5 ms·
I would say it can be because it makes ads manipulative. Think for example of the Axe ads that try to tell people that the deodorant will turn them into attract
by Barrin92 8y ago
I would say it can be because it makes ads manipulative. Think for example of the Axe ads that try to tell people that the deodorant will turn them into attractive romantic partners, I don't think that's very likely.
Advertisement in a good sense increases the information a consumer has about a product, and would help a consumer make a more accurate choice. Advertisement that just plays to the lizard part of our brains accomplishes the opposite.
The entire advertisement industry is basically a hundreds of billions dollar experiment on how to reshape human attention. If a group of scientists or a government would run an experiment of that size on the human cognition, people would probably be very concerned.
- chrisseaton 8y agoHow do you think a reputable perfume manufacturer should advertise their product? Should they not? What dry information can they give you about their product to better inform you with images and audio alone?
- chongli 8y agoI don't think people need perfume, thank you. The fact that a perfume manufacturer is "reputable" has more to do with the efforts of their marketing department than it does with any sort of merit.
- chrisseaton 8y agoI think this is such an extreme and oppressive vision of society that it's probably not worth trying to debate it with you.
- chongli 8y agoOppressive? Did I say we should ban perfume or perfume manufacturers? No. Just because I think they're unethical doesn't mean I think they should be illegal.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chongli 8y agoReplying to myself because chrisseaton deleted his own post: Nothing of the sort. I didn't say anybody should be banned from doing any sort of marketing. I merely said that I think people don't need perfume and that the sort of marketing in these industries is unethical. Convincing people they need something they never knew they needed through psychological manipulation is unethical, period. It happens all over society and it's really too bad. But trying to ban it would create a dystopian society which is arguably worse. There are more than 2 options for dealing with unethical behaviour, apart from "lock them up and throw away the key" and "let them run amok, doing whatever they want", there is the possibility of rational debate. The vast majority of the time, I choose the third option. If my (hypothetical, future) daughter wanted to buy a bottle of perfume, I wouldn't forbid her from doing so, I'd talk to her about marketing and beauty standards and so on. I'd try to persuade her that she's a perfectly good person without needing a product like that to augment her.
- ruseOps 8y agoThis hypothetical daughter stops you mid- well-intentioned lecture, smiles comfortingly - places her hand gently your shoulder, and says, “Dad - it’s okay. I just bought it because it smells good.” Do you believe her? How do you respond?
- brandonmenc 8y ago>If my (hypothetical, future) daughter wanted to buy a bottle of perfume, I wouldn't forbid her from doing so, I'd talk to her about marketing and beauty standards and so on. Some (most?) of us wear perfume because we like to be enveloped by a pleasant scent - it's for ourselves as much as it's to "impress" others.
- dweekly 8y agoSniff strips (in pretty much every fashion magazine) are the obvious answer here. Unlike most products, the actual end-product itself can be shipped inside a magazine. If you like the smell, there's an obvious paid action to take. If you don't, you're at least informed that it's not right for you. Perfume advertising with samples is one of the most direct and pure forms of advertising I can think of: pure information and pure product.
- avar 8y agoThe GP is talking about deodorant, not perfume. The main selling point of deodorant isn't how it smells, but how it makes you not smell. That's not something you can ship as a sniff strip. Besides of course the obvious issue with the target market of a "manly deodorant" line having almost no overlap with people who read fashion magazines.
- wild_preference 8y agoYou'd have a point if the deodorant in question here was scentless, but it's not. It heavily markets its fragrance, like its ability to supposedly attract hot women. It's absolutely a deodorant + perfume combo, and primarily the latter from my experience as a niño. Go smell some Axe next time you're in Walmart and see for yourself. Or smell a junior high boy's locker room.
- aylmao 8y agoWhich makes me wonder, is deodorant something that should be advertised at all? If your deodorant has some new unique property, etc, then it makes sense to advertise that. And I remember deodorants that did advertise they were careful on the skin, or didn't stain your shirt, were "invisible", longer-lasting, etc. But if deodorant development has reached a point of stagnation, where no new deodorant tech is being invented and all deodorants are essentially the same, then we're in an interesting economic arrangement. Macro-economically speaking, is this a company or industry that should keep on growing? The point of capitalism was supposed to be that there was competition in R&D (which brought about progress) and margins (which brought about availability through affordability) and eventually things like the ballpoint pen came to be: ubiquitous products that are extremely cheap and effective at what they do. You don't see advertisements for the ballpoint pen any more: it's period of R&D and cheapening are long past. The industry is mature, it's done developing and is now producing a steady supply of ballpoint pens for a steady number of employees making a living off of it. It's just companies today seem addicted to unbound growth and have discovered that R&D and margins aside, they can use advertising to sell more of anything by meddling with emotions.
- sincerely 8y agoLook at how websites describe scents: e.g. https://www.luckyscent.com/product/21631/black-by-comme-des-garcons https://www.luckyscent.com/product/21631/black-by-comme-des-... >Notes: Cedarwood, vetiver, leather, liquorice, birch tar, pepperwood, black pepper, incense This is the information people who are buying perfume (for reasons other than brand image) actually care about. Sure, there's a lot of other marketing text there, but literally none of that information is in perfume ads (without sniff strips).
- aylmao 8y agoThis is part of why the concept of the free market economy makes little sense to me. The free market revolves around the idea that eventually bad players lose and good players selling what's best for the consumer win. Rational buyers buy what's best, so producers have to adapt to that. But if the sale of your product depends not on its quality, or its benefit, and is so influenced by a "gut feeling" and irrational association of your brand to an idea, then what gives? The whole thing devolves into "who can advertise best" instead of "who can build the best thing". Which is actually largely what we are seeing is happening. Both in industry and in politics. In industry some of the biggest companies in the world live off of ads. This is crazy if you think about it. So much of the internet, TV, radio-- these huge infrastructure and production projects employing thousands upon thousands, producing billions of dollars. Google, Facebook, other SV companies employing some of the brightest minds solving some of the biggest SW engineering challenges-- exist off of the value people put to ads. In politics, it's all increasingly about advertising a feeling and less about the product (policy). Is it that strange that the guy who had the most air-time, shook people the most, and has most experience with being a screen personality won the last US presidential elections, when the population has, thought the years, learned to be susceptible to gut-advertising via constant, steady bombardment from the advertising industry? I've concluded this is what a free market economy gets you, because as a company or producer optimizing for survival doesn't mean optimizing for being the best out there, just "seeming" the best.
- bcgraham 8y agoIn every economy, companies optimize for survival by "seeming" the best. The only part that changes is the audience to which it seems.