3 ms·
To add to what others said about it being somewhat arbitrary, it should be noted that in different time and places other definitions have been used. Each of the
by tzs 8y ago
To add to what others said about it being somewhat arbitrary, it should be noted that in different time and places other definitions have been used. Each of the following sets has been "the primes" to mathematicians at some time/place:
P1 = {1, 2, 3, 5, 7, 11, ...}
P2 = {2, 3, 5, 7, 11, ...}
P3 = {3, 5, 7, 11, ...}
The underlying mathematics is the same no matter which of those you call "the primes". All that really changes is what you then have to say when you want a specific one of those sets.
If P1 is "the primes", and your theorem needs a p that is a member of a specific one of those sets, you have to say "Let p be...":
P1: "...a prime"
P2: "...a prime other than 1"
P3: "...an odd prime"
If P2 is "the primes", it is:
P1: "...1 or a prime"
P2: "...a prime"
P3: "...an odd prime"
If P3 is "the primes" for you, it is:
P1: "...1, 2, or a prime"
P2: "...2 or a prime"
P3: "...a prime"
Given the state of mathematics since the 19th century, P2 as the "primes" probably results in the minimum verbiage.
I don't think anyone has used P3 in a very long time, so unless you are studying ancient math history you probably will never encounter anything using it.
P1 and P2 were used together up until at least the 18th century, with some mathematicians using P1 even longer, but pretty much everything you will encounter now will use P2.
Even is a book you might read now says it is presenting the historical proof of some theorem as it was originally proven, and that proof has done by someone who used P1 as "the primes" in the proof, the book will almost certainly reword it to be for P2 prime.
You will probably only ever have a chance of running into P1 primes if you actually go to original sources, finding copies the actual books or articles or papers of mathematicians from back when many used P1 primes.