3 ms·
There is no single universally agreed definition of the term "free will". So, it is possible to define "free will" in such a way that it is compatible with det
by skissane 8y ago
There is no single universally agreed definition of the term "free will".
So, it is possible to define "free will" in such a way that it is compatible with determinism (e.g., "my will is free if its decisions are the product of my ordinary processes of thinking–even if those ordinary processes are determined by natural laws–as opposed to the product of any extraordinary external interference such as drugs, brainwashing, mind control implants, etc").
Part of the dispute is over whether such a definition of "free will" matches people's everyday pre-philosophical usage, and also whether it works for the purposes of other disciplines in which the concept of "free will" might be invoked, such as ethics or law. Compatibilists would say it is close enough, and can be made to work for those purposes. Incompatibilists say it is a radical redefinition, and undermines those purposes.
- MrScruff 8y agoSo it seems the crux of the matter is how we regard the process of a person making a decision. A compatibilist would say that for the purposes of discussion we describe this event as the exercising of will, even though from a physics perspective the outcome could be predetermined. Is that correct? If so that seems similar to a recent discussion on Bohr's view of the irreducibility of biology to physics. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18104508 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18104508
- skissane 8y agoCertainly that's one way a compatibilist could put it – that "free will" is part of psychology, which ultimately reduces to/emerges from/supervenes upon lower layers of biology/chemistry/physics which may be fundamentally deterministic. (Although exactly how deterministic they are may depend on which interpretation of quantum mechanics is correct.) A point worth adding – there are different forms of determinism. Physical determinism says people's decisions are predetermined by physical laws and initial conditions. Theological determinism says people's decisions are predetermined by God's will. A compatibilist could be either. (Although most compatibilists you'll encounter these days are in the physical not theological camp.)
- naasking 8y agoI think you pretty fairly describe the current landscape of this debate, which is unusual in itself. Kudos! > Part of the dispute is over whether such a definition of "free will" matches people's everyday pre-philosophical usage, and also whether it works for the purposes of other disciplines in which the concept of "free will" might be invoked, such as ethics or law. Fortunately, this is an empirical question that has been explored by experimental philosophy [1]. It turns out that most lay people employ Compatibilist reasoning, so I think this question has also been answered. [1] The latest that I've seen on the topic: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/274892120_Why_Compatibilist_Intuitions_are_not_Mistaken_A_Reply_to_Feltz_and_Millan https://www.researchgate.net/publication/274892120_Why_Compa...
- fjsolwmv 8y agoLay people, yes, but lay people also believe in ghosts and angels. Lay people believing it doesn't make it true. Scientific reasoning shows compatibilism is inaccurate, But just how like how belief in an scientifically absurd afterife can make people happy, being scientifically correct is not equivalent to having a good life. And this is a potential definition of the essence religion or wait, properly opposed to science: faith can make you happy even when you are wrong, and losing that faith makes you unhappy. Therefore, having faith is the correct choice for an ideal human life. It's right to be wrong.
- naasking 8y ago> Lay people, yes, but lay people also believe in ghosts and angels. Lay people believing it doesn't make it true. I suggest you read the study and others like it. If you flat out ask people what they believe, with no further context, they tend to support incompatbilist intuitions. But when they test their responses to moral questions, they employ Compatibilist moral reasoning, and agree with claims that are Compatibilist.
- clairity 8y agoi'm leaning toward a belief in an outcome where we eventually prove strong determinism false, simply because of the probabalistic underpinnings of the universe. in that scenario, compatibalism would be an acceptance of a weak determinism based on the likeliness of probabalistic outcomes (particularly at larger scales), rather than an absolute certainty.