8 ms·
Emissions-free energy system saves heat from the summer sun for winter
- gus_massa 8y agoIt's weird that the article has no data about the molecule. You can find it in the research articles "linked" at the bottom.
- mchannon 8y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norbornadiene https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norbornadiene Wikipedia has a pretty thorough chemical description. Fascinating, really.
- symplee 8y agoThese liquid Norbornadiene Photoswitches have an energy storage density of up to .559 MJ/kg.[1] For comparison: Mechanical Flywheel- 0.36–0.5 Lithium-ion battery- 0.36–0.875 etc...[2] [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04230-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04230-8 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#Energy_densities_of_common_energy_storage_materials https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#Energy_densitie...
- verelo 8y agoSo, it's as good as a "good" flywheel? or as good as a middle of the road lithium-ion battery? That's interesting!
- sjburt 8y agoIf so, storing a season's worth of heat might not be so feasible. A home in northern Europe needs about 30,000 MJ, so that would be 53,000 kg of norbornadeine. If the system absorbs energy during the day and releases energy at night, it might work with quite a bit less (maybe only a few hundred kg). It's interesting that the article doesn't suggest that. I wonder if there is a reason that wouldn't work--not enough solar energy in the winter, perhaps?
- jws 8y agoYour solar collectors will still be pulling in 1/3 of summer sun in the middle of winter (rough estimate, varies by latitude and weather, void above arctic circle). At the edges of winter you’d even be gaining energy still, so let’s say 40,000kg. That fits in an underground tank typically used by gasoline stations and could be filled by two tank trucks. Sounds doable in the scheme of new house construction, subject to the cost of the chemical of course. But, I have to think that if space is available, increasing the collector area to gather more winter energy and reducing the inventory of chemical and energy would make more sense. In the summer you could sell your saturated chemical to industry and have them replace it with unsaturated to offset your panel cost. Of course now that I have introduced shipping… who wants to live in a shiny reflector farm? Cover industrial buildings and car parks with reflectors, ship or pipe the chemical to houses and have a nicer domestic landscape. I wonder if there are degradation issues? They make a point of being able to store for 18 years which probably only interests survivalists, but make no mention of cycle limits.
- extrapickles 8y agoAssuming the at-scale cost is similar to gasoline, it would cost ~$75k just for that much material. If you assume the useful life is 18 years, you would have to spend >$347/mo on heating/cooling for it to be worth it.
- jvanderbot 8y agoYou're suggesting buying pre-charged sun juice? That seems less helpful. TFA suggested you can have much less by recharging it, and did not suggest the fluid expires ever (suggested otherwise, actually). It holds energy for 18 years, but can be used in cycle forever.
- m_eiman 8y agoA home in northern Europe needs about 30,000 MJ Really? We live in central Sweden, just outside Gothenburg. According to the estimate from our power company, our house uses about 15,000 MJ per year - and we have a single floor 200 square meter house. It's rated "C" in energy efficiency (which is the minimum rate allowed for new housing now).
- beefield 8y agoDo I calculate right that plain water stores energy around 0.2 MJ/kg when heated by 50 degrees celsius? (Specific heat is 4 J/gK) If I am right, ot feels like it would likely be cheaper to just make seasonal heat storages with water.
- Someone 8y agohttps://www.ecovat.eu/?lang=en https://www.ecovat.eu/?lang=en aims for water of 90 degrees Celsius (a 70 degree difference with room temperature), and claims heat can be stored with 95% efficiency (possibly exaggerated; the site also says ‘over 90%’) for more than 6 months in a tank 16m deep and 13m in diameter.
- hinkley 8y agoAnd if it leaks into the groundwater you only have to worry about the anti fouling agents you put into the tank, and anything leaching out of the tank lining.
- endymi0n 8y agoAre you sure they're talking about the same thing? Norbornadiene has a formula of C7H8, while the OP team's molecule is composed of "carbon, hydrogen and nitrogen". But thanks for posting some context on current research anyway!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gus_massa 8y agoIIUC the good part of these molecules is that the energy storage is very stable. With a flywheel the friction will stop it in a few ¿hours/days? The batteries also discharge too fast to store the energy for months. In other comment, someone else proposed to store the energy in hot water, but it's also difficult to keep the hot water for too long.
- jpollock 8y agoMy first thought was about Drake Landing in Alberta. They use heat pumps and store excess summer heat in the ground for use during the winter[1]. Nifty that this is a new molecule for long-term rather than seasonal storage. [1] https://www.dlsc.ca/ https://www.dlsc.ca/
- pfdietz 8y agoA long term storage system has to have very low capital cost, as it doesn't have many cycles over which to amortize that cost. I doubt this system makes any economic sense.
- ianai 8y agoTrying to figure out marginal cost. I think some part of it uses coal tar as a precursor. It might actually be pretty cheap and/or the US may have a comparative advantage given how much coal it has.
- jvanderbot 8y agoThe revolution isn't as long term storage, it's as a closed cycle, carbon neutral, solar-powered energy capacitor with relatively high capacity per kg. Long term storage is just nice to have.
- skookumchuck 8y agoYou can do the same thing today simply by burying tubes in the ground, at least 6 feet down. The ground is cooler in the summer than the air, and warmer in the winter. This can pre-heat and pre-cool air for your HVAC system. It's been around a long time, I'm surprised almost nobody uses it.
- masonic 8y agoNo risk from radon gas?
- skookumchuck 8y agoNo, the tubes exchange heat with the soil, not air. If mildew is a problem, you can run coolant instead through the tubes, with a heat exchanger in the building.
- MertsA 8y agoThere would be an increase in the amount of Radon pulled out of the ground. Usually the way an HVAC system is set up is that you have the filter, then the evaporator coils, then the fan, then the ducts to the rest of the building. To heat or cool the air the tubes would need to be placed before the evaporator coils or it would just be wasting energy instead of saving energy. This also puts it before the fan. Everything before the fan is at a negative relative pressure and everything after it is positively pressurized. Presumably those tubes aren't perfectly sealed so the negative pressure will draw in a tiny bit of Radon from the ground. You could flip things around and move the fan to right after the filter and before the tubes and evaporator coils, I'm not 100% sure why that isn't normally done but all of the residential HVAC units I'm familiar with are done this way so there's probably a reason.
- stjohnswarts 8y agoI can't personally because 8 inches down is solid rock. To remove all that rock would cost a fortune to get down to 6feet.
- ianai 8y ago
- anon1253 8y agoDoes anyone know of similar technology for the inverse? Saving cold from the winter for the summer? With hotter summers and more extreme temperature swings to be expected, it might cut costs on running the AC's
- foxhop 8y agoResearch thermal mass storage. Basically fill your house with heavy stuff and then insulate the outside walls well. It works for both winter heating and summer cooling
- jmkd 8y agoFor thousands of years ice and snow have been gathered in winter and stored for various summer usages in purpose-built structures, ideally underground: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_house_(building) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_house_(building)
- mrfusion 8y agoCan this also store heat from electricity? If so I’m wondering if this couldnrevolutionitize the lowly water heater. I believe they use a lot of energy just keeping their tanks at the right temp.
- foxhop 8y agoI'm the process of building a "breadbox" + coldframe hybrid to warm hot water using the sun. Similar design: https://youtu.be/tqUwBwfN5iE https://youtu.be/tqUwBwfN5iE
- finnh 8y ago> He hopes that the research group will shortly achieve a temperature increase of at least 110°Celsius .. So, enough to boil water? Once you can execute a phase change you can generate electricity, not just heat....