3 ms·
Seems a funny thing to moralise over. Is it a problem?
by chrisseaton 8y ago
Seems a funny thing to moralise over. Is it a problem?
- mrob 8y agoThe usual excuse for advertising being morally acceptable is that it informs potential customers about the product. If it has nothing to do with the product then its only possible purpose is deception.
- chrisseaton 8y agoIf an advert doesn’t mention the product it seems very hard to say that it’s deveiving you about what the product will do, doesn’t it?
- chongli 8y agoIt's deceiving you in a far less obvious and ham-fisted way: it's associating a brand with your lifestyle and your identity. It's using insights gained from psychology research to try to hack your brain into thinking that this brand is part of your tribe. And it works. To an obscene degree, really.
- gingerbread-man 8y agoThe iconic "1984" Apple ad was about as abstract as anything on today's screens. It did tell users about the product, indirectly, by telling them about the values of the Apple brand and company. And I'd much prefer to watch that than the harrowing "Head-On: Apply directly to the forehead" commercial.
- masonic 8y agotelling them about the values of the Apple brand and company It was ad genius but said nothing about any Apple "values". It instead attacked the IBM/DOS world as an Orwellian nightmare disrupted by a hot, busty female. It was about destruction, not "values".
- wutbrodo 8y ago> And I'd much prefer to watch that than the harrowing "Head-On: Apply directly to the forehead" commercial. Haha that commercial is so entertaining in its absurdism
- feri339 8y agoI wouldn't say deception. It's more a manipulation. I'm sure there are hundreds studies in neuroscience and behavioral economics that tell advertisers exactly which buttons to push. Most ads, especially brand advertisement aren't supposed to effect an immediate reaction. Way down the line they may influence you subconsciously though.
- ionised 8y ago> The usual excuse for advertising being morally acceptable is that it informs potential customers about the product. And it's a bullshit excuse at that. Advertising uses concepts developed in propaganda and psychological warfare to play on human insecurities in order to make them feel inadequate without your product.
- Barrin92 8y agoI would say it can be because it makes ads manipulative. Think for example of the Axe ads that try to tell people that the deodorant will turn them into attractive romantic partners, I don't think that's very likely. Advertisement in a good sense increases the information a consumer has about a product, and would help a consumer make a more accurate choice. Advertisement that just plays to the lizard part of our brains accomplishes the opposite. The entire advertisement industry is basically a hundreds of billions dollar experiment on how to reshape human attention. If a group of scientists or a government would run an experiment of that size on the human cognition, people would probably be very concerned.
- chrisseaton 8y agoHow do you think a reputable perfume manufacturer should advertise their product? Should they not? What dry information can they give you about their product to better inform you with images and audio alone?
- chongli 8y agoI don't think people need perfume, thank you. The fact that a perfume manufacturer is "reputable" has more to do with the efforts of their marketing department than it does with any sort of merit.
- chrisseaton 8y agoI think this is such an extreme and oppressive vision of society that it's probably not worth trying to debate it with you.
- chongli 8y agoOppressive? Did I say we should ban perfume or perfume manufacturers? No. Just because I think they're unethical doesn't mean I think they should be illegal.
- deleted 8y ago
- BurritoAlPastor 8y agoSure. The simplest, and in my view strongest, argument for why we as a society should accept and tolerate advertising is that it provides a mechanism for consumers to learn about things they want. But, if you accept that, then you have to deal with this problem: why do we still allow advertising which cannot inform? Like, what societal value is provided by an ad for your local power utility? Either you already knew about them, or you don’t need to know about them. Conversely, what value is presented by an ad which is designed to not inform me about anything?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> The simplest, and in my view strongest, argument for why we as a society should accept and tolerate advertising is that it provides a mechanism for consumers to learn about things they want. This is a solid argument, but it's used mostly as motte-and-bailey, a bait-and-switch. Ads are important because they are the mechanism for product discovery. But in reality, most ads are not like that - they're no longer about discovery, but about shifting where the spending goes. Personally, I'd be fine if all ads except purely discovery-related were to disappear.
- bredren 8y agoNo matter his personal practices, this guy was basically a secular saint. So I personally do think it matters that his name and image would be used to sell smartphones. I realize the production company has a good sized staff, a board and ambitions to carry on their mission. But paying for it this way looks cheap and like they aren’t really trying. Given the weight and voice of this brand I suspect they could have earned just as much through some kind of crowdfund. I think it is a bad sign of things to come w regard to the use of me Rogers content, unfortunately. This taps into a bigger question about the use of a dead persons name and image to make money. This came up when Kurt Cobain was made to sing any song on Rock Band a few years ago: https://www.alistdaily.com/media/bon-jovi-weighs-in-on-cobain-guitar-hero-controversy/ https://www.alistdaily.com/media/bon-jovi-weighs-in-on-cobai... While I carry no celebrity, it would matter to me if my name and image were exploited in a way that was against my values. One of the things that supposedly sets us apart from “animals” is that we have respect for and bury our dead. I’d say that foundations, organizations or “estates” that need to exploit the persons image for financial reasons fail to meet this test.