3 ms·
Show me on this doll of the org chart where the responsibility was abdicated. If you're a summer intern, sure, you can go home and feel good about getting extr
by pavel_lishin 8y ago
Show me on this doll of the org chart where the responsibility was abdicated.
If you're a summer intern, sure, you can go home and feel good about getting extra credit. If you're the CEO who pushes dark patterns and chooses to sacrifice security for profit, you should toss-and-turn at night. But at which point can we say, "you, the person who knowingly implemented this piece of shit pattern that enables malware to be delivered straight into my machine, did a bad thing, and are personally culpable"?
- whatshisface 8y ago>If you're a summer intern, sure, you can go home and feel good about getting extra credit. Unless the summer intern didn't accomplish a single thing, maybe not. I would say that you are guilty if you ordered something bad to be done, or carried out a bad order, and an accomplice to the guilty if you supported the actions of someone who was ordering or carrying out something bad.
- MRD85 8y agoAfter WW2 it was established that soldiers following orders were still guilty of crimes if they knew that their actions were unlawful. Following orders does not excuse guilt.
- esotericn 8y agoIt really depends what you mean by 'personally culpable'. I don't think anyone should have force used against them (e.g. prison time, fines). However, it's not only completely fair, but inevitable, that someone's actions influence how they're seen by others. If your job involves being an asshole, then it's completely unsurprising that people will see you as an asshole. Because you are one. The fact someone pays you to do it is immaterial. You're not an actor at work, your actions have consequences in the world we all live in.
- pavel_lishin 8y agoMaybe I should have said "ethically" or "morally" instead of personally. I'm not suggesting we ride people out of town on a rail, or tar and feather them, but I definitely agree that if you work for an asshole company doing asshole things, that makes you an asshole, with all the social consequences that follow the label.
- egypturnash 8y ago“I was only following orders”
- anigbrowl 8y agoIf you're the person without whom the project can't go ahead or will suffer a major inconvenience (at worst, filling your position with someone else) then you get part of the collective responsibility.
- pavel_lishin 8y agoIf you write code you know will harm people, you get part of the collective responsibility, no matter how much of a cog you are.
- anigbrowl 8y agoYeah I didn't put that very clearly but I agree.