4 ms·
World annual production of Be is just 220 tonnes. A single ARC reactor would use 40% of this. The total world Be resource is estimated at 100,000 tonnes, and
by pfdietz 8y ago
World annual production of Be is just 220 tonnes.
A single ARC reactor would use 40% of this.
The total world Be resource is estimated at 100,000 tonnes, and if fully used in ARC reactors would supply just 1% of the world's primary energy demand.
- philipkglass 8y agoIn mining parlance a resource is a function of economic demand as well as geology. Elements with limited demand may have "resource" levels far lower than those in regular industrial use, even if ore bodies of comparable grades actually exist for both. Uranium was produced at a level of only hundreds of tonnes per year before the development of nuclear weapons and reactors. Now it is produced in quantities of tens of thousands of tonnes per year. Obviously the terrestrial geology of uranium did not change quickly; industrial demand is what changed. Uranium's crustal abundance is comparable to that of beryllium. Despite cumulative production of more than 2.2 million tonnes uranium through 2003, additions to resource totals have kept pace with production so that overall resource levels have remained level or have increased over time. The ratio between Known Conventional Resources and reactor-related uranium requirements in 2003 was 52 compared to an average of 47 since 1985. ... Uranium production in 1945 is estimated to have totaled 507 tonnes uranium. By 1965, when the first Red Book was published, production totaled 31,564 tonnes. Production peaked in 1980 at 69,692 tonnes from 22 countries. In 2003, uranium production was reported by 19 countries with output totaling 35,492 tonnes. Cumulative worldwide uranium production between 1945 and 2003 totaled 2,204,732 tonnes... "Forty Years of Uranium Resources, Production and Demand in Perspective: The Red Book Retrospective" https://www.oecd-nea.org/ndd/pubs/2006/6096-40-years-uranium.pdf https://www.oecd-nea.org/ndd/pubs/2006/6096-40-years-uranium... It's a fair point that beryllium exploration and extraction would have to increase tremendously for routine construction of these reactors. But putting 100,000 tonnes of beryllium in ARC reactors would not mean that the Earth has then run out of beryllium.
- pfdietz 8y agoHowever, expanding the total resource of Be by a factor of 100 would likely mean a large increase in the price of the element.
- starbeast 8y agoWouldn't economies of scale push in the opposite direction?
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoNo. At price X, there are Y tons that are economically extractable; at price 2X there are more than Y tons that are economically extractable. If you want more than Y tons of it, the price is going to have to be more than X.
- starbeast 8y agoIf there is low demand for something, then there is low production and the production costs are high per unit. High demand will at first push the price up, but if there is ability to scale production of the resource, the price per unit should then come down, as the production costs per unit will drop due to economies of scale.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoTrue, but in resource production, that rarely is what dominates. The problem is that, as you try to produce more, you're having to process ore that has lower and lower concentrations of whatever you're trying to extract. You can get a more efficient facility if you have the volume, but the lower concentration (usually) dominates, and so the cost goes up rather than down.
- starbeast 8y agoI don't think your analysis here is right. If you look at the history of the price for aluminium, it has steadily dropped as production has risen, which is the opposite of what you are saying. And to pick another metal, the lowest copper price of the last 100 years was around the year 2000.
- jabl 8y agoCouldn't one use, say, FLiNaK instead of FLiBe? Sodium and potassium are pretty abundant. That of course leaves the problem of needing relatively large amounts of 6Li, but that's something one has to live with as long as one wants DT fusion, I guess. And it seems this is more with building up the enrichment capacity rather than some fundamental geological limits.
- pfdietz 8y agoBeryllium is needed for neutron multiplication. The 5th neutron in 9Be is the most weakly bound neutron in any stable isotope, with a binding energy of just 1.6 MeV. It might be possible to use lead for neutron multiplication (it has a nice high cross section for (n,2n) reactions above 8 MeV), but it would not moderate the neutrons much, and 6Li breeds best off thermal neutrons. So the blanket and reactor would have to be bigger.