8 ms·
>On the flip side, many black hole experts put no stock in the analogy and consider it potentially misleading, since it isn’t known whether Hawking’s math, upon
by adrianN 8y ago
>On the flip side, many black hole experts put no stock in the analogy and consider it potentially misleading, since it isn’t known whether Hawking’s math, upon which the analogy is based, actually does describe black holes.
That is the key issue. You can't do an experiment in a system X that can be described by similar math as system Y and conclude things about Y without first making sure that Y is actually behaving in the same way. These analogue experiments might be good tools to explore the consequences of the mathematics and come up with new theories, but in the end you only get results on system Y under the condition that your theories about it are correct. That doesn't sound too interesting, especially if you just confirm effects that you already derived theoretically. In that case you already know that if they behave according to your math then you'd see that effect.
- blueprint 8y agoDoes this not apply even to experimental result interpretation? e.g. One can argue that the GRACE satellite program didn't image gravity, but showed the theory and the effect of the theory.
- adrianN 8y agoSure, it has happened before that we found a different theory that's also compatible with the experimental evidence.