2 ms·
Not being production systems means entire subsystems are omitted. No tritium breeding blankets, no robotic maintenance systems, not extremely high efficiency t
by pfdietz 8y ago
Not being production systems means entire subsystems are omitted. No tritium breeding blankets, no robotic maintenance systems, not extremely high efficiency tritium purification and recovery systems. Research reactors don't need the materials that could withstand the extreme neutron loading a production reactor would be exposed to. And they don't need to be reliable enough to operate with a high enough capacity factor to pay off the investment, as a production reactor would have to.
As you scale up the power of a fusion reactor, the volumetric power density goes DOWN. This is because it becomes limited by the power/area through the first wall. Square/cube law in action.
- Retric 8y ago> no robotic maintenance systems ... neutron load. ITER has full remote handling as it's expected to get extremely radioactive. Scaling reactors up does not really mean increasing the neutron load on the walls as you want to keep that fairly steady per surface area. Tritium production has ~zero impact on operation. The breeding blankets are really simple, you take lithium and enclose it in a metal of some type. Replace after a few months. Also, a ~10x device is unlikely to be 50-50 DT as while hard to operate on pure DD fusion it's not that hard to get when you have some tritium in the mix.
- pfdietz 8y agoRetric: a production reactor would need robots capable of replacing the entire first wall every few years. ITER will not have anything like that.
- Retric 8y agoITER remote maintenance system (IRMS) is specifically designed to do just that: http://users.isr.ist.utl.pt/~mir/pub/SOFT_RHSystemsForITER_IRibeiro-PlenaryTalk.pdf http://users.isr.ist.utl.pt/~mir/pub/SOFT_RHSystemsForITER_I... It's not designed to replace everything, but I doubt commercial designs would go that far either.
- DennisP 8y agoMIT's ARC is designed to make that easy. The reactor opens right up and you just lift out the inner wall and drop in a new one. They've already tested joints in the REBCO tape, and found that they introduce very little electrical resistance.