17 ms·
It's humorous how willing they are to build HQ2/3 in areas already with high rent and income. They probably have the money and the will to create a new city and
by unethical_ban 8y ago
It's humorous how willing they are to build HQ2/3 in areas already with high rent and income. They probably have the money and the will to create a new city and public transit system out of a pliable town. Why not do that?
It's not so simple and I'm not quite so naive... but it would be interesting if high paying jobs went to places with decent weather and reasonable land prices.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoWhy spend your own dollars when you can consume the infrastructure of other cities without having to pay for it? Property taxes will rise, slowly, as property values increase due to the greater demand in these cities, but not enough (nor fast enough) to offset the infrastructure burden incurred by Amazon.
- iscrewyou 8y agoAnd cities can in turn tax the people. Therefore, actually make your own employees pay for it.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoUnfortunately, you'd be raising taxes on everyone in your taxing district (not against taxes, against poor economic abstractions). It's an indirect subsidy to large corporations like this. I'd prefer a headcount tax on the business; you demand a butt in a seat somewhere, you're paying for the infrastructure to get your employee to that seat. Very similar to CDD fees (one time or annually [paying off bonds]) in the case of residential real estate development.
- closeparen 8y agoWhat’s special about the present moment? Was it improper to subsidize all the other firms operating in those areas? Do 1980 transplants owe 1970 transplants a higher tax rate to offset the undue burden they imposed? Municipalities tend to pursue growth intentionally. Facilitating business activity is often the explicit purpose of an infrastructure investment.
- toomuchtodo 8y ago> What’s special about the present moment? Is today special? Must there be a special day when better decisions are made? There is no reason whatsoever for Amazon to be provided any sort of subsidy or tax benefits at their size and scale, most especially from existing residents who were not involved in the selection process.
- closeparen 8y agoIf we made “better decisions” from the beginning, would New York be New York, or farmland?
- RhysU 8y agoNew York state has farmland, yes. What are you getting at?
- closeparen 8y agoNew York City is New York City because of extensive government subsidies and public works projects facilitating private businesses and their transplant employees. If they hadn’t done that, had made “better decisions,” there wouldn’t be a New York City.
- outside1234 8y agoTalent doesn't want to work in the middle of nowhere. I wish it did, but it doesn't.
- smt88 8y agoThere are a lot of places between "middle of nowhere" and NYC/NoVa...
- cabaalis 8y agoThe statements in this thread are the Hacker equivalents of "flyover country."
- wpietri 8y agoThis isn't an unreasonable generalization. But a) there's plenty of talent that wants to live somewhere other than an urban core, and b) if Amazon opens an HQ in a place, that place will become a somewhere, and c) Amazon is at the scale that they can afford to take raw talent and train it up. Personally, I find Amazon's decision disappointing, and I regret getting caught up in the hype. I was hoping that they'd do something bold and interesting, not open a couple of satellite offices in obvious places.
- ghaff 8y ago>there's plenty of talent that wants to live somewhere other than an urban core That's true. Although I'm not sure you can build a campus on this scale that doesn't need to function as an urban core in at least some respects. I'm not sure how you plop something like this down on a prairie someplace and expect it to function. (Especially given that employees may not want to live in an urban core but don't necessarily want to live in a company town in the middle of nowhere.) I agree that, if something like this is as reported, it's sort of a boring outcome in that it was entirely expected and safe.
- jacques_chester 8y agoA lot of people want to live in NYC, that's why it's so expensive to live in NYC. Amazon cannot replicate NYC in the middle of nowhere, or even the middle of somewhere. The confluence of geography, history, commerce, culture and sheer verve can't be bought.
- zemo 8y agothis is insanely tone-deaf. they're moving existing employees there. People don't want to live in the middle of nowhere. People don't want to be moved without their consent to start a new society. This is painfully, ridiculously obvious if you stop thinking about people as numbers and start thinking about them as actual humans living full lives.
- wpietri 8y agoPeople don't want to be moved without their consent, period. It doesn't matter where the new office is. There are plenty of people who do want to live in the middle of nowhere. I know a number of techies who have taken advantage of remote opportunities to finally live where they want, and at a much better price. And one could reasonably describe the whole trend of suburbanization as people moving to the middle of nowhere, so I suspect Amazon could find plenty of people who'd like a reasonably priced, new-built home in an up-and-coming area.
- tjr225 8y agoThere are plenty of people who want to do basically anything you can imagine. Statistically, we are as a society, drifting closer to urban cores. I too dream of buying 50 acres in the midwest for about 100k or so - so don't get me wrong I get the appeal. It's just more or less not what is happening. > And one could reasonably describe the whole trend of suburbanization as people moving to the middle of nowhere, I disagree with this. Suburbanization is a way for people to live close to urban centers with the employment prospects (although with a commute, contributing to congestion, emissions), without the benefits (and negatives) of living in an urban core. I have never been to a suburb that is in the middle of nowhere...if it was it wouldn't be sub-urban.
- umanwizard 8y agoA lot of the Southwest directly contradicts your point: huge, almost endless tracts of suburbia with no urban core whatsoever. Phoenix (4.7MM people in the metro area, virtually no downtown) is the quintessential example.
- murph-almighty 8y agoI'm of the opinion they could have used Newark, NJ in lieu of LIC and had basically the same experience but cheaper. Newark is maybe 30 minutes from Manhattan by train, has cheaper real estate, and contains a stop on the Amtrak NE Regional Line, which would allow access to their VA HQ in between 2-3 hours. I'm probably biased because I'm NJ based and I want Newark to become a more attractive location to companies other than Prudential, but Newark was up for consideration and I'd argue the cheap real estate + proximity to NY combo is workable.