4 ms·
> I think computing science (not just software engineering) is slowly but surely becoming an essential part of many areas of modern physics research. I like to
by naasking 8y ago
> I think computing science (not just software engineering) is slowly but surely becoming an essential part of many areas of modern physics research.
I like to say that physics, mathematics, and computer science are the three pillars of human knowledge. There's some overlap between each pillar, and we don't yet fully understand how each of them fully relate to the others, but each is essential to gathering a full picture of any phenomenon.
- Engineering-MD 8y agoI think there must be more pillars than that. Biology and chemistry while related to physics are distinct (in the same way physics is not maths). More broadly, humanities and the arts are still valid areas of knowledge. Hacker news has a bias towards your three pillars, but I think it is important to acknowledge that human knowledge does go beyond CS, maths and physics.
- naasking 8y agoI disagree re: biology and chemistry. Certainly they are epistemically useful simplifications of the other pillars, but they are not foundational or fundamental. Physics is not math because it's an empirical rather than a priori exploration. We are trying to reproduce the function governing natural laws, where in mathematics we are exploring the properties of functions. Computer science in turn is concerned with the construction of mathematical structures via algorithms, and so physics will be one such construction. I think trying to place humanities and the arts under "knowledge" is a category error. These fields don't produce knowledge as its commonly understood, as a corpus of mind-independent facts and their relationships. Certainly facts appear in these fields, such as historical facts and authorship, but I don't think building a corpus of facts is not the main purpose.
- Koshkin 8y ago> simplifications of the other pillars This fallacy is called "reductionism."
- wnoise 8y agoIt's not universally accepted that it is fallacy. And for whatever it misses, reductionism is a hell of a tool that has been incredibly useful in understanding the world. Of course, so are chemistry and biology, so blithely dismissed in the parent comment.
- naasking 8y ago> Of course, so are chemistry and biology, so blithely dismissed in the parent comment. I didn't dismiss them at all, I explicitly said they are epistemically useful, but that doesn't entail we should accept them into our core ontology.
- naasking 8y agoIt's a philosophy not a fallacy: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/scientific-reduction/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/scientific-reduction/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lolitan 8y agoWrong. Philosophy and Mathematics are the real pillars of knowledge. Everything else can be derived from this including physics.
- minhazm423 8y agowould you care to elaborate?
- naasking 8y agoPhilosophy doesn't really produce knowledge, it explores and frames questions. When we accept that the questions define a coherent domain of discourse, we create a field of study that does produce knowledge. This is how natural philosophy became science, and if ethics ever gets to this point, we'll get a moral science which will produce moral knowledge. Ethics doesn't currently produce moral knowledge.
- kybian 8y agoAnd that's the problem with living in a philistinic society. When people think the sciences are the only noteworthy achievements of human intellect.