4 ms·
So then big corps do all their customer information risking behavior in spun out small wholly owned subsidiaries or even arms length non owned ones and if succe
by gigatexal 8y ago
So then big corps do all their customer information risking behavior in spun out small wholly owned subsidiaries or even arms length non owned ones and if successful acquire them for some fixed amount but if they screw up with this law the company just folds and the parent is free from financial damage.
- codegeek 8y agoI am not an expert bill reader but seems like this loophole is covered as there is another point that says : "(ii) is not substantially owned, oper ated, or controlled by a person, partner ship, or corporation that does not meet the 6 requirements under clause"
- r00fus 8y agoContracting it out still seems to bypass the regulation
- setr 8y agoTbh thats still a better outcome than the status quo isn’t it: a single hack is now limited in damage, and multiple are required to do the equivalent of todays scenarios
- CamelCaseName 8y agoWhat if everyone contracts out the data collection to a single party? Only giving the data a larger exposure. I'm really glad this is coming to light and I hope it passes. It will be very interesting to see how companies try to avoid it, but at first glance, it seems well thought out.
- kissickas 8y agoIf that company has 1,000,000 or more customers' data, then they're no longer exempt. Maybe you came in after the OOP did their edit.
- hessenwolf 8y ago“Controlled”
- vkou 8y agoGenerally speaking, judges and juries aren't idiots, and you can't hack around laws by claiming that your dog did it.
- jacques_chester 8y agoSoftware engineers tend to assume that (a) they are the smartest in the room, (b) legislation is exactly like code, (c) caselaw doesn't exist and (d) nobody has ever had to write complex rules before software was invented. All of which, we feel, qualifies us to poke holes in any legislation we happen to stumble across. But, of course, it doesn't. Not even close. By way of analogy, if someone looked at a link to a github repo and said "yeah well I can't see any GOTO 10 lines, I bet this will crash when the IP trace becomes Apache'd" I hope someone would be patient and polite in explaining the several levels of wrongness involved.
- zaarn 8y agoThere are jurisdictions were caselaw doesn't exist (which a lot of software engineers also conveniently forget a lot of the time) or law is written differently from the anglo-american legislations (which software engineers also conveniently forget a lot)
- jacques_chester 8y agoThat the doctrinal basis is different does not change that law requires interpretation by experts using something more sophisticated than "it's just code". Civil jurisdictions don't have caselaw as an independent source of legal rules, but they still have cases and they still have interpretation. It is not uncommon for an ancient Roman jurist's opinion to be cited in argument in Scots law, just as it is not uncommon to cite very old English cases in Australian law. And it is also common to have civil codes in common law jurisdictions -- the criminal law I was taught was based on a statutory instrument which asserted itself to be the whole of the criminal law and which was frequently amended whenever courts began to accrete rulings around it.
- fjsolwmv 8y ago