quo).
- dionidium 8y ago> You genuinely feel that registering with a party so you can vote in its primary elections is... a violation of the idea of a secret ballot? Yes, especially since there's no reason to require it. In Missouri, where I'm from, there is no party registration. They ask you at the polls if you want a Republican ticket or a Democratic one. No record of your choice is kept. While it's true that you could construct an epistemological and philosophical argument that party registration doesn't reveal votes, everybody knows, in a practical sense, that that's exactly what it does.
- mikeash 8y agoA decent number of people vote in the opposing party’s primaries, either because the general election is a foregone conclusion and it’s the only way they’ll have any real input, or to vote for the worst candidate in order to give their own party a better chance. I think that requiring people to declare an affiliation ahead of time is bad. And making it completely secret might be a decent goal. But recording which primary you voted in seems fine too.
- dionidium 8y agoBy one account, something like 5% of voters engage in "crossover voting" for the first reason you gave ("it’s the only way they’ll have any real input") and almost nobody for the latter reason ("to vote for the worst candidate in order to give their own party a better chance"). If you see a D or an R next to somebody's name in this app, then you know who they voted for with pretty high confidence. http://www.latimes.com/local/politics/la-me-pol-california-politics-20150222-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/politics/la-me-pol-california-p...
- justtopost 8y agoI admit to having done both types of crossover voting. I personaly loathe the party system and those that perpetuate it. I have zero alegiance to any 'party', as they have similar feelings toward me. Its like sports favoritism, except with very real consequences. Partisanship makes me sick and deeply ashamed for those involved.
- xcfsadfasdfas 8y ago"They're personally worried about being outed to their friends as holding political beliefs other " Let's change the scenario a bit to make you uncomfortable with your proto-fascism: - Imagine a pro-civil rights Southerner in 1950s having their GOP party affiliation available at a swipe. - Or a gay person in the Bible Belt today. See its not just coastal elites that would badger and harass others. Frankly, I feel quite fortunate that, as a non-citizen, I cannot vote and therefore I don't have to justify not participating (I do not believe in the farce that are your elections). But this dangerous app and the bigoted attitude towards others from ppl like you could cause some grief for my wife (who votes and is a registered Dem, btw)
- pessimizer 8y agoYour particular peer group is causing you to see this as a distinction. If you want to vote in the Democratic primary in Indiana, and your family are born-again Trump Republicans who would be happy to ostracize for being a registered Democrat, you're having exactly the same problem. There's little difference in my mind between saying "if you don't want everybody you know or do business with to know you're a Democrat, you shouldn't vote in the primaries" and "if you don't want everyone knowing you voted for Obama, you shouldn't vote!"
- daenz 8y ago>The second paragraph of the article explains quite clearly that these apps display only the fact of a ballot having been cast, not the votes. No, that is not the only thing these apps display. From the article: >depending on the state, it can include details like their name, address, phone number and party affiliation and when they voted. Emphasis mine. And if you don't think party affiliation is a big deal, then you haven't been listening to the rhetoric used to describe the parties lately.
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoParty affiliation is already public record in many states. I don’t understand the concern.
- tk75x 8y agoIt's one thing for it to be public record where every person who wants to know has to make the effort to look it up. It's a different scenario entirely when thousands of people have access to that information via an easy-to-use app. Now, the likelihood of someone in your social group who disapproves of your political beliefs finding out is much higher. I believe we are all entitled to our privacy and shouldn't be singled out for things like political party affiliation.
- mikeash 8y agoLobby your state government to make that information secret, or end official party affiliation altogether. In the age of ubiquitous internet access, it’s no longer reasonable to expect any publicly available information to remain obscure.
- belorn 8y agoHere in Sweden there has been several alternatives which all puts barriers in front of public information in order to prevent it being accessible through the internet. One method is to simply not allow people to copy it. I can go to the department and request the information, but I can't leave the building with any digital or physical copy (photoing inside is forbidden). Technically within the legal definition of public information. The other method is using copyright to grant permission for private use but not distribution, which mean no one has permission to put the public information online. That way its publicly available to request from the department but it will not be published online. The third method is not really a method but simply relying on the gdpr. The information may be public but there are still legal limits on the kind of databases people may have about private information.