3 ms·
The thing I find most obnoxious is the "a better end naturally justifies removing liberties" concept. Suppose there was positive correlation between racial div
by paulddraper 8y ago
The thing I find most obnoxious is the "a better end naturally justifies removing liberties" concept.
Suppose there was positive correlation between racial diversity and violent crime in the US. Would you support de jure segregation, because it reduces violence? Even if there seem to be good effects from segregation didn't necessarily mean the government should dictate living locations.
Even if there are good effects from legislated prices, that doesn't necessarily mean the government should dictate employment contacts.
- elicash 8y agoI find it obnoxious to say "yes, a minimum wage makes for a better society overall but I'm going to take a principled stand because ideologically I'm opposed to forcing employers to pay a living wage." Seems silly to me. If I think something will make society better, I'm in favor of it. > Even if there seem to be good effects from segregation didn't necessarily mean the government should dictate living locations. To be clear, you're NOT saying there are good effects of segregation, right? That was just an example to illustrate a point? Because I see zero positives from segregation.
- goalieca 8y agoYour argument is moronic. De-segregation is not the cause of violence in your hypothetical and if it was then you were imagining a racist dreamland.
- paulddraper 8y agoIt's a (negative) example. It's supposed to be moronic.
- davvolun 8y agoTo play devil's advocate (you can read my response to OP to see how I feel generally about the overall argument), it does seem to correlate that more homogeneous societies, e.g. Japan, Norway, have lower crime statistics, or lower violent crimes. Possible reason being, the more likely you are able to socially connect with your potential victim and the less likely you are to see them as the "other," then the less likely you are to feel justified in causing them harm. KKK feels justified because other races are inferior, the rich feel justified in exploiting the poor because poor people are lazy, e.g.
- paulddraper 8y agoAnd you could find similar examples in the US as well. E.g, the least violent state (Maine) also is the least racially diverse. Like you say, it's not hard to believe that homogeneity (whether race, religion, culture, ethics, politics etc.) causes less conflict. Naturally, that's an awful justification for a terrible practice. But you find many tunnel-visioned "the statistics justify the means" arguments: minimum wage, gun control, privacy, etc. Proper laws are not just about statistically good outcomes.
- goalieca 8y agoCanada has a lower violent crime rate even in major city centres where diversity is crazy high.
- davvolun 8y agoAre you serious? That's almost the basis for our (U.S., Western) form of government. "Social contract arguments typically posit that individuals have consented, either explicitly or tacitly, to surrender some of their freedoms and submit to the authority of the ruler (or to the decision of a majority) in exchange for protection of their remaining rights." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_contract https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_contract The only thing you're actually arguing against is applying it mindlessly regardless of any other concerns, as in, the reduction of violent crime is sufficient in and of itself to be a "better end" -- in actual fact, we've seen separate but equal doesn't work. As an aside, look at people like Marcus Garvey. As an attempt to resolve the conflict in America between black and white, complete segregation has been seriously proposed; it was not (entirely) stopped or prevented due to ethical/moral arguments. As a slightly silly example, you have a family who has been living in a home for 100 years, but the neighborhood they live in has shifted. Perhaps you use eminent domain to remove them. Now multiply that by thousands -- will they all move peacefully? Where are you getting the money for this? etc. etc. > Even if there are good effects from legislated prices, that doesn't necessarily mean the government should dictate employment contacts. Doesn't necessarily mean it shouldn't either. I would argue the better solution would be mandatory union participation. Unions would equalize the power imbalance between the individual worker and, say, McDonald's, without the government dictating terms. But I'm guessing you, or people who also support your argument, would balk at that as well.
- paulddraper 8y ago> Where are you getting the money for this? etc. etc. A more plausible approach is discouraging immigration of heterogeneous population. Sound familiar?